-
Now that we've all been having fun for awhile using Mark's new method FVP, I'd love to hear what your thoughts/experiences are. How's it working? What have you noticed? Paper or digital? Likes & dislikes? Etc..
4 June 2015 at 3:37 | Tommy
-
I really like it! But when the list started getting too long, or when I was adding a lot of new tasks, there tended to be too many comparisons. On paper, this was causing me to "tune out" to the list -- I just couldn't get myself to focus my eyes on all those items, and conscientiously do the compares. Ultimately this led me to resist using the method altogether.
So I tried using Andreas's web app -- that helped a lot! I didn't need to deal with so many items on a page, or with the page-flipping when comparing items on different pages. Using the webapp also began to highlight how many compares you have to do, when things are moving quickly (adding new items to the list in little bursts, mixed with re-entries). Even with the web app, that started getting tedious. Tap on my phone, tap tap tap tap tap tap tap take action. Add a few tasks. Tap tap tap tap tap tap tap tap tap tap tap take action. Lots and lots of tapping. I'd get to doing it quickly, which would lead me to stop reading closely, and then skip over a task I really "wanted to do more than X" but had already tapped past it and couldn't figure out how to roll back the last tap. LOL
The thing that I *really* liked about the web app, was the ability to compare JUST TWO ITEMS. It really helped me stay focused, and actually work the system. But it also led me to question whether an exhaustive comparison of all items was really needed.
Looking at only two items at a time reminded me of SMEMA, which has always had a certain appeal for me. Then someone else mentioned SMEMA, too, and this gave me an idea to reduce the number of comparisons, and to move the system into OneNote, which is where I track all my projects.
So today, between meetings, I started collecting a list of tasks in OneNote and called it "FVP". It became my catch-all. But if anything seemed pressing, or simply top-of-mind or "standing out", I would move it to another list I called "SMEMA". I tried to keep this list really short, 2-3 items, but sometimes it got up to 5. If it got to be more than that, I'd just move the oldest ones back to FVP, so I could focus on just 2-3 items. Then I'd keep hammering on those items till I felt like pulling in some more. To do that, I'd look at my FVP list, and grab a few that stood out, or I just felt like doing, and move them over to SMEMA. I'd try to do this quickly, running down the list and asking, "what do I want to do more", or really, just grabbing the first handful of tasks that got my attention, and move them to the SMEMA list. Then I'd turn to the SMEMA list, and keep focusing on it, and hammering away till they were done (or maybe had 1 left). And then I'd repeat.
This is totally ad-hoc and probably not scalable / sustainable, but it worked great today! So I tried it at home this evening with my personal list, and it worked great too.
However, I am guessing it wouldn't last more than a few days, because then the list will get too long again. That always happens with me, with "catch all" systems. But here is how I think I might be able to handle that: if the list gets too long, I can just "dismiss" it, and start over with a new, empty FVP list. Then once a week (or more, if I feel like it), I can scan over the dismissed lists and see if anything still needs doing. I was essentially doing this with my personalized DIT-like method, before FVP came along, and it was working really well.
Also, that kind of dismissal is essentially what I've been doing these last several days, when I switched from paper FVP to webapp FVP then to OneNote FVP/SMEMA. Each time I switched over, and started with a fresh list, it kept me moving, and I got good results both with larger projects and with recurring maintenance trivia. I didn't delete the older lists -- I kept them handy, and would copy over some items from time to time to my new list.
4 June 2015 at 5:16 | Seraphim
-
I have returned to Mark's system after about two years.
After starting in paper mode, I adapted my Todoist system.
It is now working well and I am getting more of the important stuff done working off a Work listand a Personal list.
I tend to dump non-critical stuff into Todoist's Inbox to incubate.
What I find nice is I can put recurring tasks on the the lsi andcwhen done, the next occurrence goes to the bottom of the list.
I can also see a history of all complteted tasks.
4 June 2015 at 6:48 | Roger J
-
I started with a paper list. That got messy quick. Then I jumped all over the Andreas' wonderful web app. One for work and one for home. Went through a lot of bumps with that, mostly with trying to copy and paste huge lists to both. Simplified both into just using the app on my phone, which I used yesterday and today. The simplicity was liberating, but I too was cycling through a lot of stuff over and over again. I then tried paper for a bit with the "exciting" question. That was ok, but the stuff I needed to get done that day fell back as it wasn't really exciting, or at least not to me at the time. I went back to the simple version of the web app, and was mostly happy.
Tonight at work I tried doing Mark's new experimental version of FVP with a paper list and "no question". It was weird at first, but seemed easier to get through. Then it seemed kind of fast actually...
As it stands now, I'm going to keep working with the paper list and the quick scanning method. That feels the most "right" right now, but who knows?
4 June 2015 at 9:12 | Jesse
-
Like Roger J I've been away from this forum and Mark's experiments for a couple of years. I too had converted to Todoist but FVP sounded promising so I've been using it this week. I've gone back to paper and pen and am following the rules faithfully.
Starting each new scan from the point of the just-completed task makes a big difference.
I practiced a few times by randomizing a list of the numbers 1-20 to get the hang of it and prove to myself it works. That was very helpful.
I use my iPhone reminders app to capture things when I'm away from my paper list. Siri makes that fast and easy.
I have an app called Due for recurring and repetitive tasks that come up weekly, monthly, annually, etc. As they come up I write them on my paper list.
FVP on paper is, so far, very effective. It's easier to write on my list than go to my laptop, switch to Todoist, and type. And it's *much* easier to prioritize.
I'm not sure yet how to handle projects. I've got a few that I'll be moving to paper so I'll need to work that out.
Starting today I'm using Mark's questionless sort. So far, so good. Feels right to me.
Bottom line - I'm glad something (not sure what) prompted me to check in on the forum. For me FVP is simple, fast, and effective. So far.
5 June 2015 at 17:38 | Zane
-
@Zane,
I use Todoist on my notebook computer, Galaxy Note 8 and Galaxy Note 2.
As the last is with me most of the time I can either enter a new task, do a scan, a task or even scribble a note in OneNote with the S Pen.
When I get back to my notebook computer, my Todoist has the updates.
5 June 2015 at 17:50 | Roger J
-
Paper. So far, it has worked better than any other system I have used in a number of years. One problem is that I am not always intentional enough to ask the question. Sometimes, I just scan and dot tasks that stand out. Thinking of changing to digital because the list has gotten quite messy and with 10 pages total, I do not want to have to re-write.
5 June 2015 at 17:55 | sobertruth
-
@Roger J
Yes, and I have Todoist on my iPhone. But for me it's quite a bit easier and faster to write and read with paper and pen. I end up spending a lot of time in Todoist looking by priority, then at labels, then at overdue, then at specific projects, etc. My own fault, probably. With paper I write and go. Easy to highlight, bold, star, happy-face, etc. And no squiggly red lines!
5 June 2015 at 18:21 | Zane
-
sobertruth:
<< One problem is that I am not always intentional enough to ask the question. Sometimes, I just scan and dot tasks that stand out. >>
That is the way that I am now doing it myself, see
http://markforster.squarespace.com/fv-forum/post/2508019#post2509454It's far faster than asking the question, and appears to produce just as good results.
<< Thinking of changing to digital... >>
Judging by the experiences reported by those who are using Andreas's app, it takes much longer to scan the list when using digital.
<< because the list has gotten quite messy and with 10 pages total, I do not want to have to re-write. >>
My current advice is not to re-prioritize, but instead to cross out and re-enter any individual tasks that have changed their priority. If you follow this advice, your list should not get messy.
5 June 2015 at 19:20 | Mark Forster
-
Nothing, for me, comes close to the effectiveness of a lined pad and my Parker (stainless steel) mechanical pencil. Always sharp, writes nicely, always erasable (no mess of dots etc), and sleek and beautiful to boot.
5 June 2015 at 19:48 | Neil Cumming
-
@Mark.Thanks. Scanning has worked, but I had been wondering if not asking the question messed up the algorithm. Evidently, the "algorithm question" regarding the "question" has generated much discussion. Am curious if others also drop the question.
I am going to implement your suggestion of crossing out and re-entering the tasks. (I was resistant to this idea for some reason.)
@Neil. I understand. I have tried digital so many times, but I always return to paper. The aesthetics and the tangible nature of paper are something I am drawn too as well.
5 June 2015 at 22:16 | sobertruth
-
I've had really good results using just the original FVP question, ("What do I want to do more than X...")
I can't really imagine the 'Exciting' question working for me, as many of my important tasks feel like the polar opposite of exciting - but as Mark rightly alludes, the proof of the pudding is in the eating.
For now, though, I'm interested in trying the algorithm with no question, which I think I'll trial today if I get the chance.
6 June 2015 at 12:30 | Neil Cumming
-
@sobertruth I hear you. I sometimes like the 'idea' of a digital method, but in reality it's never come close to the good old pencil and paper approach for me, which are "a uniquely portable magic" (to paraphrase Stephen King's description of books).
6 June 2015 at 12:39 | Neil Cumming
-
Neil Cumming:
I'm finding that questionless FVP works brilliantly and for me is much faster and more effective than the other ways.
Although I appreciate Andreas's efforts with his app, I think that using anything other than pen/pencil and paper will greatly reduce the speed of the system.
6 June 2015 at 12:49 | Mark Forster
-
And I'm also finding that using a different ink colour each day is very informative and motivating.
6 June 2015 at 13:41 | Mark Forster
-
One variation on the question for rapidly scanning your list is, "What's better?".
6 June 2015 at 16:11 | Michael B.
-
For awhile now I've been using Maniana Todo List app for Android. Since all tasks move from maniana over to the today list at midnight, all I do is in the morning is run through the list. I find myself saying "not today" to most of the tasks and sending them to the maniana list. It works great to give clarity of what I have/want to get done today. Recently I've used FVP on my today list & it is working great! Since the today list typically is fairly small after sending "not-today" tasks to the maniana list. This seems to really solve the main "issue" with FVP, that the list is too long to be scanning, as my today list is much more managable. Really then FVP becomes a method to work my list of things I already know I'd like to work on today. Gets them done in the order that I most want to do. Awesome!
Just thought I'd share.
6 June 2015 at 21:47 | Tommy
-
Tommy:
<< This seems to really solve the main "issue" with FVP, that the list is too long to be scanning, as my today list is much more managable. >>
My own experience with FVP is that provided you are using pen and paper and the "no question" method, FVP is actually as fast as or faster than any other system.
6 June 2015 at 22:17 | Mark Forster
-
@Mark:
Agreed, it is fast. I think what I'm doing is, once per day, excluding items which are not relevant. This gives me better clarity knowing that everything I'm scanning is truely possible for that day.
6 June 2015 at 22:26 | Tommy
-
Tommy:
<< This gives me better clarity knowing that everything I'm scanning is truely possible for that day. >>
Of course you can use FVP however you like, but it was designed to be a "universal capture" system, not a one-day list, and that is the way I'm using it - to great effect.
6 June 2015 at 22:46 | Mark Forster
-
<<And I'm also finding that using a different ink colour each day is very informative and motivating.
>>
I agree! I used to do this with AF and its variants, and it was just as you said. Think I'll return to that now that I've come back to paper and pen.
7 June 2015 at 13:40 | Lenore
-
Since FVP was launched, wd have reached three versions of questions:
"want"
"exciting"
"no question"
For the last, surely there must be some question in mind?
7 June 2015 at 13:51 | Roger J
-
Roger J:
From my reply above:
"One variation on the question for rapidly scanning your list is, "What's better?".
Using these questions:
What do I want to do more than X?
What's more exciting than X?
What's more exciting?
More exciting?
What's better?
Better than X?
I have found "What's better?" to be the lightest and fastest of them all. So far it feels as fast to me as question-free.
7 June 2015 at 14:22 | Michael B.
-
Roger J:
<< For the last, surely there must be some question in mind? >>
No, there's not. It relies entirely on "standing out" in the old AF1 sense of the task feeling ready to be done, though unlike AF1 it won't necessarily be done immediately.
I'm coming to think that the "No Question" version of FVP is not really like the other FV/FVP versions which use a question. Unlike with them, the algorithm is not really ranking anything in order. It's just a very efficient method of pre-selection. It is probably best thought of as a development of AF1.
7 June 2015 at 14:25 | Mark Forster
-
After a day of confusion on fvp (thanks Mark for straightening me out)! I have been using it to great effect. I run it off a single flat excel list, in which everything is entered.
I still use the question, what do I want to more than X and finds that to work. I am also keeping g an adding to my selected items over multiple days, deleting dots only when I hit the bottom of my list.
Loving the process, thanks Mark.
7 June 2015 at 21:50 | Vegheadjones
-
I think the system is great so far, when I follow it. It also seems to hold up better than anything before when I neglect it.
In my opinion digital is not at all inefficient, provided you have an efficient digital system. I know many are very cumbersome in how much effort it is to add, edit, delete, move, scan and so I rejected all sorts that had these flaws.
The simple tools are best. Excel for this purpose is a simple tool. So are OneNote and the iPad based Cloud Outliner. In each case everything is on one page escept for scrolling, ther are no popup windows or menus, no automated anything, just onscreen items to work with directly.
10 June 2015 at 21:18 | Alan Baljeu
-
Hi Alan,
I am still using FVP on a small A7 paper notebook. But I will definitely be doing FVP on one of my digital online list apps in the future. Most likely checkvist.com / m.checkvist.com, though fargo.io / android outliner pro still in the running.
However, FVP on paper is always less "friction" than digital ...
(1) Paper notebook is a 3D stack of paper, but digital list representation via scroll bar, page scrolling vs line scrolling, has more "friction".
(2) Paper dotting, active item marking, crossing, rewrite; need related action (or actions) in digital list, these are usually more "friction". Even with simple digital lists like Excel.
Hence, I am doing FVP on paper first to build up my "FVP willpower muscle memory" before I can afford to tackle using FVP on digital list with its "higher friction". Else I risk back sliding / falling off the bandwagon again.
15 June 2015 at 3:01 | sabre23t
-
I agree with both Sabre23 and Alan. Alan: a flat list like excel is better than a computer option where you cant see everything but Sabre is right that the is still less friction when done on paper. I tried doing the questionless method on excel vs paper and it works so smoothly on paper, I could not get it to work that way by scrolling in excel. My issue on paper is that you cannot link easily to emails and for other reference materials but I think I have a way around that and thus the best of both worlds for me. If true, I will let you (all) in on it.
15 June 2015 at 15:23 | Vegheadjones
-
Vegheadjones:
<< My issue on paper is that you cannot link easily to emails and for other reference materials >>
As a convinced paper user I've never had the slightest problem with this. I think the saving in time by having links to emails and other materials in one's list is largely illusory - in fact I strongly suspect that it slows the whole process down. If you look at either of the two recent lists on my blog of things I've done in a day, you might come to the conclusion that I'm not being held back much by any lack of links.
Nevertheless I am looking forward to hearing what your way round the linking problem is when you are ready to let us in on it.
15 June 2015 at 16:08 | Mark Forster
-
As I spend my working life in MS Outlook, it is natural to use the task list as THE list. So, for instance, when I do a batch of mail, anything that's going to take be more than a few seconds to deal with gets flicked into the todo list. Ctrl+K adds a new manual task. Writing a separate paper list feels like duplicate work with no obvious benefit.
Nevertheless, that's what I'm doing at the moment.
16 June 2015 at 9:49 | Will
-
Will:
<< Writing a separate paper list feels like duplicate work with no obvious benefit. >>
You're right. It is. But that's because you have organized your email that way.
I have my email organized in a completely different way so that it's more efficient to use a paper list.
16 June 2015 at 11:47 | Mark Forster
-
Mark,
I'm intrigued...
This has got me thinking about why my e-lists need pruning so often. Or quickly become unmanageable. I end up getting tasks at a very detailed level. Each mail in a correspondence with half a dozen participants, for example, becomes a task trigger. This rarely the most efficient or effective way of working.
Having a manual task list which only shows the main tasks does help to keep things manageable.
Regards,
Will
16 June 2015 at 13:05 | Will
-
Mark Forster wrote:
<< I have my email organized in a completely different way so that it's more efficient to use a paper list. >>
Can you elaborate on this? Awhile back, you gave a few examples of how you handle email-based tasks in your paper list, together with using some of NEO's flagging features, if I remember right.
But I would love to have a better understanding of how you do this. I have the same issues with email that Will is describing.
16 June 2015 at 19:15 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim:
<< But I would love to have a better understanding of how you do this.>>
There's nothing particularly exciting or original about the way I do it. Mainly I just deal with email in NEO and put "Email" as a task on my list. I don't see any point in duplicating what is in NEO on my paper list.
Of course sometimes an important email will be need to be deal with as part of a larger task, in which case I will flag it and/or tag it, and put "Project X" (or whatever) on my list. For instance I might be waiting for seven or eight people to reply to an email suggesting dates for a meeting. I would tag them and when I had all the replies I would put "Convene meeting" on my list.
Recently I have been experimenting with having "Email Backlog" as well as "Email" on my list. "Email" consists of email which has come in today. "Email Backlog" consists of any email which came in earlier than today but hasn't yet been dealt with. The idea is that it prevents the older email being pushed to one side by new email. It seems to work because it spends most of its time empty!
16 June 2015 at 22:44 | Mark Forster
-
Mark - re: NEO
If you have much of a backlog try adding a task "Active Folders/Active mail" (or Unread/Unread).
You can choose these under the Filter tab, Folder and Status. If you haven't discovered this yet it's a slick way to get thru a lot of email quickly. You can add these buttons (as well as Clear and Disable) to the quick access toolbar by right clicking on them.
16 June 2015 at 23:28 | Zane
-
I get several emails every day which need more attention, maybe some more careful reading, thinking, or an extensive reply, or just some one-off action that will take 5-20 minutes to complete. These aren't project-related -- they are often new requests/demands that need attention. How would you handle this kind of email? They aren't easy handled as part of my "clear email" task. (Also, in all these cases, it's necessary, as part of closing out the implied task, to have easy access back to the email, in order to reply, re-read, etc.)
17 June 2015 at 0:41 | Seraphim
-
Zane:
<< If you have much of a backlog try adding a task "Active Folders/Active mail" (or Unread/Unread). >>
The way I do it is to add a "backlog" tag to all yesterday's mail which is still "Active" at the beginning of the day, using the Categorize menu item. I have the "backlog" tag marked as "Hot" so the backlog folder shows up under the Hot tab - I prefer to have it in the left panel along with the other Hot folders rather than on the Easy Access bar.
Then I remove the active status of all the emails in the folder so they don't show up in the Active folder, and make them all Unread so that the title of the "backlog" folder shows the total number of emails in it (I have the option set in all my folders for displaying the number of unread emails).
When I've dealt with an email I remove the "backlog" tag from it, it disappears from the folder and the total figure after the folder title adjusts accordingly.
17 June 2015 at 1:45 | Mark Forster
-
Seraphim:
<< I get several emails every day which need more attention...They aren't easy handled as part of my "clear email" task.>>
Why not? It's how I'd handle them.
<< (Also, in all these cases, it's necessary, as part of closing out the implied task, to have easy access back to the email, in order to reply, re-read, etc.) >>
In NEO I'd achieve this by tagging and/or flagging. While I'm still working on the email I'd keep it with Active status.
17 June 2015 at 1:53 | Mark Forster
-
Thanks Mark. Let me repeat back what I think you are saying (based on what you've written here and in your other FVP examples), to make sure I am understanding it clearly.
When you work on your recurring task "email", you try to clear all your new emails in one go:
- if a new email is project-related, you tag the email with a project tag, and enter the project name on your FVP list
- if a new email needs larger action that you can't complete right now, you flag it as "Active" (or, if all your incoming emails are automatically flagged as Active, you just leave it flagged that way) (I believe NEO gives you some options here, how to use the "Active" indicator)
- otherwise, reply or take action on the new email as needed, then delete/deactivate/archive the email
- if you still have any Active emails that arrived today, you try to clear them out
- if any Active emails are still on your list from the previous day, you tag them as Email Backlog and get them off your Active list, which is reserved for emails that arrived today that still need action
When you work on your task "email backlog", which you enter on your list whenever any Active emails from the previous day are still needing to be processed, you try to clear out all the emails tagged with "Email Backlog": take action, finish them off, or delete if no longer needed.
Is that basically correct?
If yes, I would imagine that on some days, if you happen to get a lot of one-off emails that each require a lot of time to complete the associated actions, you might end up with an email backlog that lasts for a few days?
I also imagine you'd aim to keep the email backlog as a "closed list". And if you find yourself adding to it before finishing what's already there, then this would be a sign that you can't keep up with your email, and need to re-evaluate your commitments that are generating so much of it, or maybe come up with better ways to delegate, filter out less relevant emails like reading material, etc.
Is that about right? Please let me know if I got this wrong -- this is probably one of the hardest areas for me right now with using FVP [or AFP as I have been tending to call it, after you noticed it's more like AF than FV! :-) ]
17 June 2015 at 6:24 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim:
<< When you work on your recurring task "email", you try to clear all your new emails in one go: >>
No, I just work on email for as long as I feel like and then re-enter "Email" as a task at the end of the list. I will do some work on email multiple times during the day.
<< - if a new email is project-related, you tag the email with a project tag, and enter the project name on your FVP list >>
No, this is far too much like hard work and would be an example of how one can bog a system down by over-organizing everything. I *only* tag emails with a project name if I need to take action on several emails as a group (see the example of arranging a meeting date in one of my previous posts to you in this thread). In other words I only do it if I need to. My default policy is no tags, no flags.
<< if a new email needs larger action that you can't complete right now, you flag it as "Active"... otherwise, reply or take action on the new email as needed, then delete/deactivate/archive the email>>
Emails are automatically flagged as Active and the "Active" folder is what I'm working from. Once I've finished with an email I remove the Active designation (which is just a matter of using the backspace key). The email then vanishes from the "Active" folder.
<< if you still have any Active emails that arrived today, you try to clear them out >>
I'm dealing with email multiple times a day but am not particularly aiming to clear them out. I just do what I feel like doing. Most days though I do clear everything. If not, I don't worry about it.
<< if any Active emails are still on your list from the previous day, you tag them as Email Backlog and get them off your Active list, which is reserved for emails that arrived today that still need action >>
Correct.
<< When you work on your task "email backlog", which you enter on your list whenever any Active emails from the previous day are still needing to be processed, you try to clear out all the emails tagged with "Email Backlog": take action, finish them off, or delete if no longer needed. >>
I'm dealing with the email backlog multiple times a day but am not particularly aiming to clear it out. I just do what I feel like doing. The only email I ever delete is spam.
<< Is that basically correct? >>
Yes, except that you've managed to make it sound much harder work than it actually is!
<< If yes, I would imagine that on some days, if you happen to get a lot of one-off emails that each require a lot of time to complete the associated actions, you might end up with an email backlog that lasts for a few days? >>
Yes, for instance I was away for three days in Paris over the weekend and it took me a couple of days to clear the backlog after I got back.
<< I also imagine you'd aim to keep the email backlog as a "closed list". And if you find yourself adding to it before finishing what's already there, then this would be a sign that you can't keep up with your email, and need to re-evaluate your commitments that are generating so much of it >>
Yes, if I really was falling behind and it wasn't just a temporary spike (like last weekend).
<<, or maybe come up with better ways to delegate, filter out less relevant emails like reading material, etc. >>
With serious reading matter I'd probably send the file to Evernote, which is better equipped for such stuff, and deal with it as a separate task. This would normally be stuff which would take more than one read to get through.
There are a few newsletters and suchlike which I already filter out of my email. They are sent direct into a separate Outlook folder for each newsletter, and I can scan quickly down them each now and then to see if there's anything of interest. I get NEO to mark them as "Unread" but not as "Active". These are the only Outlook folders I have, apart from the obvious Inbox, Sent Mail, etc.
<< Is that about right? >>
Yes, except that I get the feeling that you want to over-organize it. I have made this system as simple as I possibly can, and my default rule is "No flags, no tags." These things are available for when I need them, but only when I need them.
17 June 2015 at 10:15 | Mark Forster
-
Thanks, Mark, this is helpful. No, I don't want to over-organize it -- I also like simple and elegant processes, of which you are a master craftsman. I just want to make sure I understand what you are doing, at a detailed level, with specific examples, and that's exactly what you wrote. :-) It's given me some good ideas. Thanks again.
17 June 2015 at 21:05 | Seraphim
-
hi all,
I committed to using FVP for 30 days with no changes, tweaks, etc. So far it's by far the best time/task management system i've used. And I've used them all.
I find it flexible, adaptive to my mood and workload, and nothing has slipped through the cracks yet.
Thanks,
brett
17 June 2015 at 23:46 | brett
-
brett:
Are you using FVP as it was released, with the original question, or the no-question way?
18 June 2015 at 3:25 | Michael B.
-
I'm really finding that breaking down my inboxes to 'paper' 'email' 'voicemail' has broken down resistance lots, I'm loving it.
18 June 2015 at 11:03 | Leon
-
Just a thought I've had while cranking through my FVP list today: FVP boosts my productivity because the chain is a no-brainer. Once I've chosen a chain of tasks that stand out, I just line up and do them. No further thinking or evaluating is necessary. When I'm done with task, I enjoy crossing it off, and then I immediately look to the next task as a potential source of positive reinforcement if I can cross it off as well.
20 June 2015 at 21:03 | Lenore
-
I took a few excursions into trying to manage my lists in OneNote, rather than on paper. It had the (apparent) advantage of being able to capture tasks "with details attached". Ideas, projects, reminders to myself captured with Siri, emails that need action, etc., are all easy to capture in OneNote. But the list would get really long, really quickly, and the number of selected tasks would get too large (because so many things would "stand out", despite Mark's posts about how to control what stands out).
So I am currently trying a different approach, based on the way Mark describes his email handling, above. I'm trying to treat my emails in basically the same way, and also treat my OneNote stuff the same way. It's not really working very well yet, but I'll keep at it and see if I can get it to work.
22 June 2015 at 1:07 | Seraphim
-
As an aside, I think the reason so many things would "stand out", despite all of Mark's suggestions (which are excellent and really have made a difference), is that I'd have a hard time keeping "in tune" with the list. The list would be too long, and it would be too much to process all at once. I'd feel the need to group it somehow. I'd grab all the stuff in my OneNote list that "stood out" -- it would often be 10-20 items. Then I'd go through THAT list and pull out what "stood out" even more. And maybe repeat a third time. Finally I'd have a short list -- interestingly, it would almost always be (1) a handful of quick tasks, or (2) a bunch of related tasks I need to do as a single group. Working through these short list was a BREEZE, always super easy.
This led me to try basing my whole system around this repeated-standing-out-and-grouping model. But it got really complicated, how to interleave these groups of things, with new incoming items.
In retrospect, I was totally overthinking the problem.
So now I've made two changes, and they are working OK for now, still needs some getting used to, but I am liking it, and I am able to get that "grouping into a short easy list" feeling:
(1) I just spin off a separate list as needed, going through the AFP list and pulling out whatever I need. This can bring immediate clarity to the list, and helps "weed" the list too. I've just been writing ad-hoc lists on the left-hand page of the notebook, or sometimes using a sheet in the back of the notebook. In my Moleskine, the pages in back are tear-off sheets, so I can just rip it out if needed and go work that separate list for a bit.
(2) Rather than treating OneNote as my main list, I just treat it like another inbox. I capture all kinds of notes, emails, voice memos, screen shots, web clippings, etc., in OneNote, into a QuickNotes page. I keep the main list in my Moleskine notebook, and I keep a "Quicknotes" task on there.
22 June 2015 at 1:15 | Seraphim
-
(Another aside - I agree with Mark that Questionless FVP "feels" a lot more like AF1 than FV, so I've been calling it AFP = Autofocus Perfected, as Mark suggested. But that doesn't seem to be catching on, so maybe I should just call in Questionless FVP like everyone else.)
22 June 2015 at 1:26 | Seraphim
-
Lenore,
The system you describe sounds like FV (1.select a short list; 2. do it; repeat from 1...) rather than FVP (1. select a short list; 2. do the first; 3. select 0 or more tasks below to add to the short list; repeat from 2...). Am I misunderstanding?
Whichever, the main thing is that it's working!
Cheers,
Will
22 June 2015 at 11:57 | Will
-
Will:
You are right! Sorry about that. I guess I was proceeding by intuition after having previously read the instructions for FV, FVP, and questionless FVP.
So now having re-read the instructions, I realize that what I'm really doing is a questionless form of FV but doing the preselected list in the reverse order of what Mark instructs.
Well, at least, as you said, it's working for me!
Sorry for inadvertently hijacking the FVP thread....
22 June 2015 at 13:51 | Lenore
-
Seraphim: I do like the name "AFP," because I work my list as AF1 part of the time anyway. It's a short jump from there to AFP.
On the other hand, page breaks and dismissals are key to AF1, and irrelevant in AFP. Those are serious differences.
On the other other hand (because I don't want three-armed mutants to feel left out), FVP came from FV which came from AF4, so who says this can't be AFP?
Alternatively, it could be "FVP-Q" for "Final Version Perfected Minus the Question."
Whatever its official name, I think it deserves a special place of honor on the "TM Systems" page!
22 June 2015 at 16:27 | JulieBulie
-
Lenore,
The difference really isn't obvious until you actually try the FVP rules, when it becomes VERY clear. I would bet that you are not the only one who hadn't quite taken it on board. So it's really helpful to have exactly this discussion.
Thank you.
22 June 2015 at 17:38 | Will
-
JulieBulie,
On the subject of three handers:
I am happy to still have full sized right and left hands.
In addition, I am ashamed to admit that I've got a little behind hand.
Back to my list!!
Cheers,
Will
22 June 2015 at 17:42 | Will
-
HA!
22 June 2015 at 20:10 | JulieBulie
-
What Mark has come up with is an efficient sorting method or algorithm. If you follow the FVP rules with a list of random numbers you'll find that it sorts the numbers from largest to smallest perfectly and efficiently every time. So your list of tasks will also sort perfectly from "largest" to "smallest" every time (assuming you've accurately assigned priority).
If you change Mark's rules you're probably making the algorithm less efficient, probably by causing yourself to reevaluate priorities you've already made a decision about. You'll see this if you try FVP'ing the list of random numbers. When you cross a number off the list you only have to compare those below it to the nearest dotted number above it. No need to reevaluate those in between the two.
Work halfway through the list of random numbers and add new numbers to it (like adding new tasks to your ongoing todo list). Follow the rules and the largest numbers are once again selected perfectly and efficiently. (This is why you do more work at the end of the list. Numbers [tasks] 'left behind' at the top of the list are, of course, smaller numbers (less important tasks). Odds are that new random numbers [tasks] added to the list will be larger [more important].)
And what question do you use, if you choose to use one at all? If, at the end of the day, you had done all your tasks in the optimum order what question would have given you that order? What question would properly assign numbers so the FVP algorithm sorts them into the proper order? My guess is the quetion changes. What do I want/need/have to do before X? What is wiser/smarter/weightier/more valuable to do than X?
23 June 2015 at 0:09 | Zane
-
Zane:
<< And what question do you use, if you choose to use one at all? If, at the end of the day, you had done all your tasks in the optimum order what question would have given you that order? >>
How about telling your mind to dot tasks in the optimum order? This is essentially what you are (or should be) doing in no-question FVP.
23 June 2015 at 8:19 | Mark Forster
-
Further to my last post, one could in theory write out what one intends to do during the day and then use FVP to re-write the list in optimal order. All you have to do then is just bang through the list in the order written for an optimal work experience!
I wouldn't actually advise doing this (except perhaps as an experiment) for several reasons:
1) It would make no allowance for your shifts in mood and energy during the day.
2) You wouldn't be able to include additional tasks added during the day.
3) You wouldn't be able to re-enter tasks to have another go at them the same day.
4) You wouldn't be able to respond to a change in priorities.
FVP as written deals with all four of these effortlessly.
23 June 2015 at 8:55 | Mark Forster
-
And further to my post above:
It occurs to me that one could remove the four disadvantages of a pre-sorted list by using FVP in the normal way on the pre-sorted list itself. In theory at least, you would then do everything in the list order except for where 1) to 4) applied.
Maybe that's just getting too devious!
23 June 2015 at 10:04 | Mark Forster
-
Or you could bang through the short list in FV mode until the need to check stands out, and then switch to FVP, checking the tasks below the last completed. I can't see why this shouldn't work just fine.
I find myself wanting to do this but I'm still at the stage of trying to run the process as written to get a deep understanding bedded in.
23 June 2015 at 10:31 | Will
-
Hi Will: Your comment really interested me: "Or you could bang through the short list in FV mode until the need to check stands out, and then switch to FVP, checking the tasks below the last completed. I can't see why this shouldn't work just fine."
I've been battling with this. For example, what happened to me today is that it started out with emails and phone calls, and it was late afternoon before I could catch my breath. I ended up with many, many new priorities and urgent items (most already scattered throughout the list, but just not in the RIGHT ORDER).
So, it is taking me willpower at this point to not just drop my system and start picking things one by one. However, I feel that, in the end, I will end up feeling frustrated and defeating the whole purpose.
But am I thinking right? If you are working off a short list, and you want to go back to that item on the long list (FVP) and scan down from that just-completed task as per the rules, who knows where on the main FVP list that item might be located (and how significant a scan-down from that item would be)?
I think as time goes on, and your priorities gain some control, this desire or need to deviate from the standard FVP will be rare. But, without the short list, I guess the drawback is having to re-write so many tasks at the end of the list. But what can you do? Anyway, the whole thing as it stands is so simple, it's great. Why mess it up? Thanks.
23 June 2015 at 12:49 | BKK
-
BKK
Presumably the new ones will be below the task you've just finished? The point of both FVs is to reduce the scan to it's minimum size.
I think the "short list" is just the dotted items on the long list. There isn't a separate list.
If you really have boggled and lost confidence that your latest task was still the one to work on next, you can always simply strike out and rewrite at the bottom all your dotted tasks until you are confident you are above the real priorities, then standard FVP will highlight them and work them in an appropriate order.
Or just strike out your dots and start again. I THINK Mark advises continuing through the tasks. Which shouldn't take more than a few seconds, if you've kept the short list to about five or less.
23 June 2015 at 13:21 | Will
-
Will:
<< Or you could bang through the short list in FV mode until the need to check stands out, and then switch to FVP, checking the tasks below the last completed. >>
What short list? I'm talking about using FVP to re-write your *entire* list for the day in the optimal order.
There'd be no need to use FV. The tasks are already in the correct order.
To save time you could mark the end of the sorted list and then only scan tasks which have been entered after that marker.
However remember it takes quite a long time to sort and rewrite the list in correct order in the first place!
Like I said, I don't really advise it except possibly as an experiment.
23 June 2015 at 14:12 | Mark Forster
-
BKK:
<< I've been battling with this. For example, what happened to me today is that it started out with emails and phone calls, and it was late afternoon before I could catch my breath. I ended up with many, many new priorities and urgent items (most already scattered throughout the list, but just not in the RIGHT ORDER). >>
This shouldn't be a problem. FVP is very good at dealing with shifting priorities like this. Things don't have to be in the right order to get done quickly. The only thing which can throw it out is when a sudden change in priorities results in a newly urgent task being buried under a long chain of dots, in which case you can either:
1) Re-prioritize the entire chain, or
2) Cross out the buried task and re-enter it at the end of the list.
I recommend 2) in most cases.
<< So, it is taking me willpower at this point to not just drop my system and start picking things one by one. >>
You can pick things one by one without dropping the system. There's no rule which says that you have to dot more than one task at a time. And it's perfectly ok to omit or skim the full scan if you know or suspect that there are no tasks which are likely to stand out beyond where you've got to.
23 June 2015 at 14:25 | Mark Forster
-
Mark Forster wrote:
<< It occurs to me that one could remove the four disadvantages of a pre-sorted list by using FVP in the normal way on the pre-sorted list itself. In theory at least, you would then do everything in the list order except for where 1) to 4) applied. >>
Speaking of experiments, that's essentially what I was trying to do in OneNote (described earlier in this thread,
http://markforster.squarespace.com/fv-forum/post/2509559#post2516253 )
You quickly run into the problem of what to do with new incoming items while you work through the selected selected tasks. Do you treat new tasks as part of your new FVP shortlist, or do you treat them as part of the larger list and ignore them till your shortlist is done? The former causes your shortlist to get a lot longer very quickly, and gives new stuff more priority than existing undotted things. The latter makes the system unresponsive to urgency and changing priorities/energy/mood.
As another experiment, I tried doing the same thing in my notebook, with a complex double-dotting method, but it quickly got out of hand, LOL! It had the same problems on how to handle new items while working the shortlist.
23 June 2015 at 15:20 | Seraphim
-
Mark,
The short list is simply the dotted tasks on the long list. I was thinking back to Lenore's comment about not having to think about the process but simply bang through the selected tasks. Sorry this wasn't clear.
I was suggesting that you don't necessarily need to commit to either FV or FVP. You could work FV for the efficiency of working closed lists and switch to FVP when the need stands out to you.
But first, I want to spend more time on FVP until it's second nature. Then I might no longer feel the cost of the review after each task, so there would be less reason to use FV in the first place.
23 June 2015 at 15:26 | Will
-
Zane wrote:
<< What Mark has come up with is an efficient sorting method or algorithm. >>
The Questionless variant has no comparative question, but I think this makes it even MORE effective as a sorting mechanism.
One thing I've learned from Agile is that trying to be very precise in setting priorities ahead of time is really a form of waste, especially in a dynamic environment. It's better to do a very rough ranking of your priorities, and then get more focused and precise about the things that come in near the top of the list. Questionless FVP does this more effectively than FVP, I think.
23 June 2015 at 15:28 | Seraphim
-
Will:
"I was suggesting that you don't necessarily need to commit to either FV or FVP. You could work FV for the efficiency of working closed lists and switch to FVP when the need stands out to you."
I'm trying a kind of "time based switch" between FV and FVP.
FV let me be very focused: once selected a chain, I execute the tasks one after the other without distractions.
FVP is a little bit heavy for me: i sometimes feel resistance in scanning the list over and over again after the execution of each task, but this mode gives me the opportunity to always work on the most relevant task.
To balance the pros and cons of FV and FVP i'm following this approach:
I generally work in FV mode.... but at the beginning of each hour (at work) I switch to FVP for a while.
24 June 2015 at 13:29 | nick61
-
Will:
Yes, the new items were below the task just finished. However, my "short list" was not simply a list of the dotted items; they consisted of new and already-listed-but-scattered items. So, it is now clear (to me, anyway) that if we wittingly or unwittingly end up with a short list, all kinds of adverse things can happen if we let it go on for too long or too often (like with Mark's points 1-4 above).
And now, this exercise is causing me to re-read Seraphim's link above where he discusses his experiments in OneNote and getting a "grouping into a short easy list" feeling (and the excellently-worded synopsis just below that link - like dealing with the new/incoming in the short list vs. with the long list).
Because I think our current moods and priorities are like whims - only to be replaced by something else, and sometimes very quickly.
I appreciate and agree with your other comments. I also like Mark's simplified solution:
<< FVP is very good at dealing with shifting priorities like this. Things don't have to be in the right order to get done quickly. The only thing which can throw it out is when a sudden change in priorities results in a newly urgent task being buried under a long chain of dots, in which case you can either:
1) Re-prioritize the entire chain, or
2) Cross out the buried task and re-enter it at the end of the list.
I recommend 2) in most cases.>>
So, in the end, I like the idea of staying with the long list and do as what Mark recommends, and also use a short lists as a tool if done properly, minimally and the time is right. It can't be too bad to turn away from our main system temporarily, commit to a few items (not just one), and then, bang, bang, bang, do them.
24 June 2015 at 13:41 | BKK
-
I'm using both FV & FVP:
1. I dot the first active task on the list.
2. I scan down the list dotting tasks that stand out.
3. I do the last dotted task on the list.
4. I dip down to the end of the list after doing each task and dot any tasks that stand out.
5. When I eventually reach the first dotted task, I do it. Then I return to step 1.
The faster you get those oldest tasks into play at the end of your list, the more opportunities they will have to be selected.
24 June 2015 at 15:36 | Michael B.
-
Michael B.
<< I'm using both FV & FVP:
1. I dot the first active task on the list.
2. I scan down the list dotting tasks that stand out.
3. I do the last dotted task on the list.
4. I dip down to the end of the list after doing each task and dot any tasks that stand out.
5. When I eventually reach the first dotted task, I do it. Then I return to step 1. >>
But that *is* FVP. Where does FV come into it?
24 June 2015 at 19:21 | Mark Forster
-
In a post yesterday I said:
"And it's perfectly ok to omit or skim the full scan if you know or suspect that there are no tasks which are likely to stand out beyond where you've got to. "
I'd like to add that it's also perfectly ok to omit or skim the scan if you don't *want* any more tasks to stand out, i.e. you want to work on the already dotted tasks only for a period. In which case you are basically doing what you do with FV.
Using this principle you can turn FV on and off as and when you wish without actually leaving FVP.
24 June 2015 at 19:27 | Mark Forster
-
Mark:
"But that *is* FVP. Where does FV come into it?"
You're right, that is FVP! For whatever reason I've been doing it wrong the whole time! Ha. The rare times I've actually made it back to the first task I've been in the habit of starting over! Scanning back down the list and dotting tasks again, from the beginning. I think when you first introduced FVP, I saw the description of how one might never do the first task and formed an impression of what that meant. I guess I can now join the rest of you in actually using FVP. Ha!
24 June 2015 at 23:03 | Michael B.
-
nick61
"i sometimes feel resistance in scanning the list over and over again after the execution of each task"
You're only scanning downward from the task you just finished, comparing it to the nearest dotted task above, right? Try following the rules with a list of random numbers and you'll see that FVP is very efficient, it minimizes scanning.
25 June 2015 at 0:09 | Zane
-
Michael B.
<< The rare times I've actually made it back to the first task I've been in the habit of starting over! Scanning back down the list and dotting tasks again, from the beginning. >>
Do you mean you were re-scanning from the first task *before* you did it?
25 June 2015 at 9:10 | Mark Forster
-
Zane:
<< FVP is very efficient, it minimizes scanning. >>
It hadn't occurred to me before, but I think you are right. There is less scanning in FVP than in FV.
25 June 2015 at 9:17 | Mark Forster
-
Mark:
"Do you mean you were re-scanning from the first task *before* you did it?"
Yep. Ha. Went right back to step 1: Dot the first active task on the list. "Oh, hey! Look at that. The first task is already dotted. And I may never have to do it, either. Great! I'll just scan down this list of mine, see if there's something I want to do more than that, and, mhmm, I'll dot that one there, and this one, and, oh, that one over there...dot, dot, dot. Hooray! Resisted task avoided."
25 June 2015 at 11:32 | Michael B.