-
As I've said before, although it's better than anything else I've ever tried, I'm not yet quite satisfied with FVP,
I think the problem is with the question, and I'm very conscious that a small variation in wording can make a big difference in practice.
Currently I'm trying out "What should be done before x?", and so far (a couple of days) it's producing excellent results. I'll keep you informed!
17 August 2015 at 9:14 | Mark Forster
-
Isn't that close to the original FV question, "What do I want to do before I do x?"
17 August 2015 at 10:55 | nuntym
-
nuntym:
No, I don't think it's in the least bit close to it. It's almost the complete opposite.
17 August 2015 at 11:57 | Mark Forster
-
Yes please let us know the results!
I find this fascinating. I've found that even little "mental nudges" (applying the ideas in your Dotting Power blog post) can make a big difference.
17 August 2015 at 14:51 | Seraphim
-
Very interesting!
I understand "want to" and "should" as opposites, because I have always experienced them as bitter rivals. Of course there is mostly overlap between what I want to do and what I "should" do, but the things that don't overlap caused real stress in AF1. (Not in FVP, because I never have to weigh a "want" directly against a "should." There are always options that are both wanted and shouldful.) (I can't think of the word that I mean for "shouldful.")
But because the two questions are practically opposites, I wouldn't expect the "should" version of the question to be much more or much less effective than the "want to" version over a long span of time. Don't you need both of them to get the full benefit? I can imagine them making a powerful team if you alternate them periodically - when you've been using one for a while and feel the need for a change.
Personally, I find that "should" feels pushy and triggers my resistance. As far as I know, that's just me. Maybe I was bullied by a "should" in my formative years. Or maybe I'm resentful because "should" always seems to be trying to pass itself off as "have to." In any case, I want to neutralize this unwanted effect of "should" without ignoring the things that I really ought to do for my own good, but am not required to do and don't want to do. Like scheduling a dentist visit, calling Customer Support, or eating broccoli.
On the other hand... maybe it's not a terrible idea for me to indulge "should" once in a while with a "should" question. I've encountered a lot of counterintuitive effects in AF1, DIT, and FVP. Maybe taming the "shoulds" will be the next one.
17 August 2015 at 23:28 | JulieBulie
-
Last week I used:
But first...
Today I'm using these variations of the new question Mark is trying out:
1. But first I should...
2. But right now I should...
3. But now I should...
4. But before that I should...
18 August 2015 at 1:51 | Michael B.
-
So far, number 2 is working best.
18 August 2015 at 2:21 | Michael B.
-
I have to admit I was a bit stumped with what Mark said about the two questions being opposites until I read what JulieBulie said. LOL I can be slow sometimes >,<
I agree that how the question is phrased can affect FVP profoundly, and small changes in the question can have surprisingly big effects. That is what I was driving for in the thread "Question Conundrum". In fact, I am surprised with the effects of the recent change I made in my own FVP, which consists of focusing in "starting" instead of "doing" in Questionless FVP.
On the topic, I agree with JulieBulie that maybe it is good to once in a while change one's question from "should" to "want". This is the spirit of the "Dotting Power" blog post, after all.
However, I wonder if there is a single question that can change in context, ranging from "want" to "should" depending on how it was asked, like if the word "need" was used.
18 August 2015 at 2:32 | nuntym
-
Hi, everyone. Hi, Mark.
This is my first post. Apologies in advance for mistakes, but English is not my native language. I had been following Mark's posts and books for several years. He makes an incredible change in my life, in particular with "How to make your dreams come true" and the AF-FV-FVP series.
This "question" item and its successive changes gives me the idea of using different questions depending on time, necessity and opportunity. I started with the standard question "What I want to do before doing X?". This pushes me toward the firsts items in the list and it has a good "energy" against procrastination. The problem starts when the fist item is very difficult. My subconscious mind preselects a lot of items before that, so the list, as Mark says, turns very rigid.
Then I used "What I want to do more than X?" As Mark says, this "want" is less specific, so allows my mind to preselect tasks on a more free way. I think the "no question" variant goes more on this idea of allowing the mind to select tasks on a subconscious way. This makes the process much quicker.
So I started using different questions regarded the situation I was. The "No question" when I have time to work and the more specific questions when I need to work through the list in a more focus way.
I'll now try the "should" question. I think this will be on a more "duty" focus.
18 August 2015 at 4:39 | Pablo
-
Pablo:
Welcome to the forum! It's my favorite forum on the planet.
18 August 2015 at 5:21 | Michael B.
-
Hi, Pablo. I think this "questions" topic is going to go on for some time, because there are a lot of ways to phrase the question! I like your observation that "before doing X" pushes us toward the first item in the list. I hadn't thought of that (or I probably read it but have since forgotten it.) I haven't been using "before" questions at all, but I will (I "should" and I "want to"!) try one soon.
18 August 2015 at 15:50 | JulieBulie
-
Pablo wrote:
<< The "No question" when I have time to work and the more specific questions when I need to work through the list in a more focus way. >>
That's pretty much the same thing that I do -- I think it works great.
18 August 2015 at 17:51 | Seraphim
-
I have been experimenting with What am I resisting less than A, and so far it has been working beautifully for me... I might give the should question a try, but Shoulds tend to really put me off.
18 August 2015 at 21:34 | Nenad Ristic
-
Welcome Pablo!
19 August 2015 at 1:23 | nuntym
-
I really like focusing on "starting" instead of "doing" in my Questionless FVP. Here are the observed advantages:
1. Since it focuses me on starting a task, not on finishing it, "starting" brings in the "little and often" hammer a lot.
2. But since it focuses me on starting a task, "starting" also forces me to be more careful in doing my tasks. That is, now I make sure that I lay down a good foundation and safety nets everytime I do a task so that I can safely terminate my work anytime and get back to it later. For example, now that I am answering a post here in markforster.net I have an open text file so that I can quickly copy-and-paste my reply in case I have to do something else. And as a side-effect, I love how I have not lost a post recently because of misloading, since I now always copy-and-paste before I click on "Create Post".
3. Resistance has gone down a lot. I have found that it is the thought of not being able to finish the task that gives me a lot of fear in doing something. Focusing on "starting" bypasses the fear.
4. "Starting" supports the "divide and conquer" paradigm: if the task is too big, divide it into smaller and even smaller tasks until you are able to do them. If I come to a very difficult task, I simply ask myself "what else do I need to start before I can start this task?" and whatever answers I think of I write in the FVP list.
There are of course disadvantages, but they are easily surmountable.
1. It can make simple tasks more complicated. However, the great advantage of laying down solid foundations and safety nets before starting a task easily trumps this.
2. On the other hand, it can make me think too much before starting a task that I can do fast. That is why I now use a criterion suggested in GTD: I ask myself whether I can do the task in two minutes or less. If yes, I just do it; if not, I lay down foundations and safety nets first.
19 August 2015 at 1:24 | nuntym
-
After further use, number 1 from the list above is working best:
But first I should...
19 August 2015 at 1:57 | Michael B.
-
20 August 2015 at 1:58 | nuntym
-
nuntym:
<< Could this "FVP question" thing be another manifestation of the same observation? >>
I should think so, yes.
20 August 2015 at 11:19 | Mark Forster
-
Here is a hack of sorts I have been using to manage the questions. I just enter a task like Switch to the resistance question, and when it comes up (if it comes up), I start using the new question from then on.
It makes things a little bit more interesting in my experience
20 August 2015 at 22:43 | Nenad Ristic
-
The longer the list and the further back in the list a scan is started, the more effective number 2 seems to be from my list of test questions:
1. But first I should...
2. But right now I should...
3. But now I should...
4. But before that I should...
Question 2 differs from question 3 by only one word. In practice however, I've found "right now" creates a faster scan and a shorter string of dots. It seems to tune in with the moment better and the current time and contexts available, allowing for a glide over the tasks as the majority of them are filtered out.
21 August 2015 at 7:00 | Michael B.
-
First, I’d like to say I really like this forum and all of the ideas that have been coming. It is really helping me think through how to best handle the hundreds of requests I get each week. I do project management and support as an IT professional.
On to the topic at hand.
I really like Michael B.'s idea of of "but first" thinking.
I also like the idea of "starting" only nuntym reminds us of.
Like JulieBulie, I tend to resist the "should" question as it already puts me in a “but I don't want to” frame of mind.
After some thought, I’m going to try “But first I will start….” Using the word “will” gives me a sense of resolve and doesn’t have the baggage of the other words. “Will” also has a nice double meaning of being willing and a commitment. Using “start” allows me to know this isn’t a long commitment.
Thoughts?
21 August 2015 at 17:06 | Brent
-
"Thoughts?"
In a reactive IT environment
- If it needs doing, get on and do it. Fit other stuff around it. Be prepared to shift priorities as situations demand, but don't compromise your commitments in the process
- Communicate even when its not good news, turn it into an opportunity if you can.
- Use a simple list to note where you're up to with things. A spreadsheet offers a simple way to note references, account managers, next actions, commercials, whatever. Keep it as simple as it needs to be to help you with those things, not any more complex where it starts to eat up time itself.
- Identify what needs doing each week and each day up front, and try to finish each day and each week having done them
- Use appropriate tools such as RAID logs for project management, don't reinvent the wheel
Chris
21 August 2015 at 23:36 | Chris
-
Brent:
“But first I will start….”
Good one. I'm adding this to my test list. Using it for the rest of the day. Thanks!
22 August 2015 at 3:41 | Michael B.
-
22 August 2015 at 6:09 | Seraphim
-
After trying the "but first" question I finding, that I do better with this:
What will I do or start next? if I'm simply scanning and looking for standouts and dotting if needed
and "What will I do or start before x" if I feel the need to compare against a dotted item.
Brent
22 August 2015 at 16:24 | Brent
-
Additions:
6. What will I start first?
7. What should be done first?
8. What needs doing first?
9. What needs starting first?
10. What is in my best interests first?
11. What's even better?
12. What's even better right now?
13. What can be started first?
14. What could be started first?
15. What first?
16. Anything before that?
17. And before that...?
18. What would stress me out more?
19. What would stress me out more than X?
20. What's more stressful than X?
21. What's worse?
22. What's worse than X?
23. What's more urgent?
24. What's more urgent than X?
23 August 2015 at 6:55 | Michael B.
-
I've gone back to "no question" FVP!
23 August 2015 at 9:17 | Mark Forster
-
I am always so surprised how a simple variation about the question can make a so huge difference in my brain. I also tried many questions and the result was also different acirdibg to my feeling and miod at the present time.
Now since a few month I went back to GTD the reason is that I have so many tasks that FV became overwhelming and stucking. Anyway even if i kept the GTD contexts adapted to my activities I still treat the list like an Fv - Af way with the no question system.
I noticed that my mind problem about gtd was that I Considered the list as a ought to list.
Ie i felt engaged on doing. Now i consider the list as a may be list. It is just a collector organised in contexts and so I just have To choose at the right time depending on my feeling what I must or feel to do. The stand out way is crucial in this process and has a real effect on my work and results. I use OMNIFOCUS for this because paper finaly was un able to righly do the job.
23 August 2015 at 10:22 | Jupiter
-
Mark Forster wrote:
<< I've gone back to "no question" FVP! >>
Three cheers for Dotting Power! :-)
24 August 2015 at 1:53 | Seraphim
-
Don't know if anyone's mentioned this, but what about "What are you resisting more than x?"
24 August 2015 at 14:42 | Paul MacNeil
-
Paul MacNeil:
I don't think I've mentioned it, but I've certainly tried it. Not for the faint of heart!
24 August 2015 at 17:37 | Mark Forster
-
24 August 2015 at 19:31 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim:
I happened to be reading Evagrios the Solitary in the Philokalia this afternoon (as one does) and it struck me that a good question would be "What would bring me more stillness than x?"
24 August 2015 at 21:20 | Mark Forster
-
The Philokalia!!
I have been looking for an ebook of one for YEARS! Maybe I should buy a paper book but maaaaaaan that's expensive.
But anyways, yeah nice question Mark :)
24 August 2015 at 23:17 | nuntym
-
24 August 2015 at 23:25 | Mark Forster
-
These questions seem to be gravitating towards describing a state of freedom, where nothing burdens you, all tasks that should be done are done and there is no sense of missing anything. "What, more than x, would carry me closer to nirvana?"
Chris
24 August 2015 at 23:31 | Chris
-
Chris:
<< These questions seem to be gravitating towards describing a state of freedom, where nothing burdens you, all tasks that should be done are done and there is no sense of missing anything. >>
Yes, that's a good summary of what I have always been aiming for. Though it would be a dynamic rather than a static state.
"What, more than x, would carry me closer to nirvana?"
As I understand it the word nirvana means "blown out", "extinguished". It's an extinguishing of individuality in the divine ground of existence. That would certainly not be what I would be aiming for.
I'm happy to be corrected by those who know more about it than I do.
24 August 2015 at 23:41 | Mark Forster
-
along similar lines, my last pass through the list (usually I'm questions) was guided by, "What will reduce my base anxiety level?" :^/
25 August 2015 at 16:23 | Sarah
-
<< These questions seem to be gravitating towards describing a state of freedom, where nothing burdens you, all tasks that should be done are done and there is no sense of missing anything. >>
This sounds more like Stoic eudaimonia than Nirvana, to me, a "good flow of life".
25 August 2015 at 17:13 | Ryan Freckleton
-
Hi, Mark... Hi, friends:
Ryan wrote:
<<
<< These questions seem to be gravitating towards describing a state of freedom, where nothing burdens you, all tasks that should be done are done and there is no sense of missing anything. >>
This sounds more like Stoic eudaimonia than Nirvana, to me, a "good flow of life". >>
I agree. At the same time I'm working through "How to make your dreams come true" again, I'm reading and making some experiments with stoic philosophy, and found some interesting elements that connect this two fields. Maybe Mark has more oriental philosophy in mind, but I think this is because already exist connections between classical philosophy as a way of life and oriental philosophy (i.e.: Buddhism and taoism).
For those with interests in this field, the books and studies by Pierre Hadot are on the first line, and another work very interesting is "A guide to the good life - the ancient art of stoic joy", by Prof. William B. Irvine.
25 August 2015 at 19:43 | Pablo
-
Pablo:
<< Maybe Mark has more oriental philosophy in mind >>
I don't. The Philokalia (Love of Beauty) is a compendium of texts from ancient Christian writers. The one I referred to, Evagrios the Solitary, was a Christian monk and ascetic, one of the desert fathers, who lived 345-399 AD.
Evagrios and the other desert fathers would have regarded "stillness" not as an end in itself but as a necessary removal of worldly distractions from attaining communion with God.
26 August 2015 at 0:05 | Mark Forster
-
@Mark Forster:
Thanks for that Mark! PDFs are unwieldy for smartphones but it's better than nothing. Besides, it's free.
@Everyone
Anyways, to add to this interesting discussion, the "stillness" and "peace" found in Christianity can be misleading. Peace in Christianity is more characterized by "harmony" rather than "quiet": it is characterized by "the union of the different movements of the heart," as said by St Thomas Aquinas. It is when all of inside you only wants one thing, without any hesitation. Christian peace is less likened to quiet as more to power.
A man of peace is likened to a river, its surface deceptively calm, but underneath its currents cut through the earth and carry everything inexorably towards the sea. His heart is like fire in a furnace that converts anything and everything given to it into heat and power, enough to move ships or power cities. He is like a car in top shape, all its parts humming and purring and ever ready to race towards its goal.
26 August 2015 at 0:49 | nuntym
-
I completely forgot to add the following about Christian peace:
It would seem that Christian peace seems similar to, let us say, a desperate man who has nothing to lose.
The main difference between a man of peace and a desperate man is that a man of peace is joyful. Peace, St. Thomas Aquinas said, is the perfection of joy, and joy is achieved when you have what you want.
26 August 2015 at 1:28 | nuntym
-
nuntym:
<< Peace in Christianity is more characterized by "harmony" rather than "quiet": >>
The quality of stillness (hesychia - ἡσυχία) in the Philokalia is not really the same as peace (irene - εἰρήνη). In non-theological Greek hesychia was the opposite of "noise", while irene was the opposite of "war". The Hesychast sees stillness or quiet as a means of obtaining peace, rather than peace itself.
In non-theological terms, leading a life of stillness and tranquility rather than frantic activity will eventually lead one to cease being at war with oneself.
26 August 2015 at 9:40 | Mark Forster
-
@Mark Forster:
Wow, that sounds like the idea of "joy" in St Thomas Aquinas' writings, which he noted to be the first fruit of loving God and of which perfection becomes peace.. As he wrote: "Now joy is compared to desire, as rest to movement, as stated above, when we were treating of the passions: and rest is full when there is no more movement. Hence joy is full, when there remains nothing to be desired." (
http://www.newadvent.org/summa/3028.htm )
27 August 2015 at 10:32 | nuntym
-
Mark: Thank you for your comment. I forgot that post, and it's just a few lines above!
The discussion here turns very interesting. I'm not so far educated on the classics, so you are opening my mind to a new scenario. Thank you all!
Could it be possible that FVP helps us to attain peace of mind in the everyday life? I think so, but it really helps if one has a philosophy of life.
27 August 2015 at 13:17 | Pablo
-
I've reverted back to Questionless, having found that, for me, explicit questions cause a drag effect on the flow while cycling through the algorithm. I think that even in Questionless mode, my mind, whether subliminally or otherwise, is anyway employing an unnamed question(s) of sorts depending on what I feel I need at that moment, which is rather powerful when combined with carefully executed Dotting Power...!
27 August 2015 at 21:06 | Neil Cumming
-
Additional guides:
25. Before X I'll...?
26. Before X I will...?
27. Before X I could...?
28. Before X I should...?
29. Before X I must...?
30. Before X I need to...?
31. Before X...?
29 August 2015 at 5:29 | Michael B.
-
Michael B... seriously? 31 variants of the question? Just get X done!!!
29 August 2015 at 6:18 | Chris
-
Chris:
It's not 31 variants I use. It's 31 I'm testing. Relax.
29 August 2015 at 7:52 | Michael B.
-
You're not really testing anything. With 31 variants of the question you're actually seeking results which confirm pre-selected, likely subconscious, ideas about how you want FVP to operate for you. You could perhaps test two very different feeling questions, side by side, in a controlled environment with all variables the same, and get something valid from that. 31 variants of question is bonkers, just another more pernicious form of system-hopping.
In my humble, relaxed opinion.
Chris
29 August 2015 at 14:26 | Chris
-
"You're not really testing anything."
Incorrect. That's exactly what I'm doing, Christopher.
"31 variants of question is bonkers"
According to that reasoning, Mark must be the most bonkers of all with his non double-blind placebo controlled trials behind the scenes to create his books, articles, comments, blog posts, and systems! What's actually bonkers is your attraction to this community, Chris, and your inability to comprehend the thread that you're posting in. Have you even read what this thread is for? It's for testing and settling on a new question. This thread isn't about you and your general opinions, Chris.
"just another more pernicious form of system-hopping."
Incorrect. I am not involved in another more pernicious form of system hopping. I'm testing for a better question for FVP, as is the point of this thread. Be sure to read and understand the context before commenting.
Chris, I want you to concentrate on staying on topic in a thread and consistently controlling yourself from derailing the discussions.
I was agreeing with your comments recently and was surprised at the politeness, humbleness, and maturity I was seeing. You were becoming helpful. I thought perhaps you'd grown during your break from the forum. I was waiting to positively respond to those comments as I've seen your patterns here. I know in the past your comments have eventually dissolved back into immature, holier than thou, snide remarks and baiting, and I wasn't going to applaud your growth just to have you start baiting and mocking people again.
We're all looking forward to your social growth and your future polite and positive contributions here. I know Mark and I are also looking forward to your full, non-flippant answers to the questions he asked you before you left the forum and again upon your return. How about rolling up your sleeves and doing that, right now, Chris?
29 August 2015 at 16:48 | Michael B.
-
"According to that reasoning, Mark must be the most bonkers of all"
Except I'm talking to you with your 31 questions, not Mark. Mark doesn't have to justify himself. When he posts a new form of the question he tends to explain how he tested it, how he found it works in practice and why he feels it adds something compared with the previous question. And he doesn't do it lightly because lots of thought goes into the system and the specific wording of the question, a common theme in Mark's systems. You're not doing that at all. You're just banging out quantity and the noise is washing out the interesting nuances of what makes a question work and not work. That's my opinion and I post my opinions just like everyone else, a privilege you certainly availed yourself of in your reply. I'm straight to the point so if you post in this forum and you don't like that then you will need to ignore me.
"But right now I should..." "But now I should...". What's are the differences? Are there any practical differences? How are you testing those differences? How will you evaluate each question in an objective way? So I'm calling you on it, all these bland variants devalue FVP. So many similar variants gives you plenty of wiggle room to game FVP and round off the pointy bits that actually prick you, make you get up and get some awkward work done. And it adds very little for anyone else reading here without explaining what's different like Mark does. Don't like something? Change the question today and avoid it! Realise that that's what you're doing to yourself, just like when you tried all your previous productivity systems looking for The One? No chance!
So you see, I understand this thread far more deeply than you imagine I do. I suggest you focus on the topic, not me, and rather than posting questions 32 through 50 over the next fortnight, explain to everyone what you are looking for in a question, how you've arrived at these 31 variants, how you're testing the differences between them and what you're using as success criteria for a specific wording of the question to show its merits. And perhaps most importantly why is it objectively any better than the original, carefully thought through question that Mark used? If it's not really that different, or you cannot articulate why you feel it adds any value, then stop obsessing over trivial wording and just get on and use FVP.
Chris
29 August 2015 at 21:31 | Chris
-
I love this place ;-)
30 August 2015 at 0:55 | Hayden Roberts
-
Chris: " And it adds very little for anyone else reading here without explaining what's different like Mark does."
Please, speak for yourself.
31 August 2015 at 16:44 | JulieBulie
-
"Please, speak for yourself."
It wasn't an opinon, JulieBulie, it was a observation regarding missing data. And if you're concerned about people speaking for you, you might want to re-read what I was responding to and voice your concerns there.
Chris
1 September 2015 at 2:45 | Chris
-
1 September 2015 at 13:21 | Michael B.
-
"Tactical Trolls: This is where the troller takes the game more seriously, creates a credible persona to gain confidence of others, and provokes strife in a subtle and invidious way."
— Netlingo
1 September 2015 at 13:55 | Michael B.
-
Michael B, totally uncalled for, and totally untrue.
1 September 2015 at 14:34 | Chris
-
Michael B, Chris and everyone:
Enough. Could we just agree please not to make personal remarks about other commenters.
1 September 2015 at 17:52 | Mark Forster
-
No problem here, I haven't made any, I'm only questioning the creation of so many practically identical FVP questions and wondering how they can be any more advantageous than the original question.
I'll explain myself. The original question is "What do I want to do more than x?" where the meaning of "want" is left undefined. Imagine three objectives which I want to get done soon and which will involve multiple steps, and that I have tasks for all these on an FVP list.
1. Research and buy a new car
2. Prepare a meal for 12 the day after tomorrow
3. Wash all the windows outside the house
Now imagine that the meal is 'on my mind' because it's coming up fast and there's little room for messing about. I look at my list and ask the question "What do I want to do more than x?". Because the meal is on my mind this sets a context for the question. Rewriting the question in each context you get:
1. What do I want to do more than x to help me research a car?
2. What do I want to do more than x to help me prepare a meal for 12?
3. What do I want to do more than x to help me wash all the windows?
Now imagine I've changed the question to "What should I do before x?" The use of the word "should" has imposed a context on the question. I might feel like researching cars but the use of the word "should" imposes the relative urgency of the meal tasks so they stand out more.
Now imagine the question is "What could I do before x?". The question now feels more like it's acknowledging what's on my mind, but that I want to do something more amenable before it. So now I'd feel that the car related stuff is standing out because I could do that before I do the meal stuff. I shouldn't, but I could.
When I look at these variants:
6. What will I start first?
7. What should be done first?
8. What needs doing first?
9. What needs starting first?
10. What is in my best interests first?
there might be explicit grammatical differences between them but for me the feeling is the same in each case, they're leading me to the stuff that has a sense of urgency and immovability to it, the meal tasks in this case. So if I was paring down these question changes I'd identify a difference between should and could but not between 9 and 10. Then I could articulate that, as I've just done.
Questionless FVP is interesting because it allows what's on your mind to essentially set the unspoken question. If the meal is on my mind then the sense of urgency will drive different comparisons to the more relaxed state of the car being on my mind. In all cases the same base question "What do I want to do more than x" is present with the "[to help me to do y]?" being implied by the unspoken context.
In otherwords I think FVP works well either in questionless form, in which case contextual meaning in the moment drives the selections, or else a specific type of question which forces a type of selection, but if the specific type of question is itself in response to contextual meaning in the moment, then the original question is quite simply adequate, since everything else derives from the way "want" is interpreted in the moment with whatever is pressing on your mind.
Which is a roundabout analysis to show that the original question suffices, questionless FVP drives the correct selection, and specific questions have very specific uses if selected carefully to change the feel of the selection, not just the wording. You summed up the consequence of this with "What exactly is meant by “want” in this context is deliberately left undefined. There may be a whole variety of reasons why you might want to do one thing more than another thing and all of them are valid."
So I can understand a difference between "What do I want to do before x?" and "What would bring me more stillness than x?" but I don't see any difference between "But right now I should" and "But now I should", two examples I've asked about.
I hope that explains my interest in this thread and my thoughts on question-creep.
Chris
1 September 2015 at 19:13 | Chris
-
Chris - your comments make sense in theory, but in practice a small variation in "the question" can have a surprisingly large effect. I don't pretend to have an explanation for this phenomenon. It is merely an observation shared by many!
2 September 2015 at 3:32 | Seraphim
-
Just chiming in to say that I really appreciate Chris' perspective because he works the same way that I do at work - make a list (not even all the time but sometimes to organize thoughts/list steps) and "just get 'er done".
I tried FVP and didn't take to it. Not sure why. Still use AF1 at home quite regularly on a 2 week closed list plus open portion that I try not to go into (it becomes the next 2 week closed list after a review to ensure everything on it is still relevant - ie. pre-dismissal). I don't think of it as a time management system as much as an anti-procrastination system. Maybe they are the same thing, I don't know.
Work is easy because I resist very little and my current work is well-defined. Home is harder because I'm often tired (from work) and feel somewhat overwhelmed at all the options of things I "could/should" do - and too many things I don't really like doing. Playing the closing game helps.
I did an experiment some years ago while working with AF with some contract work I was just dreading and a statement/question that I found on a CBT site. It was stating 'I choose to...' Somehow it triggered a desire in me to do these things and to realize that truly, I did have a choice of whether or not to do them that day or ever. I can't fathom doing that multiple times a day though. I feel it would lose its effectiveness and seems more of a "big gun" approach.
Anyhoo, back to your previously scheduled question discussion... which seems a little... interesting from an outsider/non-user's perspective but whatever floats the boat.
2 September 2015 at 4:34 | Jacqueline
-
A look back of the past six months gave me an inkling of the possible reasons for the phenomenon we've been seeing here, of the large effect a small change in the question can have on FVP.
When I started using FVP I had been reporting problems using it. In hindsight, it could have been the question. You see, Mark Forster did say that the question "What do I want more than x?" was made deliberately vague so that it can adapt to any situation and context as we needed it. The problem arises, though, when we don't know what we want, or specifically [[why]] we want something.
This was the time when I went home from the US, giving up my job, to my home country because my father got sick. My father eventually passed away last June, and I just came back the end of August. Understandably this was the time I was feeling lost, and of course that reflected on my use of FVP. "Want" was too vague to be of any use to me at that time, and the first task was no help either. Questionless FVP was no different.
Changing the question alleviated some of the difficulties. Including "joy", "love", and "start" in the question gave direction to the "want": what do I want that would give me joy, or let me love more, or let me start something?
Looking back, it seems knowing [[why]] you want something is one of the most important factors for making FVP work, and I think that is what is being affected by the changing of the question.
That also could be the reason why some users such as Chris and Seraphim have no problems using FVP. They know what they want: not get swamped in their work. In such an environment not only do they have a clear goal, but they cannot afford to doubt on why they want.
However other people such as myself only use FVP at home, where the environment is more relaxed and the goals are less defined. There, the goals are what you decide on, and sometimes you need more guidance, hence the big effect of changing the question.
Finally, there is the effect of changing how I start chains. The tweak I am using starts chains with the task that stands out in the first page. This has made FVP much easier for me. I think the reason for this is that by analyzing all the tasks in the first page I give myself the time not only to know what I want but more importantly why, and that guides me in choosing the next tasks in the chain. This explains why it "seems to guide me on what kinds of tasks I choose next for the chain, sort of like how "Dotting Power" works but in a more subconscious way," as I posted earlier.
5 September 2015 at 17:41 | nuntym
-
Sorry for my late response to this part of the thread!
Mark Forster wrote:
<< I happened to be reading Evagrios the Solitary in the Philokalia this afternoon (as one does) >>
LOL! I love your sense of humor Mark. :-)
By the way, there is a newer (and I think, better) translation of the Philokalia available - it's not complete, but does include Saint Evagrios. It was translated by the ever-memorable Dr. Constantine Cavarnos (who reposed as Monk Constantine a few years back here in Arizona).
http://www.amazon.com/Philokalia-Love-Beautiful-Prof-Constantine-Cavarnos/dp/1884729797 I like this translation better than the one by His Eminence Metropolitan Kallistos and colleagues -- the language is clearer, more accurate, less academic (though I also greatly admire Metropolitan Kallistos and his many works!)
<< and it struck me that a good question would be "What would bring me more stillness than x?" >>
The discussion seems to have faded away, but how did this work out for you? What were your conclusions?
I wrote a longer reply but am not really happy with it yet, so in the meantime I will give you my short version. To get my focus more in tune with the spiritual direction I want it to go in, I've found Greg McKeown's "most important hour of your life" exercise to be really useful.
http://gregmckeown.com/blog/important-hour-life/ I haven't tried it with FVP yet, probably because I have been so driven by the tyranny of the urgent these past weeks. But it seems like it would work really well as an FVP question: "What would I do first if I only had one month to live?"
This really brings things into focus for me -- am I actually READY to die? Am I spiritually prepared? Have I at least confessed all my sins? Is there anyone with whom I need to be reconciled? Are my worldly affairs in order so that my wife and family would be OK? If not, why not? Don't I realize this could happen at any time, and the consequences are permanent and eternal?
I've used this method many times, for getting focused on the things that really matter. But I've usually applied it by stepping away and thinking hard about the larger picture: commitments and larger questions. It has an incredible focusing effect, especially as you draw it out as he recommends, starting with a week, then a month, then a year, and so on. For example, if you have only a week to live, you probably aren't concerned with getting a paycheck. But if you have a year or more, maybe I would need a paycheck for a good portion of that period -- do I really want to try to live off savings all that time and take away from whatever funds my family will have to live on? and this puts work/job/career in a different kind of light.
It's a very worthwhile exercise, and very much in tune with another precept of the Desert Fathers (and the Gospel!), to frequently ponder our own death, to keep it always in mind, and to always be prepared.
6 September 2015 at 0:37 | Seraphim
-
nuntym wrote:
<< That also could be the reason why some users such as Chris and Seraphim have no problems using FVP. They know what they want: not get swamped in their work. In such an environment not only do they have a clear goal, but they cannot afford to doubt on why they want. >>
Actually I'd put this a little differently. There is always more opportunity to do things than I could ever possibly do. And the goals are almost never really clear -- quite often I have to define them myself (which can be a blessing or a curse, I suppose).
When the environment gets really crazy, the situation transforms into far more demands on my time than I can possibly meet. And that's when two things become really important for me: (1) Lots of things must get dropped -- but don't drop anything that will have a big negative impact if it gets dropped. (2) Don't let the chaos take my attention away from the things that only I can do that will have the most impact in the long run (half the time I don't even know what they are).
In the midst of the storm, it's not easy to figure all this out. One day, something may seem super important, but the next day's meetings and conversations make that thing seem a lot less relevant. So sometimes the best strategy is to wait a bit and see which of the many items clamoring for attention actually have staying power. Some things just seem to take care of themselves -- the need goes away, or someone else takes care of it, and that's all fine.
FVP is really good at sorting this all out. Or rather, I should say, FVP is a good framework for allowing me to see the things that have real momentum and value, compared to the things that are simply making a lot of noise, and then to apply my own intuition and discrimination to do the right work with the right level of effort. Sometimes I am really surprised by how it all works out -- especially at how often I think something needs 2-3 hours of work but in the end I did a decent job getting the key elements completed in 10 or 15 minutes.
It can still be quite overwhelming and FVP is not a panacea. The overloaded calendars, conflicting objectives, overwhelming volume of email, etc., are all draining and stressful and unsustainable.
But FVP does allow me to find the best balance to get through this and establish some kind of strategy for attacking the root causes of this situation. For example, when the current storm passes, and I'm able to catch my breath a little, I can just apply some "dotting power" to step back and think, "OK how can we make sure THAT never happens again?", maybe write down a few ideas, then follow the algorithm, and see what stands out! This has helped me to find new ways to delegate large chunks of my work, get my manager to agree to deprioritize commitments, and so on. This gives me hope that a more reasonable and sustainable workload may be possible in the future. :-)
<< However other people such as myself only use FVP at home, where the environment is more relaxed and the goals are less defined. There, the goals are what you decide on, and sometimes you need more guidance, hence the big effect of changing the question. >>
LOL, my home life is pretty crazy, even more demanding than work: more diverse challenges, a broader range of things we are trying to accomplish, and (especially) more constraints on time.
Hm, this does lead me to think, maybe FVP really *thrives* on a challenging workload with changing priorities and objectives? Maybe if FVP isn't working for you, you need to add a couple hundred things to your list and see if that helps? Only half joking. LOL
6 September 2015 at 1:40 | Seraphim
-
Speaking of home life, FVP is the only personal time management system of any kind I've ever made a serious effort to share with my family. My three oldest sons are now all getting started with it. One of them (in his first semester at University) is reporting that it's really helping him a lot! Great stuff!
6 September 2015 at 1:47 | Seraphim