-
Mark - why not sell this as an e-book on the site?
25 January 2010 at 9:12 | Man of Kent
-
If I did, what would you be willing to pay?
25 January 2010 at 10:36 | Mark Forster
-
Depends on the content. How long? What's the table of contents? For eBooks, I generally expect about 20 pages, and would pay a couple dollars [to you, that's 1 pound] on the rare occasion I find the topic useful.
25 January 2010 at 13:05 | Alan Baljeu
-
" If I did, what would you be willing to pay? "
I'd pay, if only to compensate you for all your free advice, systems and helpful board. I believe most of the regulars feel this way.
25 January 2010 at 13:44 | Avrum
-
Hi Mark and All,
I would pay gladly....Mark, you deserve this and I cannot think of anyone MORE deserving.
-David
25 January 2010 at 13:59 | David Drake
-
Hello Mark,
bought DIT today from Amazon for 9.98 EUR.
Let's say DIT2 ist just a supplement for DIT (so you need to buy DIT for fully understanding DIT2). The price range i think would be fair is 5.99 EUR - 7.99 EUR, assuming the ebook has more than 10 pages of real content.
If DIT2 is a complete book on it's own, i would be willing to pay 9.99 - 12.99 EUR.
If DIT2 is a supplement for DIT plus all the collected wisdom from your webpage and forum, i would pay up to 9.99 EUR.
scameronde
25 January 2010 at 15:30 | scameronde
-
Alan:
<< I... would pay a couple dollars [to you, that's 1 pound] on the rare occasion I find the topic useful.>>
Hardly worth the trouble of setting it up then!
25 January 2010 at 15:31 | Mark Forster
-
Avrum:
<< I'd pay, if only to compensate you for all your free advice, systems and helpful board. I believe most of the regulars feel this way. >>
The problem is that there are only about 20-30 regulars so again that's hardly going to be worth the trouble of charging.
25 January 2010 at 15:33 | Mark Forster
-
Mark, I wholeheartedly echo David and Avrum's comments. Other than that it would be difficult to estimate an appropriate price without details of the product being offered.
25 January 2010 at 16:02 | Leon
-
I fear you're right Mark. Although I would pay more for your particular book, eBooks aren't big money makers unless they are marketed, or funnel people into some other money maker. You need to get a bigger audience somehow.
25 January 2010 at 16:26 | Alan Baljeu
-
"You need to get a bigger audience somehow."
This is true. But Mark seems to lack the required narcissism and new-age charisma to draw in a large audience.
25 January 2010 at 16:31 | Avrum
-
I would pay $20 for your average paper book. Free 1-chapter eBooks are a good way to advertise that book.
Tell a little about your system, explain something useful, and then promise the real book has the rest.
25 January 2010 at 16:31 | Alan Baljeu
-
<<would pay a couple dollars [to you, that's 1 pound]>>
You would pay about 1,60$/1 pound? A little on the cheap side, don't you think? scameronde's prices seem more realistic.
Anyway, Mark, if you're concerned about the relation between effort and profit, you can still simply put up a paypal donation button and be done with it. Your regulars will donate generously, newcomers may donate more or less generously when they like what you offer them here. It's better than nothing and comes with minimal effort on your part.
25 January 2010 at 16:35 | Andreas Hofmann
-
I agree with Andreas.
I'm sure I received much, much more than $50 worth of benefit from AF (and this site). However, for now, I'd be willing to donate $50 & I'm in the process of purchasing DIT.
25 January 2010 at 16:49 | Avrum
-
Andreas:
Thanks for the renewed suggestion re Donations Button. I'll give it some thought.
25 January 2010 at 16:59 | Mark Forster
-
Mark - I'd be willing to pay £5 for the instructions - I would only be expecting instructions similar to those produced for AF, not a full e-book.
25 January 2010 at 17:34 | Man of Kent
-
One thing to consider is that there are a lot of lurkers on here that just read but don't feel like they have a lot to offer (and thus don't post) but would gladly donate.
I guess since I'm posting here I might as well give my two cents on what I think you should do.
1. Publish the instructions (let's say as a 5 page ebook) with a suggested minimum donation (e.g. $5) I think this is really important, many people won't donate if they don't have an amount.
2. Ask people to only spread the instructions via the website or if they summarize in a blog post to also include a link for more details and donations.
3. Finally (and here's the key to making this a success) tell everyone that you will work on a full book (self or publisher published) if you get a certain number of minimum donations(say 1000 or 5000 or whatever.) This can act as kind of a publisher's advance by giving you upfront cash, while also showing you that enough people are interested to justify the time and effort put in to a real book. This also makes all the regulars feel empowered since they can go out and tweet about it to encourage people to read the instructions (and hopefully donate) in order to get a potential book out of it.
Anyway just some thoughts. Hopefully you can derive something of value here. And thanks again to you Mark for the systems and also to all the regulars for the great discussions!
Chris
25 January 2010 at 17:43 | ChrisK
-
Regarding "there are only about 20-30 regulars" -- Are you basing that on who comments or statistics from your site? I've only posted twice but I check the site daily. I wonder how many other lurkers are here? You might have a wider audience than you think.
25 January 2010 at 17:44 | Michael E
-
25 January 2010 at 17:49 | Michael E
-
Thanks to all for the suggestions. Perhaps we'd better keep the discussion for when I actually have some instructions to sell! At the moment it's still very much a work in progress.
25 January 2010 at 18:11 | Mark Forster
-
Mark, I do believe that you are deserving of compensation for your great insights and tinkering. However I would also be hesitant to push the e-book thing for a couple of reasons. First, releasing systems free does not create nearly the expectation that someone who pays may expect. I'm not talking strictly about forum members, but potential new members and the public at large. We all see you creating new things, tinkering with them and understand the amount of time that goes into it-someone who stumbles upon the ebook and buys it will not have that background. As you've conceded before, one time management system doesn't do it for everyone and AF certainly didn't work for me.
Second, although you test these systems, I think you'd agree that they become better when done open source so others can troubleshoot them and find problems.
Maybe the happy medium is a brief period where it is free to download or a donate button as others have mentioned.
25 January 2010 at 18:11 | TK
-
I'd pay and I'm a lurker.
Be sure to set up for credit cards, not just paypal
25 January 2010 at 18:34 | gghays
-
Regarding expectations - I have the Zen-to-done ebook. It's pretty fullsome - I edited it into Word becuase I wanted to print it out and read it and make notes and it comes to over 35 pages of text. I was very happy with what I got for my money. I think it is all about managing people's expectations.
25 January 2010 at 18:37 | Alison R
-
I think it's challenging for some people to pay for "value received" from something such as an eBook versus the "size" of that same thing (e.g. page count, chapters, etc.). A 5-page eBook may not be worth $5, if you can buy a 50-page eBook from someone else for the same price. But the value received from a 5-page Mark Forster eBook could easily offer over $500 in value to the reader, if taken to heart.
In reality, I expect most productivity eBooks available today fall short of their authors' revenue expectations, and just create another mess to be managed by their own productivity system. :-)
Charging for something that used to be free can also polarize Mark's fan base. I understand that DIT was not free, but AF is, and Mark would likely take a hit in popularity from the casual visitor.
Better to sod it and enjoy a stress-free retirement...
25 January 2010 at 19:30 | Brian
-
Long time lurker and more than willing to pay.
25 January 2010 at 20:10 | Jake
-
Mark - You could open a thread inviting all 'lurkers' to send a post letting you know they're there, and asking how often they read the forum? Or would that overwhelm the system (as I expect there are lots)? It would be an interesting exercise, whether or not you used the information to decide about charging. For my part, I'd be more than willing to give a donation and/or buy the DIT2 book if you write one. Best wishes.
25 January 2010 at 20:30 | Margaret1
-
I guess I'm one of the lurkers, with an odd post every now and then, and also willing to donate ...
25 January 2010 at 20:57 | JMTee
-
The Lurkers... sounds like a b-rated horror movie from the 70s.
25 January 2010 at 22:06 | Avrum
-
Lurkers reveal yourselves...
25 January 2010 at 22:08 | Leon
-
As an on-and-off poster, I would buy a DIT2-book, in addition to the DIT-book I already bought thanks to this forum. I'd prefer a physical book, but an e-book would do also. I'd also appreciate a Donate-button!
25 January 2010 at 22:24 | Nicole
-
Long-time lurker. Will pay gladly.
25 January 2010 at 22:43 | Ilse
-
I actually sold my ebook which was 11 pages for $5 us and made a reasonable amount of sales. When I look back at the time spent writing, editing and promoting, I am sure I lost money, but it was a fun and valuable experience.
Mark it is pretty easy to use some of the ebook and pdf file hosts which charge either a small flat fee or percentage of sales. Once it is set up it can sell forever via a link.
I decided to make all of my content free as the time management niche is hard to monetize unless you do the full blown GTD route with an organization, DVDs, training and a series of books etc and really promote it. Someone on here told me simplicity does not sell well and they are right. When you tell people to be a GTD black belt takes two years versus using my simple system on a legal pad or AF or DIT, you loose lots of people who like the "cache" of GTD and the complexities of it.
That said, I would gladly pay or donate up to $10 for the new instructions as to me it is not the length of the content but the quality of the ideas that matter. Mark has given enough away for free to convince me his ideas are very worthwhile and to buy DIT and I will gladly pay for the next set of ideas.
Gerry
http://www.simple-time-management.com 25 January 2010 at 23:05 | Gerry
-
Long time lurker with few odd posts here and there. Willing to donate gladly...
25 January 2010 at 23:08 | Greenchutney
-
My thoughts at the moment - which may change:
1) I will publish the new system as a supplement to DIT. It won't be very long - probably only a few paragraphs.
2) I will mention the supplement on the DIT page of amazon as available on my website.
3) I will put a donate button on this site, and specifically on the page on which the supplement appears.
4) I will ask my publishers to include the supplement in future printings of the book.
26 January 2010 at 0:18 | Mark Forster
-
5) I will remember that Canada was a British colony, as such, I will make sure that my books are carried by chapters/indigo.
26 January 2010 at 4:10 | Avrum
-
Avrum:
<< I will make sure that my books are carried by chapters/indigo. >>
Apart from the fact that I have no idea what chapters/indigo is (are?), such decisions are entirely out of my hands.
26 January 2010 at 8:25 | Mark Forster
-
I would gladly donate,even before DIT2 comes out if there is a donate button set up.
May I suggest you set it up ASAP because I am sure there are many wellwishers like me
who have benefited from AF and will continue to do so through DIT2.
Jay
26 January 2010 at 11:08 | Jay
-
26 January 2010 at 11:19 | Rainer
-
Thanks, Rainer. I've learnt something new today!
26 January 2010 at 11:38 | Mark Forster
-
Chapters/Indigo - largest bookseller in Canada
26 January 2010 at 13:10 | Avrum
-
Mark Forster wrote:
<<My thoughts at the moment - which may change:
2) I will mention the supplement on the DIT page of amazon as available on my website.
3) I will put a donate button on this site, and specifically on the page on which the supplement appears.
4) I will ask my publishers to include the supplement in future printings of the book.>>
I think this is a smart idea. If nothing else, it will likely spur book sales through existing distribution channels. And I'm sure current DIT/AF practitioners wouldn't mind re-purchasing the supplemented DIT as a show of support, and/or donating on the site.
Simplicity!
26 January 2010 at 13:14 | Brian
-
hmmmm
My current DIT is quite dog-earred and crowded with notes on the margins....perhaps it's time to buy a fresh copy! Mark, should I hold off until the revised copy is published? I'm an oldish bird. I prefer books to electronic reading. I don't need to boot up a book! Plus, I love the accompanying tactile and even olfactory sensations! lol! (No, I don't sniff books as a peculiar fettish! )
learning as I go
26 January 2010 at 13:28 | learning as I go
-
"f nothing else, it will likely spur book sales through existing distribution channels. "
Brian - I ordered DIT last night!
26 January 2010 at 13:55 | Avrum
-
Avrum:
It's currently 1,942 in the Amazon UK best sellers list. It'll be interesting to see what happens to it over the next few weeks and months.
26 January 2010 at 16:56 | Mark Forster
-
Mark:
My sale won't change that # as I purchased via amazon.ca.
26 January 2010 at 18:03 | Avrum
-
Another long time lurker chipping in, will gladly pay/donate once the opportunity arises.
27 January 2010 at 1:20 | ChrisKe
-
I am a very occasional poster who has bought every Mark Forster book I could (I have previously ranted about how hard it is to get an affordable copy of Make Your Dreams Come True), and I will happily contribute in gratitude for a supplement to DIT.
28 January 2010 at 2:04 | Gorham
-
Just received my copy of DIT from Amazon today. Along with the others, I wholly support the idea of adding a small fee for DIT2. You deserve it Mark.
...Although I am not complaining if you just provide it to us for free ;-)
28 January 2010 at 3:14 | nuntym
-
Mark wrote:
<< My thoughts at the moment - which may change:
1) I will publish the new system as a supplement to DIT. It won't be very long - probably only a few paragraphs.
2) I will mention the supplement on the DIT page of amazon as available on my website.
3) I will put a donate button on this site, and specifically on the page on which the supplement appears.
4) I will ask my publishers to include the supplement in future printings of the book.>>
That would work ^____^
28 January 2010 at 3:18 | nuntym
-
Mark wrote:
3) I will put a donate button on this site, and specifically on the page on which the supplement appears.
If I were you I would create some workflow for the download. Ask people for their e-mail and country, give them an opportunity to subscribe to the newsletter and don't just offer a donation button, but integrate it within the process from putting the download in your shopping basket till downloading the book. I can imagine that you would prefill the donation with 5 EUR and give people the opportunity to set it to zero, or to a bigger amount.
29 January 2010 at 10:16 | Evelyne
-
Implemented right, it sounds like Evelyne has a great idea.
30 January 2010 at 16:48 | MartyH
-
Yes, I agree. But I still haven't got the system right - so it remains academic for the time being!
30 January 2010 at 17:37 | Mark Forster
-
Somehow I expect that you will.
31 January 2010 at 3:01 | MartyH
-
Yes, I am an occasional lurker/poster and would be willing to make a good donation for the DIT2. BTW, did anyone happen to notice the price for "How to Make Your Dreams Come True" on AmazonUS? $165 new and $69 used. I ordered it from AmazonUK for 20usd, now I see the price has gone up. Not bad for a time management book. I'm guessing it's out of print in the US. Good Luck with DIT2! Looks like you have a good following. (Bev P same as Bev...noticed there is another Bev, so wanted to distinguish).
31 January 2010 at 15:47 | Bev P.
-
Bev P:
<< I'm guessing it's out of print in the US. >>
It's out of print everywhere unfortunately, with no plans to reprint. I've thought about issuing it as an ebook, or even as a free download on this site, but I think I would want to do a considerable rewrite on it first.
31 January 2010 at 18:21 | Mark Forster
-
Mark
I bought "Dreams" when it first came out, and thought the ideas in it were really interesting. I have long hoped that you would let us know your thinking in this area as it has evolved since then. I would love to see a second edition/rewrite in one form or another, and would be prepared to pay for this too!
31 January 2010 at 21:58 | James T
-
James T:
Well, I'll put "Rewrite 'Dreams'" on my list. But somehow I think that at the moment it's likely to end up being dismissed!
31 January 2010 at 23:22 | Mark Forster