-
With AF2 I am getting stuck at the business end of the list. I find that the only way to get back to the "on notice" items is to leapfrog the rest of the list. The upshot now is that I have 25 tasks left on the list that will be "on notice" tomorrow.
This can't be right. What am I doing wrong?
14 July 2009 at 16:48 | Wooba
-
I feel your pain. I have the same problem. There seems to be no way, in AF2, to get back to the "on notice" items. Not everyone seems to have this problem. I'm repeatedly told that it will all work out. It has not worked out for about two weeks now.
In anticipation of somehow getting back to the beginning, I've suspended all dismissal. Not a good solution, but better than copying items back and forth from the AF list to the "someday/maybe" list. So now my AF2 list has become an old style TO DO list with me working on the most urgent items and occasionally tripping over old ones and doing them in the course of doing other things.
14 July 2009 at 16:53 | Mike
-
Why do the 'on notice' items stand out less than anything else?
Because they deserve and so need to be dismissed, surely.
14 July 2009 at 16:58 | smileypete
-
I have the same problem as well. I like that I am getting the urgent things done quicker, and I am not that worried about what I am dismissing (like smiley said they probably deserve to be dismissed) but there is good stuff in the middle of the list that I never get to as I keep starting over a the end and other things jump right out at me.
14 July 2009 at 17:09 | vegheadjones
-
OY! Smiley, not yet again!
Look, standout schmandout! If I can't SEE the fricken' things they are simply not there to STAND OUT! Sheeesh. I keep 'splainin' that and no one seems to hear me. A voice in the wilderness, that's me ;-)
The ONLY way an "on notice" task can "stand out" is if I were to start at the end and SKIP OVER ALL THE TASKS UNTIL I GOT TO THE BEGINNING. Otherwise, three or four tasks up from the bottom something "stands out" and I'm stuck there doing it for the rest of the day ... or that one and the next six others. Then, during the day, I add 15 more tasks, most of them URGENT and so THEY stand out ... like big ole sore thumbs ... which all conspires to keep me at the end of the list.
If I have 10 open pages on Monday, on Tuesday I'll have done a half dozen items on the last page and added another page so I'll have 11 open pages. On Wednesday, I'll have done a few of Tuesday's items, maybe one or two more of Monday's, but added yet another page of items. On Thursday, I'm even further behind, with now 12 open pages (ready to be 13) and being forced further and further away from the beginning of the list. I never get back to the beginning of the list except to mark items that live there as "on notice". (Unless they are so urgent that I pull them off of the AF list and put them on an index card so they WILL get done. But that is the ONLY way they will get done. They will never be seen in AF2 except to be marked for dismissal.)
And that is why I no longer dismiss anything. Which has wrecked the functioning of AF. And since I am forced to the end continually, pages do not close and so the list is growing arithmetically. I had about 18 pages on July 1st and this morning I have just started page number 35. By day's end, I'll bet I'm up to 36 or 37. I hold out no hope that a page will close.
I'm giving it until month's end to see if the magic everyone says will happen, happens. If not, then I'll re-do the AF2 rules force work at the first active page before going to the end. Much like the system mentioned by someone else.
So that is the story on "standing out". I'm taking time out of my tasks today to make a voodoo doll and I will assign it to the next person who tells me that the "on notice" tasks will "stand out" ... I'm collecting my pins now ;-)
14 July 2009 at 17:22 | Mike
-
I don't get the quick dismissal at all. I've read through the instructions a number of times and a bunch of AF2 threads, but it just doesn't jive with me. There's things on the list that I simply can't dismiss. That's why they call it work - you have to do a lot of it. Or dr. appointments - I need to make them, even if I haven't taken action yet. In terms of working backwards on the list, I kind of already did that with AF1. Also, I'm a little loose about which item I start on - I don't strictly stop at something at the end--I want to keep the rest of the list front and center, so I review the whole list at least once if not multiple times a day. The "dismissal" concept has been helping, even though I'm not actually dismissing something, because I am taking action on more things and either eliminating them or moving them forward on this list after taking some action.
14 July 2009 at 17:23 | Balfour
-
A couple of points. You do not have to work on each item in order from newest to oldest. You merely have to look at each to see what stands out. The reason you read through each item at the beginning of the day, is that it puts the whole list into your mind so you can filter what needs to be done, using a combination of the rational and intuitive.
What happens with most of us, is that if we really need to work on the items "to be dismissed" then we find that the newer items just don't stand out that much, even if they are fairly urgent, so we skip over them. Let's say I come to a task that is fairly new and one that I could easily and want to do, so it stands out somewhat. Whether it stands out enough for me to work on right now is determined by several factors--the need I have to get to older items, and the fact that I will certainly get back to this other task frequently. There is a force inside me that on some days moves me quickly through the list and on other days keeps me where the newest items are, all based on my overall contextual understanding of the whole list.
But if you are ready to dismiss 25 items at once, then your list may be too long or you have little discretionary time. If you are forced by your job to add large numbers of extremely urgent and time critical tasks, then that may be the problem. Otherwise, if you really need to get to older items, then the newer items just won't stand out. You can skip them (provided you do look at them.)
14 July 2009 at 17:28 | Chris
-
Mike - did AF1 work better for you? If so, why not go back to AF1 instead of using AF2? I'm guessing Mark won't mind :)
14 July 2009 at 17:29 | Lillian
-
Mike,
If you are doing only 6 or so items each day and adding new pages each day or so, then I can't see how AF (or any list method) will work if this continues. You only have so many hours in the day to do your list.
You can read through your list several times through the day. An item at the beginning of my list can't stand out until I actually look at it of course, but the items I am looking at right now (maybe newer items) will not likely stand out if I "know" that there are older, but urgent, items I need to work on, allowing me to move through the list faster.
But it still sounds like you have too many item on your plate.
Balfour
You don't put Doctor appointments on your list. If you mean a task to call the doctor, then if the item is up for dismissal, then it more than likely has been on the list for a number of days. The idea is that if you are looking through the list each day, then you will know which items are up for dismissal and which will be up for dismissal over the next several days--all of which becomes a force that will affect what items stand out and how fast you move through the list.
14 July 2009 at 17:38 | Chris
-
Mike, I enjoy your posts and completely understand. I am understanding the logic of the system the same way.
Fortunately, I don't have scads of active pages and never have. I have a list at work and one at home. I currently have 5 active pages in my work list and just started a sixth. The older pages become more sparse as I pick away at them. I have 19 closed pages (having started pretty much at the very introduction of AF1 and continuing with my original list/notebook into AF2), with a very, very few dismissed items that I've highlighted. These items are nearly all of exactly the same type, that will get completed at some time.
I'm very curious: why do people have such huge numbers of pages?
14 July 2009 at 17:47 | Balfour
-
Chris--yes, I meant Dr. appointments that need to be made.
14 July 2009 at 17:49 | Balfour
-
Hi Chris,
>>> A couple of points. You do not have to work on each item in order from newest to oldest. You merely have to look at each to see what stands out. The reason you read through each item at the beginning of the day, is that it puts the whole list into your mind so you can filter what needs to be done, using a combination of the rational and intuitive. <<<
<sigh> Once more. That simply does NOT HAPPEN. Yes, going through the list in the morning gets me muttering: "Yeah, I've got to get to that. Yup, that too. And that." However, once I start on the last page, the items I just wrote there recently are the really HOT ones so THEY stand out. The ones I saw first thing in the morning are long in the distant past when compared to the hot new things on the list. That is simply the way it works.
>>> What happens with most of us, is that if we really need to work on the items "to be dismissed" then we find that the newer items just don't stand out that much, even if they are fairly urgent, so we skip over them. <<<
Yea, it apparently works that way for you ... but not for me.
>>> Let's say I come to a task that is fairly new and one that I could easily and want to do, so it stands out somewhat. Whether it stands out enough for me to work on right now is determined by several factors--the need I have to get to older items, and the fact that I will certainly get back to this other task frequently. There is a force inside me that on some days moves me quickly through the list and on other days keeps me where the newest items are, all based on my overall contextual understanding of the whole list. <<<
Yeah, that is what it says in fine print. However that does not happen. The last pages stand out the most.
>>> But if you are ready to dismiss 25 items at once, then your list may be too long or you have little discretionary time. If you are forced by your job to add large numbers of extremely urgent and time critical tasks, then that may be the problem. <<<
No, I did not say I had a great number of items to dismiss. I said I had stopped dismissing entirely.
<<< Otherwise, if you really need to get to older items, then the newer items just won't stand out. You can skip them (provided you do look at them.) <<<
I just don't get why you are telling me that. I said, any number of times, that it is simply not true for me. Yet you (and some others) continue to imply that I must be "broken" somehow if I don't see things your way. I just don't get it.
*** If I need to get to an older item I have to DO IT, not move to some other page of a list and look at items there. If I do THAT, then I will work on items THERE, not the ones that need to get done. ***
I don't get why this is such a hard idea to communicate. If I need to mow the yard it does not make sense to go to the movies first so that I'll be nagged to get back to mowing the yard. That's just crazy nuts, IMO.
14 July 2009 at 17:55 | Mike
-
Chris--
You say:
"you will know which items are up for dismissal and which will be up for dismissal over the next several days"
That sounds like an interpretation of AF2, because, by my understanding (correct me if I'm wrong, please), according to AF2, everything prior to the line drawn today is dismissed unless you take action on them today, no? That's how I read AF2 and why I don't work it as written. I am translating it into something that makes more sense to me, which is that I can't just dismiss all items that I haven't taken action on that are still there today.
14 July 2009 at 17:55 | Balfour
-
Fortunately I don't have time to put any new items on my list this week, am to busy working on the old stuff. LOL!
14 July 2009 at 17:56 | Rainer
-
Hi Lillian,
No, I'm sure Mark won't mind ;-) The thing is that AF2 has advantages. It moves faster. It keeps the current stuff under control ... things were growing moldy with AF1. The problem I'm having is with getting to the beginning and the dismissal rule.
Barring magic, the only fix for me will be to add a rule that puts me working on the first pages before transferring me to the last pages. Of course, then the middle will go wanting. But I guess if I close the first pages at a reasonable rate that will take care of itself.
14 July 2009 at 17:58 | Mike
-
Hi Again Chris,
>>> If you are doing only 6 or so items each day and adding new pages each day or so, then I can't see how AF (or any list method) will work if this continues. You only have so many hours in the day to do your list. <<<
Exactly the problem which AF2 surfaced. With AF1 I was working the old items and the current things were coming up more slowly. But with AF2, I'm working the more current things and so that is causing more current things to be spawned. Example:
New item in both AF1 and AF2: "Fix up bike for trip on Thursday"
In AF1, I'd be working on early pages and not get to it for a while.
In AF2, I'd go right to that and start "fixing" Which would spawn:
- Go to bike store: Buy tubes
- Get current maps of C&O trail
- Email X to ask how his trip went
- Buy snacks to eat on ride
- Learn how to fix a flat
- Get tools to fix flat
- Get new pump
- etc.
So you see that six tasks came from that one ... and that happens for most of these things. It just seems as if the older tasks spawn fewer things. Maybe because they are not so urgent and so I work on them in blocked time? I dunno.
>>> You can read through your list several times through the day. <<<
Why would I want to do that? !!! Now it is becoming like GTD with the overhead swamping the actual doing of things. It takes me a good 10 - 15 minutes to read the list over. I could easily lose an hour of productive time to list maintenance. It strikes me that is the wrong way to go.
>>> An item at the beginning of my list can't stand out until I actually look at it of course, but the items I am looking at right now (maybe newer items) will not likely stand out if I "know" that there are older, but urgent, items I need to work on, allowing me to move through the list faster. <<<
EEEEEK! There it is again! ;-) Why oh why do you keep saying that every time in answer to my saying that it is NOT true? This is starting to sound like the old GTD list where if you had a problem you were just "wrong" and had to make yourself "right" so that the GTD system would work for you.
>>> But it still sounds like you have too many item on your plate. <<<
It is more a question of them breeding like bunnies ;-)
>>> You don't put Doctor appointments on your list. If you mean a task to call the doctor, then if the item is up for dismissal, then it more than likely has been on the list for a number of days. The idea is that if you are looking through the list each day, then you will know which items are up for dismissal and which will be up for dismissal over the next several days--all of which becomes a force that will affect what items stand out and how fast you move through the list. <<<
So he's broken too? If 500 people all posted here that they had this problem, would you tell them all that the items will just "stand out"? LOL ;-)
14 July 2009 at 18:10 | Mike
-
Balfour,
<<< That sounds like an interpretation of AF2, because, by my understanding (correct me if I'm wrong, please), according to AF2, everything prior to the line drawn today is dismissed unless you take action on them today, no? That's how I read AF2 and why I don't work it as written. I am translating it into something that makes more sense to me, which is that I can't just dismiss all items that I haven't taken action on that are still there today. <<<
No, you got it wrong there. (I think ;-)
- You draw a line after the FIRST block of open tasks (it should only be a few tasks)
- You mark those as "on notice"
- Tomorrow you dismiss those which have not been done.
- You mark the next block of open tasks and mark them "on notice"
The line for today's work can be many pages distant. You do NOT dismiss anything before today.
14 July 2009 at 18:15 | Mike
-
Balfour,
>>> Mike, I enjoy your posts and completely understand. I am understanding the logic of the system the same way.
Fortunately, I don't have scads of active pages and never have. I have a list at work and one at home. <<<
I use only one list for everything.
>>> I currently have 5 active pages in my work list and just started a sixth. The older pages become more sparse as I pick away at them. <<>
Mine did under AF1, but I never get to the old pages these days.
<<< I have 19 closed pages (having started pretty much at the very introduction of AF1 and continuing with my original list/notebook into AF2), with a very, very few dismissed items that I've highlighted. These items are nearly all of exactly the same type, that will get completed at some time.
I'm very curious: why do people have such huge numbers of pages? <<<
Well, in my case it is because I have only 15 lines per page. I can't speak for others.
Also, I completed a full book (86 pages, if memory serves) under AF1 and was just starting this new book when AF2 made its entry.
14 July 2009 at 18:19 | Mike
-
Thanks Mike. I still simply don't get it. This is what I'm understanding (forgive me if I'm just repeating myself):
BEFORE I add anything to the list today, I draw a line at the end of my list. Everything prior to that line is "on notice." If I don't take action on any of those by the end of today, I dismiss them all.
Otherwise, what do you mean by a "block"? How do you establish a block?
14 July 2009 at 18:23 | Balfour
-
Hi Balfour,
No, you really do have it wrong.
START THE DAY
1 - Look at yesterday's tasks marked "on notice" and dismiss those not done
2 - Find the next "block" of tasks.
*** A block of tasks is one or more OPEN tasks between the last CLOSED (dismissed or done) task and then next CLOSED task. Example: ([X} is done, [ ] is OPEN]
[X] Call Joe
[ ] Fix car
[ ] Conquer world
[X] Make coffee
[X] Drink coffee
[ ] Wash cup
[X] Call Mary
So "Fix car" and "Conquer World" are the first block to be put on notice. If you don't wash that cup, it will go on notice tomorrow and "Fix car" and "Conquer world" will be dismissed then if not done.
3) Mark next block "on notice" (Wash Cup)
4) Scan list
5) Start working from bottom up.
That is how it works ... it says here in fine print ;-)
14 July 2009 at 18:33 | Mike
-
Oooops, I did not address the "draw line" part. You draw a line after "Conquer World" because that is the next open block and drawing the line is how you mark items "on notice".
Sorry about that ;-)
14 July 2009 at 18:34 | Mike
-
Thank you Mike. I've read the instructions a number of times - I really am a careful reader ;D but that never made any impression on me. I'll try that and re-read the instructions too. That makes more sense than the way I've had it. I might actually be able to implement that--wow.
14 July 2009 at 18:38 | Balfour
-
Mike,
If you're using a To Do list, how do you decide what's best to do next?
For AF2 it might help to write a few of the 'on notice' items on an index card, then look at it as a reminder when _also_ looking at the 'hot' items later on in the list.
If the 'on notice' items on the index card still don't stand out compared to the 'hot' items, surely the on notice items are ripe for DISMISSAL! ;-)
14 July 2009 at 19:36 | smileypete
-
Mike, I feel your pain!
I use a Mead composition notebook (the type I used in 5th grade :) ) I have 30 open pages. As I said before, I have no problem dismissing-- I'm the first to admit I have too much to do and I like that I can "throw anything" at AF (and I do!)-- and I review dismissed items about once a week and add them to the end of the list if necessary. I also liek that AF2 deals with urgent items better. that being said, I have two problems:
1) Stuff in the middle for me does not get done. I rarely am able to go back more than five pages in a given workday.
2) I am no longer asking the question that I used to ask in AF1, "why did I dismiss this item?" I liked that there were pages in AF1 where nothing stood out, I would use that opportunity to either bite the bullet and do something I was avoiding or accept that I am not doing it anytime soon and dismiss it. Nowadays I always know why I dismissed an item, it has nothing to do with the item itself, it is because my list is too long!
14 July 2009 at 20:37 | vegheadjones
-
I think there are a couple of possible solutions. First if something is urgent and needs to be done, just do it. My basic strategy is before I use the system I check my intuition to see if there is something compelling and urgent that needs to be done right now, regardless of the list.
That usually solves the issue of burning issues that the system doesn't get you to right away. AF2 seems to trade-off the ability to move rapidly and build momentum on current and important tasks against allowing some items to get stranded. I solve that in two ways:
a) After reading through the list from front to back, some items stick out immediately as urgent so I just do those first.
b) I do one single pass from back to front at least once a day (so after completing a task I don't jump to the end again I keep moving back through).
Applying those two rules has really helped me avoid the dilemma you describe, which I think it a real dilemma if you follow the rules too literally. Overall I'm very happy with AF2 because it solves the 2 major dilemma for me with AF: my resistance to dismiss items and the inability to keep current important items moving because you couldn't get to the newest items quickly enough.
14 July 2009 at 21:36 | PowerSecrets
-
Why not do something like AF1 in the morning and AF2 in the afternoons? Or do AF1 one day (when you have lots of discretionary time) and AF2 the next (when you don't have lots of discretionary time or have deadlines to meet)? Or just do one pass with AF1 through your pages daily? And dismiss using AF2 rules. It seems to me someone can switch back and forth very easily between the two systems - or at least that's what I found when I switched back to AF1 from AF2.
I switch back and forth from AF Condensed to AF1 weekly and by working two systems, it seems I get more done than ever and the planned switch in systems keeps things lively.
There's something to be said for keeping the strengths of BOTH systems. I just don't think it's an either / or proposition.
14 July 2009 at 23:21 | Jacqueline
-
Hi Mike
I am finding with AF2 that i am even more familiar with my list so know if something urgent is further back in the list. That said, newer items will invariably stand out more which meant that, if I was going to action my on notice items according to the rules I had to ignore the standing out items as having less pull. That felt wrong - and I suspect that is what is happening to you. Whereas for you it seems the pull of the recent items virtually wipes out the memory of the old (in that you do not see them again) for me it just left a discomfort until I went back - but it felt like I was forcing it.
For me the solution has been to action my on notice items if I feel like it at any time of the day that I feel like! That to me feels more like AF than forcing myself back against other standing out items. I can then quite happily do whatever stands out, wherever it is, and whilst I work a lot at the end of the list it is getting quicker to move back because the latter pages are nearly complete.
15 July 2009 at 0:16 | Christine B
-
Hi Mike
"OY! Smiley, not yet again!
Look, standout schmandout! If I can't SEE the fricken' things they are simply not there to STAND OUT! Sheeesh"
ROTFL ROTFL ROTFL That's why I lean the trash up against the door, write HOT items in 6 inch letters on my bathroom mirror. hang a 2 foot monkey (laundry in process) wherever I am, etc........
Hey, our intense focus is MOSTLY a gift even if it doesn't work well with other stuff. It enables us to stay in flow better also when we're lucky enough to be doing stuff we love....our lasar focus isn't bothered by distractions......or stuff on previous pages! LOL!
I've even been known to whiteboard my aims. To learn Flylady, I nailed a frig door to the wall and shuffled around stuff until the overall thing imprinted the overall system in my brain...ROTFL! Then I scrapped most of it because it didn't blend with my MO.......I failed MISERABLY with AF.....I couldn't create drive or momentum with a bunch of random stuff scattered about......I NEED my aims in my face to keep me on track.....or....to quickly get me back on track! ROTFL!
Mike, overall.....I wouldn't trade my focus for anything.....so what if it doesn't match up with how linear thinkers process and do stuff? Our orientation is different because we process information differently.
I abandoned AF.......I use a system that works with me......maybe you'll develop tweaks to accomodate your focusing style. Hell, Mike.....once I turned a page, the stuff was gone. That's why I like to keep my MIT's in my face and get my MITs out of the way first, then work with a checklist or adhoc. Timeboxing is easiest. I just hum away until the buzzer sounds without any cares except what I'm doing....what's in my face and flooding my awareness! LOL!
Trying to master AF was masochistic! *blush* Our focus operates differently. If you really like AF, I do hope that you find tweaks to help you out. Whole system thinkers and linear thinkers are two different breeds within the same species! ROTFL!
learning as I go
15 July 2009 at 2:20 | learning as I go
-
p.s.
True, my brain injuries wrecked my short term memory and recall.....but it didn't alter my natural focusing methods. I think we focus differently, because we're wired to process information differently. With reference to what I love to do, it's an asset. Other times, it's a pain in the arse.....unless I can quickly create a viable work around! *blush*
I'll bet that what you're really good at and what you love to do is also influenced by this.
Welcome to the club! Our membership is strong!
learning as I go
15 July 2009 at 2:45 | learning as I go
-
Mike,
Two simple suggestions for you in a second, after I first admit I don't have a silver bullet for you; and explain that my work is 85% customer support; I am simply am not allowed to dismiss an item a customer needs answered and some days the new items do breed like bunnies. So I grok your pain.
Suggestion (1) be more macro/high level with the items you write down when it's practical. My simple example is; if you'll know what to do when the time comes don't break the task down any smaller. "buy milk" doesn't have to be written as "get money, grab keys, get in car, drive to store, walk to milk; pick milk, pay for milk, drive home, put in fridge". Yes that is an absurd example but it's hard to miss the idea. I put big overall items in my list; that often have multiple steps. I trust that I know the next step or I write it in such away that it leads me to the obvious step; if it's a big project I just list "work on project" and I have the project outline somewhere else; when it's time to work on the project pull out the support materials and see where I was and continue. When I'm done update my notes put the support material away and put "work on project X" back on the list. For your bike store example I would have had "plan trip to bike store" on my list. after I did the planning on some index card or something else. I would have scratched it out, and wrote "go to bike store (take list)" on my AF2 list. I don't know if that would help you. I have to discipline myself to do that; and have faith that I will not mentally melt if I don't write the details down; after years of compulsive list making I admit to having to fight the urge with active effort. When I win the fight I am rewarded with more productivity.
Suggestion (2) Play Your Slice. Ask any golfer; if you have a SLICE you have to play it until you have time to fix it. If you constantly miss 30 feet to the right; aim 30 feet to the left. Here are some suggestions to play your slice depending on your hurdles. After 20 years I have no desire to "fix" my slice I know it's there and I use it well.
2a) if a task doesn't go BOOM today then give yourself permission to skip past it in favor of something that might be lurking in the list. Mark calls it intuition; I call it sensible choosing; there's a difference between that and just doing the fun stuff; that old saying inspiration is 98% perspiration; I don't get through the list anywhere as easy as Mark does; but I get through it by making choices and decisions as I go; I actively make my intuition and rational thoughts fight about what task to do. I have to drag myself through the list. Until I find a task I CAN'T resist doing (intuition) or one that will go BOOM if I don't do it (rational).
2b) If you can't resist those new items then find a way not to do the new items until they have matured/aged just a little. I had an old boss that would change his mind like the wind; our staff adopted an effective filter policy; until he asked for something the 3rd time we ignored the request. Sounds stupid but with him it work.
Each time you pass through the list; look at each item as you get to it.
(i) If it goes boom do it (be honest with yourself boom means QA-BOOM, not *pop*);
(ii) If no boom; then put a symbol like "!" in front of it.
(iii) If it has Qty 3, "!!!" then don't add any more marks.
(iv) Don't do any tasks that doesn't have Qty 3 marks.
Three is an arbitrary number pick a number you like greater than or equal to 2. That will force items it age a little bit and help get them off your reticulating radar.
3b) Break up your hyper focus if your job/ life requires that you task switch more frequently than you are naturally inclined to.
Get a $9 electronic kitchen time. If your not working on a BOOM task, Use it to make yourself stop a task at whatever interval works for you; I suspect 25 minutes would work for me; check off said task and add it to the end of the list. If you do (2b) you'll have to at least 3 other tasks from the list before you can restart that task.
If AF2 doesn't work for you, then do what does. No system is universal; my daughter and I have severe Gestalt learning issues. I don't expect anyone to think like we do; but we've both learned to maximize what's good and "manage" the bad.
You aren't broken; AF2 is not broken; there is a slight possibility that a percentage of the population is not compatible with AF2 out of the box.
I hope this helps a little; absolutely fascinating discussion....
(all attempts at humor in this post that failed are the responsibility of the author with apologies to the reader).
15 July 2009 at 5:42 | ratz
-
Mike,
I and others have suggested this before: why not add a new task: "check dismissed tasks"?
Sorry if I've missed your response.
15 July 2009 at 9:32 | Will
-
Good Morning Smiley,
>>> If you're using a To Do list, how do you decide what's best to do next? <<<
The next undone item on the list is the next one to do.
If I were to use a non-prioritized list, then the list would be short enough so that I could see everything on it. See, with AF, it is more than a TO DO list. It is also a "universal capture device" (n GtD parlance). So it can become quite long and therefore things can lurk among other things, hiding in wait for you.
>>> For AF2 it might help to write a few of the 'on notice' items on an index card, then look at it as a reminder when _also_ looking at the 'hot' items later on in the list. <<<
That has been my practice since it became obvious to me that AF had this very dark side to it ;-)
>>> If the 'on notice' items on the index card still don't stand out compared to the 'hot' items, surely the on notice items are ripe for DISMISSAL! ;-) <<<
Yes, in that case, using those tweaks, I agree. The thing is, I was looking to find a way to make AF work, with no tweaks. Mark (rightly) admonished me to use it as described before getting all grouchy about it. I'm trying and failing. My impression is that AF2 NEEDS tweaks in order to work for me. AF1 did not. But then, in a sense, AF2 is really a tweak on AF1 so it really should be no big thing.
15 July 2009 at 10:09 | Grouchy Mike
-
Good Morning Veg,
>>> Mike, I feel your pain! <<<
LOL ;-) Yeah, it is been that way since AF2. Though, and don't get me wrong on this point, I love some aspects of AF2.
>>> I use a Mead composition notebook (the type I used in 5th grade :) ) <<<
I love those. Very nice size and no rings to catch. And they are sewn. I don't like that last aspect for AF, however as I like to keep my history of important things done separate from "take out the trash" so I rip out my AF pages and I would never do that to a sewn book ... there is something sacrilegious about that ;-)
>>> have 30 open pages <<<
That is quite a list. Just about twice my size and already I'm' climbing the walls.
>>>.As I said before, I have no problem dismissing-- I'm the first to admit I have too much to do and I like that I can "throw anything" at AF (and I do!)-- and I review dismissed items about once a week and add them to the end of the list if necessary. I also liek that AF2 deals with urgent items better. <<<
Those are also my reasons for sticking with this. I just need to start tweaking, I guess.
>>> that being said, I have two problems:
1) Stuff in the middle for me does not get done. I rarely am able to go back more than five pages in a given workday. <<<
With me it is the middle and the beginning.
>>> 2) I am no longer asking the question that I used to ask in AF1, "why did I dismiss this item?" I liked that there were pages in AF1 where nothing stood out, I would use that opportunity to either bite the bullet and do something I was avoiding or accept that I am not doing it anytime soon and dismiss it. Nowadays I always know why I dismissed an item, it has nothing to do with the item itself, it is because my list is too long! <<<
I had not considered that side effect. With AF1 it was because the task had not been done and was not going to be done NOW. With AF2 it is just because it is the first undone task on the list. Yes, that really is more arbitrary. In reductio ad absurdum, if one just started and had a list of only 10 items, one would have to dismiss the first undone ones the very next day! Of course, that is never the case, but does point out the arbitrariness of this aspect of it. But I also like that "moving line of doom" as someone put it. There is also something attractive about inexorably clearing out the old. (Remember the end of that Stephen King film, "The Langoliers" where those chomping things destroyed the past so it did not clutter up the present and future? LOL ;-)
15 July 2009 at 10:26 | Mike
-
Hi Power,
>>> I think there are a couple of possible solutions. First if something is urgent and needs to be done, just do it. My basic strategy is before I use the system I check my intuition to see if there is something compelling and urgent that needs to be done right now, regardless of the list. <<<
You have the description of my problem exactly backward. AF2 is wonderful at handling the urgent ... it is less impressive at handling the IMPORTANT. It is the important that is being neglected ... those things that need to be done whose time has not yet come for one reason or another.
>>> That usually solves the issue of burning issues that the system doesn't get you to right away. AF2 seems to trade-off the ability to move rapidly and build momentum on current and important tasks <<
I would say "current and urgent tasks".
>>> against allowing some items to get stranded. I solve that in two ways:
a) After reading through the list from front to back, some items stick out immediately as urgent so I just do those first. <<<
Yes, but what about important but not urgent? The Q2 variety. Balfour used the example: "Make Doctor's appointment" which had gone undone for some reason and he was still not ready to do. It could be that he is not ready because he is uncertain of his schedule ... not because of simple procrastination. In that case he does not WANT AF2 making him make or dismiss his appointment. He is not yet ready for good reason.
>>> b) I do one single pass from back to front at least once a day (so after completing a task I don't jump to the end again I keep moving back through). <<<
That will not work with long lists ... it takes too much time. But it does indicate that most people are making SOME tweaks to AF2 in order to fight the "dismissal problem" ;-)
>>> Applying those two rules has really helped me avoid the dilemma you describe, which I think it a real dilemma if you follow the rules too literally. <<<
Yes, I'm wondering now how many people are really following the rules. I suspect that I'll go back to my old AF1 tweak of culling out the things I want to do today and putting them on a second list (usually an index card but sometimes a Post-It) and making that list my priority list, and using AF to "fill" the time otherwise. Then I will probably take the AF2 dismissal rule as more advisory than absolute ... IOW, those tasks would go on my priority list to get some kind of special treatment or at least very serious consideration of why they are not yet done. But that does really start to remove the "auto" from "Autofocus". I have to think if that is an entirely good thing or not.
>>> Overall I'm very happy with AF2 because it solves the 2 major dilemma for me with AF: my resistance to dismiss items and the inability to keep current important items moving because you couldn't get to the newest items quickly enough. <<<
I agree. I think a balance is what is really needed and I think Mark hit on something with his AF1/AF2 combo ... switching back and forth. Maybe I don't want exactly that, but I need the effect of balancing working at the beginning of the list to get old things done and working at the end to keep current. One thing I've noticed is that in AF2 I have many more repeated items. IOW, I will have "Call Joe" on the list, undone, several times because I know it is important and I can't get to it once it sinks into the quicksand that is the beginning and middle of the AF2 list. LOL ;-) I have a continual feeling of de ja vu when I do my morning scan of the entire list. "Huh, did I not just see that one a minute ago?" ;-)
15 July 2009 at 10:43 | Mike
-
Jacqueline,
>>> Why not do something like AF1 in the morning and AF2 in the afternoons? Or do AF1 one day (when you have lots of discretionary time) and AF2 the next (when you don't have lots of discretionary time or have deadlines to meet)? Or just do one pass with AF1 through your pages daily? And dismiss using AF2 rules. It seems to me someone can switch back and forth very easily between the two systems - or at least that's what I found when I switched back to AF1 from AF2. <<<
I think that is what Mark proposed then backed away from. Put a task on the list to switch over to the other processing method. Yes, that is one answer.
>>> I switch back and forth from AF Condensed to AF1 weekly and by working two systems, it seems I get more done than ever and the planned switch in systems keeps things lively.
There's something to be said for keeping the strengths of BOTH systems. I just don't think it's an either / or proposition. <<<
As I say, I've just reached the conclusion that perhaps no one is really doing pure AF2. Maybe I'm the last one trying to make it work as described. Well, I said I'd keep at it until the end of July ... but I still will only mark tasks "on notice" but not dismiss them. I can't wreck my life, after all ;-)
15 July 2009 at 10:47 | Mike
-
Hi Christine,
<<< I am finding with AF2 that i am even more familiar with my list so know if something urgent is further back in the list. That said, newer items will invariably stand out more which meant that, if I was going to action my on notice items according to the rules I had to ignore the standing out items as having less pull. That felt wrong - and I suspect that is what is happening to you. Whereas for you it seems the pull of the recent items virtually wipes out the memory of the old (in that you do not see them again) for me it just left a discomfort until I went back - but it felt like I was forcing it. <<<
You are the first person to accurately restate my problem. Yes, if you were to ask me, at any time of the day, "Is there anything important that needs to be done that is being overlooked", I'd be able to tell you. BUT ... when working the list, the page of recent and urgent items wipes out memory of the old but important ones.
>>> For me the solution has been to action my on notice items if I feel like it at any time of the day that I feel like! That to me feels more like AF than forcing myself back against other standing out items. I can then quite happily do whatever stands out, wherever it is, and whilst I work a lot at the end of the list it is getting quicker to move back because the latter pages are nearly complete. <<<
Yes, but that is not AF2, as I understand it. There is no "automatic" (i.e. rule driven) method to get you back to the early tasks that you know you ought to be working on. I am even more convinced that no one but Mark is actually doing pure AF2.
15 July 2009 at 10:54 | Mike
-
Hey Learning,
>>> ROTFL ROTFL ROTFL That's why I lean the trash up against the door, write HOT items in 6 inch letters on my bathroom mirror. hang a 2 foot monkey (laundry in process) wherever I am, etc........ <<<
Oh, don't forget: "The steaks are in the oven." Damn, I really do live in terror of having my attention brought back to dinner by the smell of smoke! This ADD business is quite a challenge some times. Just last night I was cursing that I sat down to dinner but did not bring my drink with me. I got up to get it and then realized it was there but unseen ... so I did not "forget" so much as I "forgot that I did not forget". Grrr ;-) I think I need to intensify my meditation session so I can be more in the present ;-)
>>> Hey, our intense focus is MOSTLY a gift even if it doesn't work well with other stuff. It enables us to stay in flow better also when we're lucky enough to be doing stuff we love....our lasar focus isn't bothered by distractions......or stuff on previous pages! LOL! <<<
Yes, that describes the root of the problem well. Distraction is a consequence of hyper focus.
>>> I've even been known to whiteboard my aims. To learn Flylady, I nailed a frig door to the wall and shuffled around stuff until the overall thing imprinted the overall system in my brain...ROTFL! Then I scrapped most of it because it didn't blend with my MO....... <<<
Damn, but you are one committed woman ... (I don't mean that in the sense of "committed to an institution" ;-)
>>> I failed MISERABLY with AF.....I couldn't create drive or momentum with a bunch of random stuff scattered about......I NEED my aims in my face to keep me on track.....or....to quickly get me back on track! ROTFL! <<<
Yes, and I see why you like the DIT kind of thing more. Maybe what attracts me to AF has been that with the AF being as much a "universal capture device" as well as a TO DO list, it is more in my face. IOW, every time I think of an idea to capture, I have to look at the damn list and see that there is something I need to be doing ;-)
>>> Mike, overall.....I wouldn't trade my focus for anything.....so what if it doesn't match up with how linear thinkers process and do stuff? Our orientation is different because we process information differently. <<<
Amen to that!!!
>>> I abandoned AF.......I use a system that works with me......maybe you'll develop tweaks to accomodate your focusing style. Hell, Mike.....once I turned a page, the stuff was gone.<<<
YES YES YES. You really do get it. It is not "forgotten" so much as it is "out of sight". If I asked you, you'd probably tell me, but you'll never think of it on your own because there is something else in front of you just now.
>>> That's why I like to keep my MIT's in my face and get my MITs out of the way first, then work with a checklist or adhoc. Timeboxing is easiest. I just hum away until the buzzer sounds without any cares except what I'm doing....what's in my face and flooding my awareness! LOL! <<<
Yes, I'm more and more working to a timer. I've not gotten the system down pat yet, but I love my watch with the ten timers ;-) I only use one, for the most part ... the 20 minute repeating timer. Work until the beep, reset and think of "What is the best use of my time right now?", then work on that until the beep. If it is a bigger project, I switch to a 2 hour timer with a five minute timer after that -- for a break. (Technology is wonderful ;-)
>>> Trying to master AF was masochistic! *blush* Our focus operates differently. If you really like AF, I do hope that you find tweaks to help you out. Whole system thinkers and linear thinkers are two different breeds within the same species! ROTFL! <<<
Yes, that is very true. I'm anything but linear. I can be, but it is not effective for the things I most want to do. I will absolutely tweak the system. In fact, I'm heading out for a week long bike trip (my wife is biking 318 miles along the Appalachian Trail from PA down to MD along the C&O canal. (NOTE: She is doing the biking, I'm driving the chase car ;-) So I'll have quite a bit of alone time in a different environment to think through my time management system. I'm going to rip the whole mess up and reorder my tools. Funny how I think better in the car, or a hotel room or someplace different. I guess removing the familiar opens up my mind to alternatives ... it is as if the familiar traps us somehow in our ways.
15 July 2009 at 11:15 | Mike
-
Learning,
>>> True, my brain injuries wrecked my short term memory and recall.....but it didn't alter my natural focusing methods. <<<
Thank goodness it was only the SHORT term memory. Your systems can get you past that problem ... or at least provide a substitute. That's what they invented paper for, I guess ;-)
>>> I think we focus differently, because we're wired to process information differently. <<<
Oh yes. I think a lot of it is wiring. I've always had a lack of focus / hyper focus "problem". I'm just staring to see that as a feature rather than a "problem".
>>> With reference to what I love to do, it's an asset. Other times, it's a pain in the arse.....unless I can quickly create a viable work around! *blush* <<<
Tell me about it ;-) ;-)
>>> I'll bet that what you're really good at and what you love to do is also influenced by this. <<<
Oh yes. Very true. It really does help explain why my life has centered around "tool building" in one way or another. I've always tried to design a tool to solve a problem, rather than simply solve the problem. I'm just wired that way.
>>> Welcome to the club! Our membership is strong! <<<
What color are the jackets? ;-)
15 July 2009 at 11:22 | Mike
-
Hi ratz
Thank you for the phrase Gestalt Learning. That really really nails it on the head!
learning as I go
15 July 2009 at 11:39 | learning as I go
-
Ratz,
>>> Two simple suggestions for you in a second, after I first admit I don't have a silver bullet for you; and explain that my work is 85% customer support; I am simply am not allowed to dismiss an item a customer needs answered and some days the new items do breed like bunnies. So I grok your pain. <<<
ROTF ;-) But hey, "customer support"? I thought the GOAL of "customer support" was to hang up, misinterpret, misunderstand, and misdirect! LOL ;-)
>>> Suggestion (1) be more macro/high level with the items you write down when it's practical. <<<
Yes, I do that when it applies. I have an item "Bike trip" and a lot of things there are not written down ... those that are, are on a separate list for just that project.
>>> My simple example is; if you'll know what to do when the time comes don't break the task down any smaller. "buy milk" doesn't have to be written as "get money, grab keys, get in car, drive to store, walk to milk; pick milk, pay for milk, drive home, put in fridge". Yes that is an absurd example but it's hard to miss the idea. <<<
Exactly. That is what drove me away screaming from GtD!
>>> I put big overall items in my list; that often have multiple steps. I trust that I know the next step or I write it in such away that it leads me to the obvious step; if it's a big project I just list "work on project" and I have the project outline somewhere else; when it's time to work on the project pull out the support materials and see where I was and continue. When I'm done update my notes put the support material away and put "work on project X" back on the list. <<<
Yes, that is why I use time blocking for those big projects. I have my whole day blocked for getting ready to leave on the bike trip tomorrow. (Well, except for this indulgence ;-)
>>> For your bike store example I would have had "plan trip to bike store" on my list. after I did the planning on some index card or something else. I would have scratched it out, and wrote "go to bike store (take list)" on my AF2 list. I don't know if that would help you. I have to discipline myself to do that; and have faith that I will not mentally melt if I don't write the details down; after years of compulsive list making I admit to having to fight the urge with active effort. When I win the fight I am rewarded with more productivity. <<<
LOL ;-) I hear 'ya. I'm a compulsive list maker myself. (I hear they are coming out with new jackets for us next year. ;-)
>>> Suggestion (2) Play Your Slice. Ask any golfer; if you have a SLICE you have to play it until you have time to fix it. If you constantly miss 30 feet to the right; aim 30 feet to the left. Here are some suggestions to play your slice depending on your hurdles. After 20 years I have no desire to "fix" my slice I know it's there and I use it well. <<<
Yes, I've given up trying to "fix me" but now rather use my quirks to my advantage.
>>> 2a) if a task doesn't go BOOM today then give yourself permission to skip past it in favor of something that might be lurking in the list. Mark calls it intuition; I call it sensible choosing; there's a difference between that and just doing the fun stuff; that old saying inspiration is 98% perspiration; I don't get through the list anywhere as easy as Mark does; but I get through it by making choices and decisions as I go; I actively make my intuition and rational thoughts fight about what task to do. I have to drag myself through the list. Until I find a task I CAN'T resist doing (intuition) or one that will go BOOM if I don't do it (rational). <<<
Yes. That is where the tweaks come in. I was trying to work without the tweaks but now I see that is not going to be possible.
>>> 2b) If you can't resist those new items then find a way not to do the new items until they have matured/aged just a little. I had an old boss that would change his mind like the wind; our staff adopted an effective filter policy; until he asked for something the 3rd time we ignored the request. Sounds stupid but with him it work. <<<
Been there. As a system that is known as the "pile system". You keep letting the inbox fill up. When someone asks you about an item, you dig down and retrieve the memo and put it on top. After you've done it a few times, you do it. Over time, most things just get buried deeper and deeper as the in box fills up and is dumped into file folders, then boxes and they just never come up again. But if they ever did ... yes, they go back on top of the inbox for another trip ;-)
>>> Each time you pass through the list; look at each item as you get to it.
(i) If it goes boom do it (be honest with yourself boom means QA-BOOM, not *pop*); <<<
ROTFLMAO ;-)
>>> (ii) If no boom; then put a symbol like "!" in front of it.
(iii) If it has Qty 3, "!!!" then don't add any more marks.
(iv) Don't do any tasks that doesn't have Qty 3 marks.
Three is an arbitrary number pick a number you like greater than or equal to 2. That will force items it age a little bit and help get them off your reticulating radar. <<<
That's a tweak I'll have to remember in my brainstorm this next week.
>>> 3b) Break up your hyper focus if your job/ life requires that you task switch more frequently than you are naturally inclined to.
Get a $9 electronic kitchen time. If your not working on a BOOM task, Use it to make yourself stop a task at whatever interval works for you; I suspect 25 minutes would work for me; check off said task and add it to the end of the list. <<<
Yes, I have a watch with repeating timers. (Timex Ironman for those who are bound to ask ;-) I use 20 minutes for the "little and often" type things and 2 hours for the larger tasks. For even bigger things I use 4 hours.
>>> If you do (2b) you'll have to at least 3 other tasks from the list before you can restart that task. <<<
Nice synchronicity there ;-)
>>> If AF2 doesn't work for you, then do what does. No system is universal; <<<
Right. Something I've been saying for years.
>>> my daughter and I have severe Gestalt learning issues. <<<
What does that mean? Just curious. Never heard that term.
>>> I don't expect anyone to think like we do; but we've both learned to maximize what's good and "manage" the bad. <<<
That is pretty much what works for everyone, in one way or another.
>>> You aren't broken; AF2 is not broken; there is a slight possibility that a percentage of the population is not compatible with AF2 out of the box. <<<
Yes. I was just objecting to the attitude that people were having when any of us complained about the problems with AF2 ... it implied that it was our fault. And yes, systems must mesh with personality.
>>> I hope this helps a little; absolutely fascinating discussion.... <<<
It really does. And thanks. And this has been the first time the issue has been addressed as a serious one ... to those of us who see it as an issue. Previously it had been brushed aside.
>>> (all attempts at humor in this post that failed are the responsibility of the author with apologies to the reader).<<<
You are a funny guy! ;-)
15 July 2009 at 11:42 | Mike
-
Hi Will,
>>> I and others have suggested this before: why not add a new task: "check dismissed tasks"? <<<
Yeah, that kind of thing might be of some help. There is something about adding things to the list that are just there to make the list work properly that rubs me the wrong way. I don't want to make my list even longer by having a bunch of list maintenance chores on the list. It might be a somewhat practical idea but it offends me from a systems point of view. From a systems point of view I'd rather have the rules of the system outside of the system itself ... otherwise a nasty recursive loop can occur ;-) I mean, if the last item on the list is "check the beginning" and I'm always going to the end ... well, you can see what will happen there ... it basically becomes AF1 with operation directions as list items rather than as rules! ;-) ;-)
What made AF so nice and attractive was the simplicity of it all. If I now have to clutter my list with list management overhead that will bog it down too much. That was why though I liked Mark's "switch to AF1" entry but then dropped the idea.
Moreover, it takes away the "auto" from AutoFocus.
15 July 2009 at 11:52 | Mike
-
Hi Mike
My jacket is reversable. It's either one solid color.....or......patchwork depending on whether I'm in lasar focus mode or kaleidescopic mode! ROTFL!
learning as I go
15 July 2009 at 12:13 | learning as I go
-
Hi Mike
ROTFL ROTFL ROTFL (losing a little pee....) ROTFL ROTFL ROTFL......
" I don't want to make my list even longer by having a bunch of list maintenance chores on the list. It might be a somewhat practical idea but it offends me from a systems point of view."
learning as I go
15 July 2009 at 12:28 | learning as I go
-
Hi Mike
I'm sure ratz will offer you a better explanation, afterall he was the brilliant guy who coined the phrase.
In reference to me, refer back to my frig on the wall, maneuvering stuff until I got the driving principles of Flylady's system. When I don't instant "get" driving principles, or more simply, the "why? of it", I use inductive reasoning to get there. In the meanwhile, my mind is like a kaleidescope changing and digesting....until the answer hits me full force.
Then I'm light years ahead of the game......I can know ACCURATELY use deductive reasoning top down rather than blindly "trusting" a sequence. For art....lots of artists spend lots of effort doing thumbnails.......If I feel that Gestalt confidence, I'll just attack the canvas! LOL! In my profession it paid WELL to be able to work fast from what's being fed to you from your brain.
Ratz, again....thank you for that phrase! Gestalt Learning. People never understood when I tried to explain that without a suffienct, prior knowledge base, I learn using inductive reasoning rather than blinding memorizing sequences or facts. Once we have it, it's GREAT ADVANTAGE. In school, it was great for advanced math and sciences, music, art...even sports. Once it's gelled into our minds, we can use it to our (almost) infinite advantage!
learning as I go
15 July 2009 at 12:49 | learning as I go
-
Mike, you aren't the only one still working AF2 in pure form - it's working quite well for me with no tweaks.
It really does sound like it is not ideal for you, though... I'm not ADD but I'm married to one so I know the "this is URGENT" instinct for the things that are in front of you quite well (just this morning the hubby was poking at the dishes in the sink while the kiddo was asking for her milk... one of those things could have waited until they left to catch the bus; the other couldn't!).
15 July 2009 at 12:53 | Sarah
-
Mike,
I think I know what you mean: if you're manually rechecking everything you discard then what, exactly, is AF doing for you?
Well, it still does a useful filtering job and your review of dismissed items could be set with a higher threshold, but it's essentially rework. I'm not sure I agree that the practical effect would be significant, but I do see that it is a little grubby.
It would be nice if there were a way to make sure that you have a chance to work all the important tasks before they get there. ratz' suggestion seems logical.
Mike, Learning, just a suggestion:
http://www.scottevest.com/v3_store/Evolution_Jacket.shtmlShould be able to handle whatever you come up with...
15 July 2009 at 12:57 | Will
-
p.s.
boop boop boop.....It's like we get our top down knowledge by seeing patterns and reasons in seemingly random or sequential bottom up stuff.....or......in reverse....once we have the governing principles, we can use our kaleidescopic thinking to CREATE or to SOLVE.
Is that better? Some things are just hard to articulate....especially the mechanisms behind Gestalt thinking! ! ! ROTFL ROTFL ROTFL
learning as I go
15 July 2009 at 12:58 | learning as I go
-
Wow, fascinating discussion.
>I and others have suggested this before: why not add a new task: "check dismissed tasks"?
This gets to the heart of it for me. And more especially perhaps with Balfour's posts here even than with Mike's. I continue to believe Mark's biggest error with both versions of AF was his decision to use the word "dismissal" for a process that really does NOT involve dismissing tasks, but rather putting them on the back burner in terms of daily action and actually bringing them FRONT AND FORWARD in terms of analysis and inspection. This is not what dismissal means in common parlance!
If you have a repeating task near the end of your list to review your dismissed tasks, and if you follow the AF rule to "let some time pass" and to think hard about them before re-entering them, you will surely develop an end-of-list that mixes the important and the urgent, solving your problem.
(If you simply have too many things that you are equally committed to doing that's different of course, and not AF's fault.)
Balfour wrote:
>There's things on the list that I simply can't dismiss. That's why they call it work - you have to do a lot of it.
Again this only makes sense if dismissing something means you don't have to do it. It doesn't.
15 July 2009 at 13:11 | ludlow
-
Actually, rereading the question, what AF is doing for Mike is filtering out the urgent tasks, which are getting done, and dismissing some of the important ones with the dross.
Maybe a quick review of the tasks in the danger zone to pull out the important ones? Or, counter intuitively, to manually eliminate the dross so that the dismissed becomes a treasury of important tasks for periodic review?
As you can tell, I am NOT an inventor of task management systems. Good luck, Mike! Let us know what you come up with.
And have a great week chasing your wife!
15 July 2009 at 13:14 | Will
-
Oops: cross post. Nicely put, ludlow.
15 July 2009 at 13:17 | Will
-
Hi Will
If I sewed up 22 of those pockets, it would be great! I'm outdoors alot in all 4 seasons! Unless the hail is the size of golfballs, I'll be out there at least for part of my day. It amazes me how many people are outdoors only long enough to walk from a building to their auto! LOL!
learning as I go
15 July 2009 at 13:48 | learning as I go
-
ludlow - I completely agree that the choice of the word "dismissal" is part of the problem. You don't actually have to throw the item away. My out of sight but not forgotten items, which I create by highlighting, allowing me to complete a page, can come back when I'm ready to do it. These are primarily in the non-urgent, someday/maybe realm for me so far.
Mike, I have to thank you again for explaining my wrong approach. I think I've got it now. I also went back and read something in a thread by Mark further explaining how to walk through the system each day. Yesterday after I got it, I used the "on notice" technique on both work and home lists and I really got some stuff moving! Accompanied by a huge burst of energy and euphoria! (If my friends could see me now...)
Part of the problem with the old lingering items in the original AF was how to pick among a landscape where nothing stood out and nothing was immediately urgent. The "on notice" method creates a way to just pick and clear out the old stuff.
Mark, you're a genius!
15 July 2009 at 13:52 | Balfour
-
Mike wrote:
'It takes me a good 10 - 15 minutes to read the list over.'
It does sound like your list is far FAR toooo looong to work effectively with AF2 rules.
I'd shunt 90+% of it onto project/hobby/tickler/SDM lists.
If there's not a healthy % chance I'll do something in the next week or so, then I'd add it straight to the above lists.
Then all it needs is a more general task 'read book' 'sort bike' etc added to the AF2 list.
15 July 2009 at 16:55 | smileypete
-
Mike –
>>New item in both AF1 and AF2: "Fix up bike for trip on Thursday"
In AF1, I'd be working on early pages and not get to it for a while.
In AF2, I'd go right to that and start "fixing" Which would spawn:
- Go to bike store: Buy tubes
- Get current maps of C&O trail
- Email X to ask how his trip went
- Buy snacks to eat on ride
- Learn how to fix a flat
- Get tools to fix flat
- Get new pump
- etc.
So you see that six tasks came from that one ... and that happens for most of these things. It just seems as if the older tasks spawn fewer things. Maybe because they are not so urgent and so I work on them in blocked time? I dunno >>>>
Wouldn’t you have to do the same 6 spawned tasks to do no matter when you first wrote ‘fix bike’ on your list?
>>>>Well, in my case it is because I have only 15 lines per page.<<<
Have you thought of using a book with more pages per line? If you have a page with 30 lines, you just cut the number of pages in half even though you have the same # of projects – but the list may be easier to manage if you have 4 open pages rather than 8.
>>> so I rip out my AF pages and I would never do that to a sewn book ... there is something sacrilegious about that <<<
Not to mention that the other pages would start to fall out and that’s probably not the best way to lower the number of open pages you have LOL
15 July 2009 at 18:02 | Lillian
-
Mike: Seriously now. How do you have time to write these long posts? On the time it takes to write all this, you could have started on your old todos already!
Isn't this a typical example of procrastination? It reminds me, why am I writing this post?
Life is too important to be taken seriously. - Oscar Wilde
15 July 2009 at 18:05 | Mattias
-
Ratz,
>>> .... my work is 85% customer support; I am simply am not allowed to dismiss an item a customer needs answered and some days the new items do breed like bunnies. So I grok your pain. <<<
>>ROTF ;-) But hey, "customer support"? I thought the GOAL of "customer support" was to hang up, misinterpret, misunderstand, and misdirect! LOL ;-) <<
I own the company; and I do the level 1 support; not an option. Kill the problem on first contact I say.
>>> My simple example is; if you'll know what to do when the time comes don't break the task down any smaller. ....
>>Exactly. That is what drove me away screaming from GtD!<<
Good I have spent 5 years preaching that to people.
>>LOL ;-) I hear 'ya. I'm a compulsive list maker myself. (I hear they are coming out with new jackets for us next year. ;-)<<
I have amazon prime for just such items.
>>> 2a) if a task doesn't go BOOM today then give yourself permission to skip past it in favor of something that might be lurking in the list. Mark calls it intuition; I call it sensible choosing; there's a difference between that and just doing the fun stuff; that old saying inspiration is 98% perspiration; I don't get through the list anywhere as easy as Mark does; but I get through it by making choices and decisions as I go; I actively make my intuition and rational thoughts fight about what task to do. I have to drag myself through the list. Until I find a task I CAN'T resist doing (intuition) or one that will go BOOM if I don't do it (rational). <<<
>>Yes. That is where the tweaks come in. I was trying to work without the tweaks but now I see that is not going to be possible.<<
>>> Each time you pass through the list; look at each item as you get to it.
(i) If it goes boom do it (be honest with yourself boom means QA-BOOM, not *pop*);
(ii) If no boom; then put a symbol like "!" in front of it.
(iii) If it has Qty 3, "!!!" then don't add any more marks.
(iv) Don't do any tasks that doesn't have Qty 3 marks.
Three is an arbitrary number pick a number you like greater than or equal to 2. That will force items it age a little bit and help get them off your reticulating radar. <<<
>>That's a tweak I'll have to remember in my brainstorm this next week.<<
Notice how that tweak change my personal behavior; I basically think of new things too fast, (Squirrel!!!!!) and can resist them so I added a buffer to autofocus that doesn't change autofocus it just slows down the process of new items getting into the system. with permissions to prevent QA-BOOM.
The key hear is to recognize something; you really really really want to tweak yourself not autofocus. I know that sounds like blaming you; but it's not, it's about learning the right way to modify system when you tweak. When Mark creates these things he puts in processes that tweak the human; in the end it's one elegant Human tweak. But some rules are fundamental; you can add more but you shouldn't change the foundation ones or you get bizarre results.
More precisely...
Enhancements should not change the LONG term behavior of a system. Long term is usually a signal that the change is breaking the elemental design; tweaks that have a short term impact on the system are usually focused on tweaking the users. I've delt with this issue in software design over the years. AF2 really is just a logic flow like a piece of software is....
Examples of tweaking the human (good tweaks): My "!!!" tweak only last for the execution of 3-5 tasks then it vanishes; it manages my behavior. It's a buffer to slow down my high revving engine. Marks Process of drawing the daily line as manages my behavior; the effect of the line lasts 1 day; after that those tasks vanish and the impact of the line moves down the list to new victums. The line manages the human.
Example of tweaking the system (bad tweaks / gamming the system): The suggestion to re-write all urgent items on notice for dismissal at the end of the list so they are in the "newness" zone. That has a long term impact because you've reset the aging timer and it will take days for them to re-age again; that too long term. Esenntially. that's gaming the system because Autofocus is based on an "aging" principle; if you game it like this you wreck the way the foundation works and the system will destabilize.
Example of a possible good tweak (the worries tweak); write all dismissed items into a separate note book, autofocus style. Every 2 weeks; process that dismissed book AF1 style; add back 1 item per page and no more to AF2 book; if you can find something on a page that you want to add back; then dismiss the page with confidence that they really are dead items.
For ME ME ME, I focus on leaving autofocus rules the same; and tweaking the way I select things with my intuition, because that's my flaw I get trapped on the end of the list and don't move through it; I need to give myself permission to let that phone call go to voicemail for process later. I play my SLICE and it's dam handy when a QA-BOOM shows up that requires me to hit a target around the corner with a curve.
>>> 3b) Break up your hyper focus if your job/ life requires that you task switch more frequently than you are naturally inclined to.
>>Yes, I have a watch with repeating timers. (Timex Ironman for those who are bound to ask ;-) I use 20 minutes for the "little and often" type things and 2 hours for the larger tasks. For even bigger things I use 4 hours.<<
>>> If you do (2b) you'll have to at least 3 other tasks from the list before you can restart that task. <<<
>>Nice synchronicity there ;-) <<
That's because we are talking short term effects so they CAN have interplay the is greater than the parts separately.
>>> my daughter and I have severe Gestalt learning issues. <<<
>>What does that mean? Just curious. Never heard that term.<<
Danger danger tangent at hand.....
Gestalt learners are mild Aspergers syndrome people; which are mild Autistic. There is an exponential progress from Gestalt through Aspergers to Autistic. Each one is much more debilitating the than the previous. Gestalt is just getting recognition lately the Aspergers is well accepted now but that's a recent development.
Gestalt learners learn in chunks; you learn learn learn learn and understand nothing and you can use it, but you sense the pattern; finally once you learn enough chucks, BAM! all of it clicks at once; and you get all of it. This were the lightbulb going on analogy comes from. Everyone has a little of this; Gestalt are 80-100% that experience. Gestalts tend to be very slow to learn verbal language; non verbal queues; and social interactions.
If taught via Drill and Grill, around 7th-8th grade Gestalts master their learning style and usually start out performing the norms because the harder the subject matter is; the more you have to "chunk it" to learn it and the Gestalt's have been doing that all along and they get very very good at it; and they excel at high math; science, and oddly the visual arts. Often the are called "late bloomers" as if something magical happens.
40 years ago U.S. Schools taught via Rot-Repetitive or Drill and Grill if you prefer. Gestalt's learn well that way and so do "Normals". So nobody noticed those students with that pre-disposistion in the population; they stayed below the radar for the most part; simply late bloomers. Today U.S. Schools don't do Drill and Grill any more because the "Norms" learn better without it, and Drill and Grill is boring for the teachers. (No offense teachers I love you and I'd find it boring too), but The Gestalt's fail miserably with this style. So now there is a whole new trend in public schools of getting the 5% of the students that are Gestalt labelled as Autistic and there-by funded with public money so they can get special sessions in school to basically drill and grill these kids.
I was lucky, I grew up in the Drill and Grill world; we have to school my daughter in parallel at home using Drill and Grill. It took forever to get her diagnosed; it's an all new area of learning science about 10 years old and not fully understood; I understand what I do, because I read the papers and realized the papers were about ME so I was able to grok it very fast and figure out how to help her; aka teach her the way I learn and *poof* results.
I find myself help more families understand this each year.
.....Tangent over.....
>>> You aren't broken; AF2 is not broken; there is a slight possibility that a percentage of the population is not compatible with AF2 out of the box. <<<
>>Yes. I was just objecting to the attitude that people were having when any of us complained about the problems with AF2 ... it implied that it was our fault. And yes, systems must mesh with personality.<<
It's all semantics' they are trying to help you tweak yourself; the questions and examples are off because they are focusing on the system rules; not the humans rules. I can't right my answers until I read all theirs to see what was going on with the discussion. You frustration told me there was a semantic trap here to unravel... I like those challenges.
15 July 2009 at 18:33 | ratz
-
Grrr typo.... The following is what I meant to say
Example of a possible good tweak (the worries tweak); write all dismissed items into a separate note book, autofocus style. Every 2 weeks; process that dismissed book AF1 style; add back 1 item per page and no more to AF2 book; if you can **NOT** find something on a page that you want to add back; then dismiss the page with confidence that they really are dead items.
15 July 2009 at 19:30 | ratz
-
Hi Mike
<<Yes, but that is not AF2, as I understand it. There is no "automatic" (i.e. rule driven) method to get you back to the early tasks that you know you ought to be working on. I am even more convinced that no one but Mark is actually doing pure AF2. >>
You're absolutely right Mike - I really didn't want to tweak the system but was not willing to give up my old list. With erratic discretionery time (that phrase is getting too worn!!!) I didn't feel I had a choice. I am hoping that my list will eventually reduce to a more manageable number of pages and will see what happens then!
In your comment to learning you stated
<<Just last night I was cursing that I sat down to dinner but did not bring my drink with me. I got up to get it and then realized it was there but unseen ... so I did not "forget" so much as I "forgot that I did not forget". >>
It seems to me that that exactly sums up "your" AF experience in that you "need" to see the item to recollect how and why it got there. One of the things that I have always tried to do when creating systems (TM or otherwise) is to look at what the person using it requires. Just because something works for one person in no way means it will work for everyone. What I have loved about AF has been the way in which it has enabled me to identify how "I" work or react to things (eg my dishwasher moment). Realising that I had a great resistance to being told "when" to do something, freed up a lot of things. Using AF to work on things "when" I wanted was a major breakthrough - but probably would have been totally meaningless to many others. The fact that AF2 has enabled you to identify a very specific "need" in the way you work is actually a really positive thing - once you know the what you can work with it - adapting to the slice as ratz put it.
It makes me realise that is what I was trying to explain in the discussion with Norman U about "must do" items. The "need" to do certain items is not necessarily driven by any degree of urgency or importance but by something else, maybe a need not to fail, or just that it is on the page, or that it is holding up something else. As I see it the important thing is to recognise those drivers - we can then choose whether we want to eliminate them or work around them, but if we do not recognise that they are there we will always be that 30 yards off target.
15 July 2009 at 21:02 | Christine B
-
Hi ratz
You mean there's an actual thing called Gestalt Learning? I thought you just coined a phrase. It was like looking in the mirror..........but you burst my bubble when you called it a learning disability. I always felted highly advantaged over the other students. I'd simply be patient for a little while in the beginning. Then when the Gestalt happened, I'd be catapulted waaaay ahead. They kept bumping me up to more advanced learning. It was clearly a huge advantage. Why is it called a disability if it allows us to easily manipulate knowledge and ideas in ways that most others can't?
Clearly, in everyday life, it presents challenges.....but the advantages FAR outweigh the challenges....Yes?
learning as I go
15 July 2009 at 23:10 | learning as I go
-
I think people are trying to tweak the system to solve problems with their relationship with their own intuition. The "tasks that stand out" is part of the magic in AF/AF2.
If every easy task you could ever do stands out every time you see it, then you'll never work on the important things.
You can tweak the system endlessly, but if your intuition isn't guiding you to the tasks that really need to be done right now then it is all a waste of your time. Then you might as well start prioritizing, but its likely that will just lead to procrastination. The great breakthrough in AF in my opinion is that the system gives you an opportunity to observe your patterns and learn to modify them as you learn what tasks you pick, which ones you habitually avoid, etc.
I could rant on about this, but I'd love to see Mark's thoughts on this because it seems like one part of AF that is a little under-specified. It's probably one of those things that's best taught in a live training, but I think it gets far less attention than things like which direction to cross items off the list. AF probably works great out of the box for people who already have a good relationship with their own intuition and can be struggle for those who don't.
15 July 2009 at 23:14 | Power Secrets
-
Hi Power Secrets
That's an excellent point. It is the "standing out" that is unique and there are a number of posts on this from the early days of AF1 Beta Testing. I think the problems come when one succombs to the pressure of the urgent and forgets to "trust the system". I would say I had probably stated to fall victim to that and AF2 is rekindling that connection with the intuitive standing out process. Thanks for the reminder! :-)
15 July 2009 at 23:57 | Christine B
-
Hi Power Secrets
Generalizing isn't always a good idea. You state:
"You can tweak the system endlessly, but if your intuition isn't guiding you to the tasks that really need to be done right now then it is all a waste of your time. Then you might as well start prioritizing, but its likely that will just lead to procrastination"
For many of us, prioritization reduces procrastination. Because we're current or slightly ahead, we're rarely in the zone of having any tasks at all in that quadrant you call "need to be done right now". We were taught to use prioritizing expressly to avoide the urgent zone so that we can be of free mind to work on the important stuff.
This is a heavily populated world......most generalizations won't encompass the entire population. In fact, I'd dare say that as many people find success with working within the urgent zone, just as many prefer to avoid it by priorizing.
learning as I go
16 July 2009 at 0:48 | learning as I go
-
Learning as I go,
I need to work on my dry sarcasim. It is now classified as a learnin disability. I don't view it as one. It is the irony that the u.s. Education system went from something that works for everyone to some thing that is easier for the teachers. I will take my gestalt "affliction" any day of the week.
the things my mind can do blows ppl away everyday I easily out produce 4 ppl everyday at the price of about 2 really crap days a month.
I love that brilliance of my daughter she might at times be dumb as a box of rocks for a while. But when she leaps forward it is a thin of beauty. She will mature to be far smarter than I am And I am far from slow and dense.
The doctors refer to it as a learning style. It is classified as a disabilty because the current curriculum make it a barrier to learning and that is wrong
16 July 2009 at 1:14 | Ratz
-
Hi learning as I go.
I guess we understand the meaning of the word generalization a bit differently, but that's not really worth arguing about here.
My central point was that tweaking the system with structural or sequence changes isn't likely to address the issue of why the important tasks don't stand out for someone. I think that the AF process provides mechanisms for calling out items not being addressed which is a big step forward. It doesn't explicitly address how to make arrangements with your intuition, which may be one reason why it works great for some and not for others.
Purely my opinion of course, but maybe I need to state that very clearly on each post.
16 July 2009 at 1:44 | Power Secrets
-
Learning,
<<< My jacket is reversable. It's either one solid color.....or......patchwork depending on whether I'm in lasar focus mode or kaleidescopic mode! ROTFL! <<<
ROTFLMAO ;-) I really love that people on this list are so damn funny ... and clever ;-)
16 July 2009 at 2:38 | Mike
-
Power Secrets, Learning,
Actually, you can't tweak the system endlessly - at least until you have really mastered it.
Wax on; wax off (repeat for ten years).
On the other hand,
1. the system itself is new and changing every few months as Mark comes up with revisions: this is not yet a grounded system like the Japanese martial arts (which still evolve, but directed by masters with many years of deep understanding)
2. when problems arise, we need to judge for ourselves whether there is something special about us that the system doesn't fit or there is an issue in the way we are implementing the system. We have only each other and Mark for guidance.
It probably shows some deep inner insecurity, but my personal preference is to attempt to follow the system. without any sort of tweak, but to follow this forum for issues and for views on how to deal with problems. At the moment I too am struggling to get all the way through the list, so things are getting dismissed. Partly because I am spending too long in the forum.
But I respect those who take full ownership for their working style and are adapting their own systems. I especially like ratz' thoughts on long and short term tweaks. Though I'll persist for a while, at least until Mark has commented.
16 July 2009 at 9:02 | Will
-
Shouldn't we ask ourselves, how a certain task got onto our list?
Did it come from a commitment, or from external pressure, or from a fear, or by chance?
16 July 2009 at 11:29 | Rainer
-
Hi Ratz
Thank you for the explanation. You weren't being sarcastic at all. I was simply totally dumbstruck that such an advantage could be called a disability! Leave it to a government body to gum things up. It tears me up to think that there are children getting negative labels over being outside the norm. The negative label alone might ruin their chances of being able to appreciate being who they are and to develop their mind and personality. Ratz, your daughter is a very lucky girl........she's been given 2 gifts. A nimble mind and a wonderful father.
learning as I go
16 July 2009 at 12:45 | learning as I go
-
“There is nothing so bad that politicians cannot make it worse” – Mark Twain
16 July 2009 at 13:08 | Rainer
-
Hi Mike
"ROTFLMAO ;-) I really love that people on this list are so damn funny ... and clever ;-)
July 16, 2009 at 2:38 | Mike "
Right back at you, buddy! I use this forum not only as my one of two sanctioned internet breaks, I also use it as a lifeline........When my pain forces me into amoeba status, I can come here to squeek out some pleasure (and learning) despite my circumstance.
Bless you all......I'm CERTAINLY grateful that Mark's personality attracts such a great group of people.
learning as I go
p.s. Mark, I apologize if my gushing is embarrassing you....but it is my truth.
16 July 2009 at 13:16 | learning as I go
-
There are so many great comments in this thread! One of the things I love about AF is that it really does give so much more insight into our ways of working than any other system I have ever tried. The key to that I am sure is the element of intuition but that in itself creates more and more interesting discussions. It feels like AF and it's effect is evolving - no wonder Mark is never satisfied with a system - I think the system itself is so good that it does actually enable us to change, both our working methods and our approach, and that in turn throws up new challenges.
The massive breakthrough with AF1 for me was the process of "standing out". It provided a systemic approach to creating that feeling of "flow" and all of a sudden work was not only easy but enjoyable. That position has proved more difficult for some to grasp than others but when that feeling occurs it is almost magical. However I think some people don't necessarily want or need that approach, preferring instead the sense of control that rationalisation brings and that is where the tension can lie.
For me, I "got" the standing out process almost straight away and felt very fortunate to do so. However with the advent of AF2 I realise that I had somehow drifted back to a more rational way of working. I can see that there is still a part of me that has that rational desire - in that I have tweaked the timing of working the on notice items - but AF2 has gotten me back so much closer to that flow process. Being able to choose from anywhere in the list, and to skip over pages that do not stand out, has freed up a lot of items which I was clearly inhibiting from standing out in that I was saving them to enable procrastination on other items. Knowing that that red line will reach them regardless is a whole new incentive. I can no longer procrastinate on them. They must be done or dismissed TODAY!
I have three items on notice today, none of which I have gotten back to yet. I want to do them (mainly because I don't want a long list of dismissed items to review later) but may well just dismiss them - we'll see. That is so less stressful than feeling obligated to do something on the page because there are items that "can't" be dismissed.
16 July 2009 at 17:36 | Christine B
-
Mike,
How about keeping the most "stand out" of your dismissable tasks in mind as you go through the review and comparing this to each task as you go back through the list?
Just a thought.
17 July 2009 at 15:05 | Will
-
Mike
You might consider a cut and paste answer template for the linears......They all seem to allude to the same misunderstanding.
learning as I go
17 July 2009 at 15:53 | learning as I go
-
Hi Lillian,
Sorry for the delay ... I'm chasing my wife through PA right now ;-) (well, at this exact moment she is snoring peacefully but she'll be up soon to start the game again ;--
>>> Wouldn’t you have to do the same 6 spawned tasks to do no matter when you first wrote ‘fix bike’ on your list? <<<
No, as I said, that was not the case in AF1. I suspect that it was due to AF1 being "slower". Working with more urgent and immediate tasks seems to make me want to fill in the details more than it does with things that are older.
>>> Have you thought of using a book with more pages per line? If you have a page with 30 lines, you just cut the number of pages in half even though you have the same # of projects – but the list may be easier to manage if you have 4 open pages rather than 8. <<<
A larger book would have a very different effect. However, I am self-constrained by my mobility. I don't want to carry things with me if I can avoid it so I use a spiral wire bound notebook in vertical 3x5 inch format. I stuff a 1/2 size pen in the wire and it never leaves my pocket. If I had to carry a larger book around with me, I'd forget it more often than not.
>>> so I rip out my AF pages and I would never do that to a sewn book ... there is something sacrilegious about that <<<
>>Not to mention that the other pages would start to fall out and that’s probably not the best way to lower the number of open pages you have LOL <<
No, with the wires that does not happen. Also, because I treat the book as a throw away, I'm inclined to really use it rather than edit myself. I'm not sure now if that aspect is so good. Maybe I should start to edit what I put in my list?
18 July 2009 at 11:15 | Mike
-
Ratz,
Re: Learning. Yeah, I hear you. I have a "learning disability". I had it before they had words for it and it made my life miserable. If I were in the system today, I'd be classified as having ADHD and I'd be on drugs ... and probably be a zombie.
The thing is that I function very well, given what interests ME. I don't function when it comes to things I'm expected to do by the "system". And that is just fine. My wife asked me some computational problem yesterday (involving how many miles she rode and what her average was and how much she would have to make up to keep her projected average due to the rain delay, etc). I just rolled up my eyes and computed it. Now realize that arithmetic was my WORST experience in school. No longer. It is now a game with me. I could not do it when I was expected ot mindlessly memorize "times tables" but when I do my wacko method, that no one else but me can follow, I get the answer in a jiffy.
I think it was Buckminster FUller who commented that if a child wants to color the sky green and the grass blue, let him be. He probably sees much more new about the world than you do.
Conformity ... BLAH ;-)
18 July 2009 at 11:26 | Mike
-
Mike, if I weren't NOT biking across PA right now I'd be pretty sure you were my husband under a different name. ;^)
18 July 2009 at 12:37 | Sarah
-
Hi Mike
I hope you and your wife are having a grand time......Yesterday was so muggy and hot, I can't imagine your wife long distance biking......let alone trying to make time as well! Bless determination against all odds, yeah?
re: calling your exquisite, nimble mind "learning disabled....." Mike,......I'm prepared to pull out the big guns on this one.........If you continue to do that, I'll.....I'll.....I'll.....(brace yourself)....why, I'll start calling you....................(are you braced?).......................BUBBLES, SR. ! ! ! ! ! Now, stop it! You'd fight someone to the death if that did that to one of your loved ones, yeah? It's not only morally cruel.....it's simply FALSE!!!!!
(lecture over.....class of one dismissed!.....Besides, if YOU buckle to "their" labels of us, we'll consider you to be a turn-coat!.....and I'm not literally referring to our waaay cool reversable club jackets! ROTFL!)
Enjoy your trip with your wife and this beautiful weather!
learning as I go
18 July 2009 at 18:50 | learning as I go
-
footnote to others....
I'm not being cruel to Mike. He has a huge, imposing looking tom cat named Bubba who's actually a bit timid, who's name morphed into .....BUBBLES! ROTFL
18 July 2009 at 19:02 | learning as I go
-
Hey Learning,
>>> I hope you and your wife are having a grand time <<<
She is in hog heaven. But she did take a down day yesterday. On Friday she rode in a downpour and was soaked, along with everything she was carrying. Beside being exhausted, we needed to dry out her shoes and gloves and all. I think the rest will do her good.
>>>......Yesterday was so muggy and hot, I can't imagine your wife long distance biking......let alone trying to make time as well! Bless determination against all odds, yeah? <<<
She is an uber Seven ;-) I tell her that she is always trying to put 20 pounds into a five pound sack. This time is was about 100 pounds ;-) The day before her trip started, she marched in 5!!! Memorial Day parades and the day after she gets back she starts band camp! OY!!!
>>> re: calling your exquisite, nimble mind "learning disabled....." Mike,......I'm prepared to pull out the big guns on this one.........If you continue to do that, I'll.....I'll.....I'll.....(brace yourself)....why, I'll start calling you....................(are you braced?).......................BUBBLES, SR. ! ! ! ! ! Now, stop it! You'd fight someone to the death if that did that to one of your loved ones, yeah? It's not only morally cruel.....it's simply FALSE!!!!! <<<
LOL ;-) I've long ago learned to cope and to use what I have and am to my advantage. I blame the system and lazy teachers who don't put the kids first.
>>> (lecture over.....class of one dismissed!.....Besides, if YOU buckle to "their" labels of us, we'll consider you to be a turn-coat!.....and I'm not literally referring to our waaay cool reversable club jackets! ROTFL!) <<<
I REFUSE to give up my jacket ;-)
>>> Enjoy your trip with your wife and this beautiful weather! <<<
Will do. It is always an experience to be in rural America. We ran low on cash (because we did not THINK to ask the B&B we booked if they took Visa ... how could anyone in the 21st century not take Visa???) So we are sensitive to any cash outlays until we get to an ATM. But in this part of the country, ATMs are rare and one for our bank even rarer. She wanted to see the new Harry Potter movie (very much darker than the rest, BTW) but the theater did not take Visa!!??!!?? So we gave them our debit card and they did not recognize our bank and would not take it? Our bank is Bank of America, fer friggin' sake! How could they not recognize that bank? I'm really surprised that they did not want to be paid in gold nuggets, or doubloons, or pieces of eight, or something. Rural America is really it's own country!
19 July 2009 at 11:21 | Mike
-
Learning,
>>> You might consider a cut and paste answer template for the linears......They all seem to allude to the same misunderstanding. <<<
I hear 'ya. Most of my life has been about endlessly repeating things because people seem to hear only what they already think and somehow have to reinterpret what you tell them to what they can understand so they can deal with it.
Have you ever written a letter saying something like "Can you please send me a replacement for part X?" and gotten a response like "Thank you very much for your interest in our new product offering. Our new model will be out in six months and we have put you on the mailing list." WHAT? Where did that come from?
In this case, people seem to think that if I only try harder ... ROTF ;-) No, I really do "get it" and have tried available solutions and understand the full scope of the problem and ... the options within the bounds of this system will not allow it to work for me ... and that is just that. Now, as to tweaks, that's a whole 'nother story ;-) But then I said that, about 14 times so clearly I just need to try harder ;-)
[NOTE: I really do appreciate that the responses here are intended to be helpful and so I take them in that spirit and thank everyone for the suggestions. If nothing else, they have served to stimulate my thinking as well as firm my resolve to really get this sorted out. So thanks all!]
I have, BTW, taken this whole business as my "project" for this trip. So far I've gone back to basics ... first principles, if you will ... and reworked my whole time management system. I've not changed a whole hell of a lot, but I've formalized and integrated everything into one single consistent (and hopefully seamless and useful) system. I stopped at Wally-World and picked up a $0.50 cent notebook and FILLED it with charts, graphs, mind maps and flow charts ... yeah, and lists ... lots and lots of lists! ROTF ;-) I just about have all the dots connected and am ready to christen my new system. Maybe I'll call it the BUBBLES system ;-) Now if I can only find a nice fine bottle of champagne for $0.75 at Wally-World ... ;-)
19 July 2009 at 11:43 | Mike
-
Sarah,
>>> Mike, if I weren't NOT biking across PA right now I'd be pretty sure you were my husband under a different name. ;^) <<<
ROTF ;-) I turn to the broad view to understand such things. My first question is always "How does this enhance the survival of the species?" If you look at it that way, you'll see that species survival requires us "outliers". Most of the herd has to be all the same. They cope well in the status quo ... that is almost the definition of "status quo": "The stable environment in which most of the herd survives and prospers." But for the herd to survive it must survive CHANGE. And only the outliers will prosper under conditions of change. So when things change, we will be the ones ready to cope and thrive ... and thus become the new herd, I guess ;-) HUH? NO!!! I don't WANT to be part of the herd ... not even if the herd is built around me and my fellows ;-) ;-)
19 July 2009 at 11:50 | Mike
-
Raner,
>>> Shouldn't we ask ourselves, how a certain task got onto our list?
Did it come from a commitment, or from external pressure, or from a fear, or by chance? <<<
Odd you should think to ask that. In my new system I formalized almost that exact question in the process flow. I made it part of the dismissal process to question how the task came about and if it should really be there at all. The answers determine how the task is to be disposed: "someday/maybe", trashed forever, put on the projects list, delegated ... etc.
19 July 2009 at 11:56 | Mike
-
Power,
>>> I think that the AF process provides mechanisms for calling out items not being addressed which is a big step forward. It doesn't explicitly address how to make arangements with your intuition, which may be one reason why it works great for some and not for others. <<<
That is part of what is going on with my problem with AF2. I did not really "get it" until I started integrating all I know about time management systems and noticed that AF combined several distinct processes ... and those work at cross purposes if combined into one tool:
- Universal Capture (Grass Catcher)
- Planning
- Prioritizing
- Scheduling
- Execution (TO DO)
Now that I caught on to that (it now seems blatantly obvious) observation ;-) I am in a position to rework (not tweak ;-) the system for my needs. I will now allow AF to only ASSIST in the filtering process and mostly restrict it to the execution phase of the whole process.
I do not possess the thinking style which will allow me to have one tool do all of that and simply implicitly trust that it will just happen automagically. AF works as a good filter, but my way of thinking works best if I put in explicit filters before things get into the system to start with, and at the point of dismissal as well.
19 July 2009 at 12:11 | Mike
-
Christine,
>>> That's an excellent point. It is the "standing out" that is unique and there are a number of posts on this from the early days of AF1 Beta Testing. I think the problems come when one succombs to the pressure of the urgent and forgets to "trust the system". I would say I had probably stated to fall victim to that and AF2 is rekindling that connection with the intuitive standing out process. Thanks for the reminder! :-) <<<
My observations are much the same as to how things are working ... but I am coming down in the direction of the opposite reaction ;-) I guess that I do NOT trust the system, and am not sure that I ever will ... or should. Systems are our creations, products of our thinking, and to trust them but not our thinking is something of a contradiction. I will trust a system under these conditions:
- I am sure that I have thought it through thoroughly,
- I have put in enough checks and balances so that I will hear sirens if there is a problem with it,
- It fits with my own personal thinking style.
The thing is that intuition is just the automation of thinking and if the thinking is not there, and correct, then the intuition will be faulty, Intuition will lead to disaster if placed in the wrong context or if it is built on faulty thinking.
19 July 2009 at 13:01 | Mike
-
Morning' Mike!
Your wife sounds like a real dynamo! Bless her spirit!
Mike, I've found that analyzing, fancy charts, etc....didn't help me at all. I work in 3 basic modes. 1: reasonably and rationally willing 2. monkey mind mode and 3. donkey mode (I affectionately dubbed this mode: Stubborn Ass Syndrome
1. Easy.....I simply do the stuff with appropriate pacing and breaks.
2. Same as one but I'm on the alert to gently refocus my brain to my objectives. My breaks might be short forays into monkey mind fodder........A timer is crucial!
3. I break it down and impose a timer. I reset it to a time that the donkey is willing to do. If the short burst doesn't break the barrier, I simply rinse and repeat. The short breaks are "less onerous work to sandwhich between the onerous short burst of the dreaded stuff. I also negotiate a final STOP for the day time. This promised sub-unit is NEVER more than two hours. So Mr. donkey breath has his choice to either intersperse short timed bursts sandwhiched between the other tasks or to hold his nose and get it off his plate so that he can do the other stuff without the drag of dread polluting his mind.
My dad used to always say, "You can stop working when either you're finished or the sun sets, which ever comes first. My sunset is 2 hours.
Sure, the donkey is the only real spammer in the works, but.....none the less, he has the power..........Even if I have to set the timer to only 5 minutes at a clip, EVENTUALLY one of the 5 minute launches will catapault him over the hump. I also allow myself to chip away at the dreaded chunk of work on previous days to lower the 2 hour allotment of dreaded work.
Sometimes the donkey's attitude actually facilitates my getting my other work out of the way while I'm sandwhiching it between rounds of chipping away at THE dreaded task of the day! It's the same phenomenum as giving my flat the white glove treatment whilst meeting a dreaded deadline. ROTFL! In college we used to joke.....don't bother cleaning it today, it'll be spotless during exam week! ROTFL See? Even though the donkey can be seen as the weakest member of my "brain team", he also inspires the others via structured procrastination.......silver lining and all that.....
Re: your reply to Raner (yes, my nose sometimes sniffs outside it's proper boundaries...*blush*........................caution!!! Possible proselyizing message....
Mark's DIT book has a section (the best one!) called Commitment vs Interest. It covers this brilliantly! After all, our REASONS provide both our motives and our resistance!
My weekly DIT allows for both no nonsense working and flexibility to work out my foibles and to actually ENJOY the grand aspects of life. I know that lots of people do brilliantly working within the Urgent zone for most of their work, but I don't like that. For both my pleasures and my passions, I prefer a free mind without the drag of guilt polluting it. It gives me a better atmosphere for both creativity and unfettered fun. That's just me.
That's why I'm strict with the donkey and vigilant with the monkey. The monkey is the silent star player. I love him best of all when I don't need to get a PARTICULAR job done...The rest of the time, he's my muse! ROTFL!
learning as I go
19 July 2009 at 13:04 | learning as I go
-
Hi Mike
whoop whoop whoopie! You've provided me with future fodder to peruse! Thanks!
Now.......to......decide...........determination or drugs?............Pain always has me making tough decisions! LOL!
learning as I go
19 July 2009 at 13:08 | learning as I go
-
correction:
2. is monkey mind mode.........decision........1. get away from keyboard and properly start my day.....try without drugs first.....
19 July 2009 at 13:11 | learning as I go
-
Hi Mike
My nose overextending again.....you stated to Christine B.
> The thing is that intuition is just the automation of thinking and if the thinking is not there, and correct, then the intuition will be faulty, Intuition will lead to disaster if placed in the wrong context or if it is built on faulty thinking. <
That's the premise I used when labeling the parts of my brain. It gives me an approachable, non castigating way of approaching my foibles. (faulty thinking in a particular context)
Of course, they are only foibles in the context of my defined work. I NEED my monkey and my donkey on other contexts of thinking/doing/living.................as they say............it's all good if you know how to work it! ROTFL!
learning as I go
19 July 2009 at 13:41 | learning as I go
-
OY! I need to get away from the keyboard....please ignore my awful, slopy grammer and spelling..................phenomenum........what's up with that? ROTFL!
Pain rules.............relegate myself to ameoba type tasks that don't require use of the English language.....
19 July 2009 at 13:49 | learning as I go
-
I haven't read all this thread - sounds like you've all been having fun while I've been away. But I would like to address Wooba's orginal post:
If you expanded the list in the way I recommend in the instructions, how did you get 25 items in a row which you haven't taken any action on?
19 July 2009 at 17:43 | Mark Forster
-
Mike:
<< Conformity ... BLAH ;-) >>
You're right. The whole point of AF2 is to help you to get things done, not to get in the way of your getting things done. So if you have something that works better for you, then use it.
The one point I'd make about AF2 is that it is less tolerant than AF1 of being used as a dumping ground for everything you can possibly think of.
19 July 2009 at 17:53 | Mark Forster
-
Hi Mark!
> " I haven't read all this thread - sounds like you've all been having fun while I've been away." <
Well, come on in and join the party! (Don't worry card-carrying members. It's not like he's going to regard us as a faction of Sinn Fein.....besides, he's NOT "the law".....he's actually one of us! )
No, Joe....don't draw him one from the USA taps, he prefers his ale room temperature!
learning as I go
19 July 2009 at 19:25 | learning as I go
-
Hi Mike. It sounds like you've resolved many of the issues you've been having with AF2. I have found as someone else mentioned in this thread, that my (electronic) AF2 list cannot manage minutiae tasks. As I have mentioned in previous posts, my list is very general (Clean, Organize, Blog, Video Projects, etc.). I then have associated lists that function much the way GTD lists do. So I have a list or cleaning tasks I'd like to get to, Blog ideas to write, etc. The exception that I make is I always add time-sensitive tasks to my main list. So I never stress out about getting to tasks on my clean list because the critical ones (like tasks to do before guests arrive) are on my main list.
The other thing you might try is to add the tasks, "Work on "on notice" task" and "Work on task on page X" where X is a middle page. This might provide more of the balance you are looking for.
I am not having trouble getting to my whole list because it is much, much shorter than it was--probably only 2 pages' worth or less. I also know, however, that we think and work much differently. You'd probably want to shoot yourself if you had to borrow my brain for a day. ;-)
19 July 2009 at 19:32 | Mel
-
Learning:
<< No, Joe....don't draw him one from the USA taps, he prefers his ale room temperature! >>
This is a common misconception. Ale should be drunk at *cellar* temperature, not room temperature.
19 July 2009 at 20:41 | Mark Forster
-
Hi Mark
You mean like a root cellar.or wine cellar...50 or so degrees Fahrenheit?
learning as I go
19 July 2009 at 21:05 | learning as I go
-
I'm relatively new to Autofocus and to this thread, but have used both AF1 and AF2, and the following points strike me.
1. Neither system is perfect, and nor - brilliant though he is - is Mark. So there's no reason why any of us shouldn't tailor either system for our own purposes if it doesn't work for us in Mark's version.
2. I'm surprised that Mark's paper didn't list as one of the differences between AF1 and AF2 the absolutely key point which is that you work from the front in AF1 and from the back in AF2.
3. The head tells us we should work from the front; the heart tells us we should work from the back. Maybe both are right, and we should alternate between them. You may be asking, "What about the stuff in the middle?" Well, that will eventually move to the front, won't it?
4. I have an item in my AF list named "Daily list", which refers to a Word document in which I list all deadlined activities in ascending order of the deadline date, plus things that need to done on a daily or other recurring basis. I then copy relevant items from the daily list to the end of the AF list.
5. I don't dismiss items at the front automatically. If I don't think I should dismiss an item, I simply move it to the back.
19 July 2009 at 22:42 | David Lewis
-
Hi David
Although I don't use AF, my system sounds remarkable similar to yours....which suits my weekly DIT hybrid. Rather than transfer my deadlines, appointments and recurring work checklists (both one offs and batching), I simply work from the checklists and calendar along with my MITs. It's simple. All I have to do is make sure I follow it (sometimes that's the biggest challenge......My timer gets plenty of use as my taskmaster and work pacer. LOL!) I keep to my assigned limits and work hours fairly closely. The flexibility is built into it. True, some things are non-negotiables, but other things can be done more ad hoc....With the weekly format, I rarely miss my aims for the week because it provides a combination of both regimentation and flexibility.
Just out of curiosity, why do you bother to transfer this information to AF? Does AF act as both a cueing device and a work pacer? Sometimes I'll write a list if I need to do a lot and need both cueing and pacing. Usually, not. I've been with my little system for a long time so much of it is a rote practice. I'll tweak it occasionally just to get over a hurdle or to freshen up my work perspective a bit.
Mark always encourages us to develop our own ways. He's great at offering up many great ideas to test and/or tweak to integrate into our existing systems. He's lead me to many great improvements over the years! Although the basics of my system remain solid, I'm open to testing for improvements (especially the distasteful, onerous, boring stuff ) Besides, it's fun to test and tweak ideas with the awful stuff to get it out of the way in a more pleasant manner! *blush*
learning as I go
20 July 2009 at 0:27 | learning as I go
-
Hi Mel
I, too, like to work off of ancillary lists. It's a saving grace for my memory issues not to have to waste time with the question "What's next?" These lists are especially helpful for procedures I don't do very often or "don't forget type lists such as grocery and sundries master reference, packing lists (both for packing and taking all the stuff home again!, etc... Other things, I prefer the broad cue and work ad hoc such as detail cleaning room by room. Those lists overwhelmed me. I've been cleaning my home LONG enough to know when the room is clean top to bottom! LOL! I simply imagine my father doing the Saturday white glove rounds! LOL! (I'm not quite so demanding on myself but it's a good reference! LOL!)
I also love your posts that embrace your life as a whole. After all, we're doing this for good reasons whether we enjoy it or not....We're aiming for the consequences of our aims and efforts either for ourself or for others of our concern. I really admire your take on this.
learning as I go
20 July 2009 at 0:51 | learning as I go
-
Hey Mark,
<<< << Conformity ... BLAH ;-) >>
You're right. The whole point of AF2 is to help you to get things done, not to get in the way of your getting things done. So if you have something that works better for you, then use it. <<<
Or course, that comment really had nothing to do with AF ... just a comment on learning styles. But as to AF2, it has its good points and its pitfalls. I'm working my way to a good mix of things.
>>> The one point I'd make about AF2 is that it is less tolerant than AF1 of being used as a dumping ground for everything you can possibly think of. <<<
Yeah, that is why I'm going to put some clearly defined and explicit filters in front of AF ... to keep out the junk.
20 July 2009 at 1:54 | Mike
-
Hi Mel,
>>> Hi Mike. It sounds like you've resolved many of the issues you've been having with AF2. <<<
I'm well on my way.
>>> I have found as someone else mentioned in this thread, that my (electronic) AF2 list cannot manage minutiae tasks. As I have mentioned in previous posts, my list is very general (Clean, Organize, Blog, Video Projects, etc.). I then have associated lists that function much the way GTD lists do. So I have a list or cleaning tasks I'd like to get to, Blog ideas to write, etc. The exception that I make is I always add time-sensitive tasks to my main list. So I never stress out about getting to tasks on my clean list because the critical ones (like tasks to do before guests arrive) are on my main list. <<<
I've been doing that, to some extent from the beginning. I'm not sure I have a rule about how to keep the list of lists ;-) but some are obvious: "Prepare for Bike Trip" with a list of chores as a secondary list is an example
>>> The other thing you might try is to add the tasks, "Work on "on notice" task" and "Work on task on page X" where X is a middle page. This might provide more of the balance you are looking for. <<<
I'm resisting that, because as I said before, it seems wrong to include list maintenance chores as part of the list itself. I'd rather my solution be cleaner than that.
>>> I am not having trouble getting to my whole list because it is much, much shorter than it was--probably only 2 pages' worth or less. <<<
Alas, mine is so much larger
>>> I also know, however, that we think and work much differently. You'd probably want to shoot yourself if you had to borrow my brain for a day. ;-) <<<
ROTFLMAO ;-)
20 July 2009 at 2:01 | Mike
-
Hi Mike
<<I stopped at Wally-World and picked up a $0.50 cent notebook>>
Is there really a store called Wally World? In the UK, if you call someone a Wally it is an affectionate way of calling someone an idiot - it would be like calling a store Stupid World!
<< The thing is that intuition is just the automation of thinking and if the thinking is not there, and correct, then the intuition will be faulty, Intuition will lead to disaster if placed in the wrong context or if it is built on faulty thinking. >>
It does seem that a lot of the "problems" we come up with in AF are as a result of different ways of thinking but I certainly wouldn't consider any of them faulty - just different. I have to admit to an envy of your (and learning's) Gestalt thinking - it seems to me much more of an advantage than a disability! I do find quite often that I can look at a situation and somehow "see" the solution without necessarily knowing how - I then have to identify how to get from the problem to the solution but at least by then I have a concept to work with. Is this perhaps a mild disability? :-)
20 July 2009 at 4:47 | Christine B
-
Christine - Not exactly. 'Wally World' is a nickname for WalMart
20 July 2009 at 5:29 | Lillian
-
Hey Christine,
As Lilian says, it is just Walmart and they have something of a bad reputation for selling cheap Chinese junk.
Re: Intuition and Thinking. There is no "wrong" STYLE of thinking. We are who we are, after all. There are PROBLEMS with how thinking is accomplished, however. If you base your thinking on some invalid principles like WWDVD (What Would Darth Vader Do?) you are not going to live a very successful or happy life ;-) This is an entirely different notion than one's thinking style.
Re: Gestalt Thinking. That was actually someone else who introduced the term. I think that Learning and I both went along with the idea that we think more "outside of the box". I'm with her on the term "linear thinking". I tend to go from A right to Z ... but then once I get there not happy until I fill in the missing pieces. Over the years, I have built a certain amount of trust in my process in some areas. But in new areas, I still need to go back and prove the validity of my intuition.
For example: I know what my time management system needs to look like. I knew it instantly once I vented here and got lots of comments. I'm now in the process of "validating" what I know to be true. Only when I have it all mapped out will I be able to trust it enough to turn my back on it.
So you are not alone. One operates well on intuition once one has learned where to trust it.
20 July 2009 at 9:26 | Mike
-
Hi Mark,
<<<If you expanded the list in the way I recommend in the instructions, how did you get 25 items in a row which you haven't taken any action on?>>>
I started a new list and added tasks judiciously. One of them was a project that I hadn't realised was quite so involved. When I acted on it I decided to split it up into sub tasks -- 25 of them. But none of them were particularly appealing, so none of them were done.
As it happened, it all came out in the wash. All 25 tasks were done and didn't need to be dismissed. Just goes to show that AF2 works brilliantly if we just let it work how it should.
Please could you clarify: on the one hand you say to throw anything at the list, but on the other you seem to be saying that items need to be filtered before adding them. You also say that it is easy to enter sub tasks, but that is how I ended up with a block of 25 items.
20 July 2009 at 11:57 | Wooba
-
Wooba,
If I had a project with 25 sub-tasks I would not add them all to AF2 at one time. I might start with one or maybe a handful of concurrent tasks and go from there. For example I might start with "Analyze and organize needs for project 1" and then when that task stands out, I would sit down and write out what I needed for project 1, either on regular paper for a separate folder, or in a text editor on my computer, or in mind map software. I would then add one or at most a couple of "next actions" into AF2, probably in the form of "Contact Jim about Project 1" and "Research Web re: Project 1". If the project is urgent, then the tasks will stand out. As I cross out "next actions" I would just add more tasks, which keeps the project on the front burner. If the project was due far in the future (more than a few weeks) and very important and time consuming, I would add a task like "Review Project 1" to remind myself to sit down with my project management system periodically and make sure I was adding the tasks that I needed to add to AF2 so that I was doing at least something on the project every day or so.
20 July 2009 at 12:58 | Chris
-
Thanks Lillian - guess I was really off "Target" there!
20 July 2009 at 14:03 | Christine B
-
Hi Mike
Actually I was a bit disappointed - Wally World sounds much more fun!
I'm glad glad you're close to finding "your" system - I can see how AF2 would cause difficulties for your style of working. I am still reallying enjoying AF2 and it is working well - but is a lot more different to AF1 than you would think from first reading. I suspect that our minds were pretty conditioned by AF1 which made us approach certain aspects differently to someone coming at it afresh. I am still actioning my "on notice" items at whatever time of day they stand out but do not feel that detracts in any way from the actioning of the remainder of the list - whether that changes when(if!) my list gets smaller remains to be seen but at present my number of open items continues to reduce daily - now down to 234.
20 July 2009 at 14:17 | Christine B
-
Wooba, I recall Mark saying that AF2 would be much more "sensitive" with respect to "dumping". And dumping tasks related to a project you think you would resist is probably a double whammy. Glad to see that you managed to get it all done!
Chris, I have done exactly what Wooba did and it has come out successfully - albeit using AF1, not AF2. I don't want a bunch of ancillary lists and project pages with AF and only see the "project x" item occasionally - because that tends to slow down the progress of a project for me. I want to have to make a decision or make some progress on that project every day if possible. If it's something I'm really committed to doing, this works well because it pushes me to work on it at least "little and often". And if I'm not really committed to doing it, it works well too because I can dismiss the whole brain dump.
20 July 2009 at 16:39 | Jacqueline
-
Jaqueline,
I agree somewhat. I tend to keep the projects in AF and usually do not use a separate project folder. However when I am planning something complicated, I do most of that work in a project folder or on my computer. The tasks, however, are kept in AF. I was just making this suggestion because of the sheer number of sub-tasks (25) he was working with. I have never broken a project down to quite that level, even when I did GTD.
20 July 2009 at 18:32 | Chris
-
Jacqueline, I can see your concern with not working on your projects little and often by using an ancillary list. But my ancillary lists seem to have solved that problem for me. For example, I do not put "Unload dishwasher, sweep kitchen floor, etc." as individual tasks. I have an associated list of these tasks to do on a daily basis. I do them all (or most of them) when I come to CHORES on my AF2 list. In the same way, I have a Habit Focus list on my IPhone that lists how much time I need to spend on each of 5 habits related to my goals for the month. When I come to HABIT FOCUS on my AF2 list, I go to the app and check whether I've done these things today or not and if not, I will do them. My current set up is not to require completion of all 5 habits before checking it off my AF2 list. As a consequence, there is one habit in particular that I've let go. I may make a rule for myself to complete at least some time on each habit before checking it off AF2 and see if that helps or hurts.
What I have learned is that the more options I have in front of me at one time, the more overwhelmed I feel and the less I do. When I was listing projects, ideas, books to read, blog posts to write, countries to conquer ;-) on my AF1 list, the list kept growing and growing and I felt less and less in control. Now I feel okay even if I don't work the list much because I know the truly urgent tasks, including project tasks are right there on my short AF2 list that I see multiple times a day. I feel like I am finally realizing the benefits of even original AF that Mark intended: a list short enough to review and work multiple times a day.
The other benefit I have is more of a DIT time-to-process set-up. In other words, if I have an idea for a new blog post, I don't add it to my main AF2 list and start working on it right away. It gets added to my Blog Post Ideas ancillary list. As a result, it can simmer and I can determine if that's really a topic I want to devote time to. I am no longer sacrificing the important routine tasks for the more exciting creative tasks that I tend to get lost in.
Speaking of writing, how goes the novel writing?
20 July 2009 at 20:08 | Mel
-
Hi Mel,
I hear what you're saying, but I seemed to run into problems in the early days of AF with putting bigger projects on the list. I'd skip over those items time and again because I would see it as "RENOVATE LIBRARY" (hard) vs. "buy shelf supports for library shelves" (easy). I think I would have to do it with almost everything like you have done to get it to work. And you're electronic which makes that easier to do.
Besides, with AF1, I don't have that many options really - I just have one page of options with maybe only 5-10 things on that page most times. There's just 10-15 of those pages. And you put ideas and possibilities on the list where I don't put anything that I'm not 95% committed to absolutely doing in the next couple of weeks / month. eg. I have maximum ~ 2 books on the list to read at one time (and a full bookshelf of "to be read" in the future). That translates to routine, everyday items plus one ~ 50 hour project. That's it, that's all I can do.
With the important routine tasks, I figure if all I do is declutter, spend 15 minutes cleaning per day (often with the kids, so get done 3 times as much) using what's on my AF list or just focusing on the kitchen if I don't have the right mix of items on the list that day, do dishes and laundry daily (I am doing these as a morning habit along with lifting weights - which I also have limited to one body part per session to get into the groove again...), that's good enough.
With the writing, I am in the process of writing the scenes on index cards. I'm trying to figure out a way I can dump that onto my list to force me to do the writing. :-) If I don't pick something off the list then, I'll have to dismiss the whole page, there's no way to avoid it.
I've learned that I have to be quite specific in my writing of items to get stuff done so I have to use that m.o., but have a solid outline to make it work. eg. "Declutter - 15 minutes" doesn't work on the list. "Declutter box of kitchen junk in garage" does work. "Write 400 words on Chapter 2" doesn't work. "Write argument b/w X and Y over Z" does work. Weird.
20 July 2009 at 22:01 | Jacqueline
-
Jacqueline, I understand what you are saying and have experienced that issue as well. I broke tasks down a lot with AF1 to help me get things moving. It worked but produced a very large list. I
think my tasks are now SO broad that I don't feel the resistance anymore. In other words, one of the huge areas I was listing was organizing. I love to organize and every time I saw a closet, a cabinet, a computer file, you name it, "Organize X" went on my list. Well, I can't do all those organizing projects anytime soon and I never pre-screened them per a short time frame as you are doing. Now I have a list of 50 organizing projects I would like to do sometime. When I see the word Organize on my main list, I get kind of excited because I can go to the associated list and find something I really want to do. I am also dismissing the last project listed if I don't organize it the day I work the list. This works for me because I think I was spending way too much time organizing and way too little doing things that really matter to me. At my funeral, no one is going to ooh and aah over my alphabetized spice cabinet, right?
I'm glad you are figuring out a way of getting the book moving. Speaking of weight training, have you looked at Super Slow Weight Training? Apparently you do it less often than BFL (1-2 times per week) and it takes very little time as you lift and lower so slowly that you reach muscle failure within 5 reps. Sorry. OT, but had to ask. LOL My dh tried it and liked it.
20 July 2009 at 22:54 | Mel
-
Hey Mel, I have Fred Hahn's book "Slow Burn" and although I had always trained slowly, I started slowing it down even more (you don't need to buy as many weights b/c you can't lift as many pounds w/o shaking like a leaf!) I'm working out at home, so doing the one body part for ~ 8 minutes gives me my hour of training a week - works out perfectly!
I remember years ago doing Callanetics with my mom and now realize it probably hurt and was effective because you would go soooo slow. Just try doing some sissy squats going super slow with just body weight - it's freaky how well it works and is a good substitute when out camping / travelling and don't have any equipment.
21 July 2009 at 0:09 | Jacqueline
-
Hi Christine,
>>> Actually I was a bit disappointed - Wally World sounds much more fun! <<<
Yes, it ind of does sound like fun.
>>> I'm glad glad you're close to finding "your" system - I can see how AF2 would cause difficulties for your style of working. <<<
It is so odd. AF2 does really have some good things to offer.
>>> I am still reallying enjoying AF2 and it is working well - but is a lot more different to AF1 than you would think from first reading. <<<
Yeah, really odd. How much different could it be to work the list backward? But it really does have a completely different effect. In the end, I'm going to be combining AF1 and AF2 in some way. I think that treating whole list as one page opens the door to procrastination. It helped to be forced to work on at least one item on a page or be forced to dismiss it all. Without that, it is easy to "browse" the list looking for the easy stuff.
OTOH, that "inexorably moving line of doom" forces action on the oldest items ... at the expense of any logic about deleting the tasks except their position on the list. And working from the end does get the current things done before they start to grow fuzz ;-) Again, I think a combination (such as the one Mark proposed for a while) of the two would help get both the oldest and newest done.
>>> I suspect that our minds were pretty conditioned by AF1 which made us approach certain aspects differently to someone coming at it afresh. I am still actioning my "on notice" items at whatever time of day they stand out but do not feel that detracts in any way from the actioning of the remainder of the list - whether that changes when(if!) my list gets smaller remains to be seen but at present my number of open items continues to reduce daily - now down to 234. <<<
I can't wait to get home and get the list revamped with my new ideas. I really need to get going again.
21 July 2009 at 3:36 | Mike
-
Jackie, thanks for the book tip. I do NOT understand why I am always last to the party. LOL Hahn has a book for kids which I'm really excited about. I have 5 boys and a fitness nut for a dh. ;-)
21 July 2009 at 5:40 | Mel
-
Hi Mike
"And working from the end does get the current things done before they start to grow fuzz ;-) "
ROTFL ROTFL ROTFL What a GREAT visual!
learning as I go
21 July 2009 at 9:10 | learning as I go
-
p.s.
It just reminded me of Christine B. talking about her green coffee! ROTFL! Mike.....you were so correct when you mentioned how clever this group is..........FUZZY chores, GREEN coffee.........ROTFL ROTFL ROTFL Sounds like a frat house!
learning as I go
21 July 2009 at 9:15 | learning as I go
-
Yesterday I tried keeping an on-notice task in mind when I went through the list. It did seem to help: got right through the list a couple of times, which hasn't happened for a while.
So, does my fencing kit want to be washed more than the printer wants it's ink ordered? Dunno: what about checking the PI9 download, then?...
21 July 2009 at 9:31 | Will
-
Good Morning Learning,
Yeah, for some reason light banter works here. Some groups are so grim that they'd not even know you were joking around. I'd get questions about the type of fuzz, what it looked like, requests for pictures to be uploaded, the whole nine yards.
21 July 2009 at 11:56 | Mike
-
Mornin' Mike!
ROTFL! So true! Some of those GTD'ers would spend pages of posts debating what pen to use! (...with the assumption that it was a crucial lynchpin for the system to work more smoothly or,worse.......more "properly" ! ! ! ! ROTFL! ! ! You hit the nail on the head with this one! Although........pssssst..........come closer so that I can whisper.......there have been similar type discussions here on other posts...........hell, even a few in this monolith post...........ROTFL!!!!!
learning as I go
21 July 2009 at 12:09 | learning as I go
-
Mornin' Will
"So, does my fencing kit want to be washed more than the printer wants it's ink ordered? Dunno: what about checking the PI9 download, then?... "
ROTFL ROTFL ROTFL So true! When I find myself getting caught up in that loop, I simply say to myself........."Damn it, do any damn thing just to get out of this stupud, self-induced stalemate!" When I find myself doing this to myself, I feel like a two month old kitten chasing after her own tail! ROTFL
learning as I go
21 July 2009 at 12:15 | learning as I go
-
Learning,
LOL ;-) Yeah. I remember those long epics ... which pen, which nib on which pen, which ink in which pen using which nib, which paper takes which ink best when used with which nib in which pen. Heeeeeeeeeeeeelllllllllllllllllllllllpppppppppppppppppp.
ROTF ;-) As if I really need to see "Buy Tomatoes" on my shopping list 100 years from now, in full contrast, in emerald green ink, with no bleeding through the paper, and the paper pristine white because it is acid free). I mean ... G*E*T A G*R*I*P. ;-) Can you see the historians digging up the list and wondering why such effort was taken to provide such a permanent record? "Was there some kind of "tomato cult" in that century? And what robes did these tomato cult high priests wear? What were the sacrificial rituals?" LOL ;-)
21 July 2009 at 12:53 | Mike
-
Hi Mike
Worse...........they'll discover the forums and force the new guy to plow through them! ROTFL!
learning as I go
21 July 2009 at 14:00 | learning as I go
-
psssssttttt.....Mike......confession: I'm guilty as charged in a similar vein.... Sometimes I actually find myself reluctant to toss a page...then I kick my own butt...........toss it, airhead. Unless it it belongs in the "proof" binder (read: cover my arse in case I'm threatened or accused of not paying.....)
GEEEESSSSHHHH....That list is crap that I'm going to do again and most of it is age sensative......What do I care if I washed the reds loads Tuesday and vacuumed the dog on Wednesday.......I'll be doing it again anyway! ROTFL! Sometimes I need to get over myself......and let myself exist with a few holes in my memory......at least with the recurring stuff! ROTFL!
learning as I go
21 July 2009 at 14:07 | learning as I go
-
Learning,
That is pretty much how it goes. I remember once I fussed because I had tossed a sheet with a phone number on it. I realized that if I REALLY wanted the number, I could probably dig it out of the phone company documents I had on file. And if it was a number 30 years old, who cares ... how many people still have the same phone number 30 years later. And for those who do, there are lots of other tracks they've left by which I could find them. If not ... so what?
One thing I have kept is the logs I used to keep at work when covering my ass big time. Once in a long while I'll want to remember the name of the plumber I used to replace the water heater or something. But eventually, they will also find their way to the community shred. ;-) I can always find another plumber.
21 July 2009 at 14:18 | Mike
-
Mike...
BAD example if he was a good (and reasonably honest) plumber! LOL!
learning as I go
21 July 2009 at 14:28 | learning as I go
-
Learning:
<< You mean like a root cellar.or wine cellar...50 or so degrees Fahrenheit? >>
Top-fermented beer (ale) is kept in a wooden barrel in a cellar underneath the bar and is drawn up by a hand-pump. The cellar is quite a bit cooler than the bar, yes, rather like a wine cellar would be.
What no British real ale drinker would countenance is any artificial cooling between the cellar and the pump. That should be reserved for bottom-fermented beers like <shudder> lager </shudder>
21 July 2009 at 15:21 | Mark Forster
-
Hi Mark
<shudder> lager </shudder>
ROTFL ROTFL ROTFL
My own purpose for beer is too cook with it......brand depends on what I'm going to cook!
<shudder> lager </shudder>
ROTFL ROTFL ROTFL
learning as I go
21 July 2009 at 15:26 | learning as I go
-
Ink ordered, fencing kit drying, PI9 set up, even did a bit of work... huzzah!
21 July 2009 at 15:26 | Will
-
p.s.
My dad used to called it marketed piss! ROTFL
learning as I go
21 July 2009 at 15:28 | learning as I go
-
Hi Mike
I'm really interested in knowing a bit more about the particular type of fuzz you are referring to .... what does it look like - could you upload picture to Flickr? :-)
Hi learning
You vaccuum your dog!!???
21 July 2009 at 17:51 | Christine B
-
Hi Christine
Yup....She's a German Shedder.....errrrrr.....German Shepherd!!!! I vacuum both her and my floors 3 to 4 times a week. I usually vacuum her out on the deck because I have to use a shedding rake and even the vacuum doesn't catch all of her fine, undercoat hairs. Otherwise, I'd be living "fuzzy" as Mike puts it! LOL! (Why, I spend more time on her grooming than I do on my own! Each session is usually about 30 minutes)
learning as I go
21 July 2009 at 18:50 | learning as I go
-
Hi learning
I love the picture that conjures up!! She sounds great :-)
21 July 2009 at 19:01 | Christine B
-
Hi Christine
She sure is a wonderful dog......She's living on borrowed time. 13 years old!!!!! She's never messed in the house, gone up on furniture, or stolen food. I can leave a steak on the coffee table or bags of raw protein in the car......She never breaks the rules. She leans into me so that I can get up leaning into her mighty shoulders. When I can hardly walk, she slows down her pace. The only trouble is that when I'm in high pain or medicated, she gets hyper alert. She'll stand horizonally in my path to make me stop lest I become too vulnerable because another human being is approaching! LOL! She guards me like I'm the President! ROTFL! She's quite genial when she deems that I'm not in any present danger! LOL! I have no idea what she uses to guage her assumption that I'm in too much pain or too medicated to be safe around strangers! ROTFL I almost wish that we both die on the same breath. I don't know what I'll do when she passes......
learning as I go
21 July 2009 at 19:38 | learning as I go
-
Hi learning
She sounds amazing - isn't it incredible the way animals develop their senses of how we are? I find it amazing that people cannot recognise that a pet becomes a part of the family as much as anyone else and how traumatic a loss is. I do hope you will have many many more happy years together ........
21 July 2009 at 19:57 | Christine B
-
Jacqueline,
If you liked Fred Hahn's book, I strongly suggest you buy the book titled "Body By Science" by McGuff and Little.
McGuff is an MD. I know that Eades is an MD and cowrote Hahn's book. But McGuff has devoted his life to this stuff. I felt that for Eades it was more of a drive-by journalism kind of assignment.
http://www.bodybyscience.net/home.html/ 21 July 2009 at 20:17 | moises
-
Hi Christine,
<Snarrrrrrl> LOL ;-)
21 July 2009 at 22:42 | Mike
-
Learning,
I know I'm still having a hard time adjusting to the loss of Thelma. All I can suggest is that you get another puppy now, so the transition will be easier. Also, the puppy will have a role model to help it learn the rules. Probably get the same breed. Those are very good and trustworthy dogs. If I were to get a dog, it would probably be an Australian Sheep dog. Those herding dogs are particularly easy to train and protective, so far as I know.
I had a friend who had an English Sheep dog and that thing was a stitch. Every where I went it would block my way and try to herd me. How funny. Very friendly and docile.
21 July 2009 at 22:52 | Mike
-
Hi moises,
Yes, I totally agree with his philosophy! I read Mike Mentzer's columns, Dorian Yates' training routines, etc. etc. but couldn't seem to make myself believe that it was possible to make significant strength gains with a small investment in time. (Cuz that's not what Arnold and everyone else did!)
I used to work out about 15 hours a week - step aerobics, jogging and weights - and ate pretty high carb. I would train hard enough that I would have difficulty driving my manual clutch, non-power steering car home from the gym, so I wasn't skimping in the intensity. I was in very good shape, but I wonder if I hadn't overexercised and under-proteined myself how much better off I would have been. I remember after a couple of months my BF% just wouldn't go down, which made no sense to me at all given that I was doing everything "right." Sure...
The only thing that I'm doing differently than what he says below is working one body part a day for about 8 minutes of active lifting (not counting rests) and that I directly work my arms as well (because I enjoy it). :-) I'm not going full-out yet because I'm getting back into it and have hurt both my back and my rotator cuff in the past pushing myself past a certain point - the joints need to catch up to the muscle strength for me. Having said that, I hurt them both on machines, not with free weights, so staying away from the machines and their possible unnatural range of motion may solve that problem. I don't want to get sidelined right in the beginning though.
"So to any woman out there who is fed up with trying the same thing over and over, I offer this suggestion, instead of getting back on the treadmill “one more time,” try this: Alter your diet so that you eat no grain-based carbohydrate: no flour, no sugar, no bread, no pasta, and no high fructose corn syrup. Then go to the gym and perform a workout of leg press, pulldown, chest press, row and overhead press. Lift slowly and smoothly but with as much effort as possible. Go to complete fatigue, or as close to it as you can tolerate. Work out once, or at most, twice a week. Make sure your workouts last no longer than 20 minutes. Then sit back and watch what happens. "
21 July 2009 at 23:10 | Jacqueline
-
Hi Mike
<sigh> - so I guess no picture then ........ :-(
21 July 2009 at 23:42 | Christine B
-
Moises, I had already gathered that the Body by Science book was the one to get from the Amazon reviews. Haven't started it yet, but I finished Hahn's book for kids. It's superb! As a homeschooler with five active boys, it's perfect for us. Actually, my dd loves to workout, too.
Jacqueline, you are so right about the diet. I made a lot of progress doing BFL but I would say most of it was in muscle gain. I started doing Feed the Muscle, Burn the Fat. Venuto discusses those who are "carb sensitive" there, but being completely addicted to fruit, I decided that wasn't me. :-) I've been on a no-grain diet for health reasons for 7.5 years. Since getting off the fruit, honey, and higher carb veggies several weeks ago, my body fat is the lowest it's ever been. The fringe benefit is that I'm healthier. What is amazing to me is that I kept jacking up the aerobics and cutting calories while leaving in the carbs. No matter how hard I worked, my weight and body fat stayed the same. Within a week and a half of cutting out fructose, I had lost 10 pounds.
Since discovering this key, I have also learned that high fructose intake is responsible for the IBS symptoms that so many suffer from. In fact, a low carb diet treats Crohn's disease, MS, and seizures amongst others.
Your practice of working just one body part is interesting. Hadn't thought of that. I would think you could just as easily do a lower/upper body split if you cared to work out more. My dh is like you. He is suspicious of working out too little. He's the type that does hundreds and hundreds of crunches. That just seems silly to me. lol I know Fred Hahn isn't a fan of aerobic exercise, but I have found that doing Jillian Michael's 30 Day Shred and other short, high-intensity aerobics combined with light weights and high repetitions has dramatically improved my endurance and overall fitness. There has to be a balance in there somewhere. :-)
I'm now returning you to your regularly scheduled topical discussion. ;-)
22 July 2009 at 2:48 | Mel
-
Mel, this IS about time management - how to get the most out of your exercise by putting in the least amount of time!! Funny, I have one of Jillian Michaels' DVD's on my AF list to find - and 2 more coming in the mail. I like doing a high intensity aerobic type of routine once or twice a week.
22 July 2009 at 3:17 | Jacqueline
-
Mel,.-)
I can't say enough good things about a low carb diet. It is not for everyone, perhaps, but it is really for me. I discovered this when Atkins was the craze. I was skeptical but when Ornish outright attacked Atkins, even lying about what Atkins really was (he and others called it the "high fat" diet ... LOL ;-) I decided there must be something to it. Leave it to my contrarian streak to get me to do things ;-)
So when this last visit to the doctor woke me up to serious problems on the horizon if I did not shed some pounds, get my blood pressure and chlorrestoral down, and exercise up ... I went strictly no carb. WoooHooo, I can't describe the energy boost I experienced ... and the pounds just drop off.
Of course, what is largely missing from Atkins (at least as the dreamers read it ;-) is that one must STILL reduce calorie intake and increase exercise. I mean, one can't simply gorge because there are no carbs in it ;-)
Anyway, as I tell my wife, tell me I have to diet by eating fillet mignon and I'm right on board with it ;-)
BTW, one thing I think that makes this work well, for me at least, is its simplicity. It is instantly obvious what one can and can not eat. Just no carbs!!! (Well, it is just slightly more complex than that but if you reduced it to that simple rule you'd be 99% right.) The people I've seen have trouble with it are those who try to game the system. If you go to the support groups people are exchanging recipes for no carb chocolate pot pie and other such nonsense. That is just masochism and accounts for their failure, I believe.
22 July 2009 at 9:53 | Mike
-
Since this discussion is no longer even remotely connected with the original subject I'm going to close it now as it's becoming too long to be manageable.
You're welcome to continute the discussion on a new thread.
22 July 2009 at 11:34 | Mark Forster