-
Hi Mark,
Pleae review the post on this website. I would love to hear your assessment of this. There are many out there that believe that one should always schedule your most important tasks directly on your calendar instead of on a list. What do you think?
http://www.evolvingexcellence.com/blog/2008/01/why-a-to-do-lis.htmlThanks,
-David
17 October 2008 at 16:00 | David Drake
-
David:
It's an interesting article but Dan doesn't really give quite enough information to be able to judge how his method would actually work. As far as I can tell he is advocating some form of full scheduling. In other words you don't just write:
Email
Voicemail
Write Report
Lunch
You write:
0900 Email
0930 Voicemail
0940 Write report
1230 Lunch
There's nothing basicallywrong with this method of scheduling, as long as one remembers that one always runs behind schedule, and leaves plenty of time for interruptions. However many people's experience is that they start getting further and further behind and end up spending more time revising the schedule than doing the work.
Bear in mind that the Task Diary in DIT is actually a calendar and therefore is achieving much of what he is talking about without scheduling exact times.
17 October 2008 at 17:34 | Mark Forster
-
I tried this at one point but it was hard to follow with interruptions. I now use a technique which is slightly less structured. I break the day into sections in a spiral notebook.
Before work
Morning
Lunch
After lunch
Evening
Three sections are my time, Before Work, Lunch and Evening and I put my personal tasks there, two sections are my work and I put work tasks there. I explain it in my ebook The Simple Guide to Time Management. I hope Mark does not mind me mentioning it. It is free so it is not really competition.
Thanks
Gerry
http://simpletimemanagement.blogspot.com/ 18 October 2008 at 4:18 | Gerry
-
Hi Gerry
I tried to download your ebook but with no success. Having followed all instructions on the emails I received all I ended up with was a .php file that was unrecognised by any of the programs on my pc. No .pdf in sight!!
Any advice?
18 October 2008 at 16:13 | Jane
-
Gerry:
I'm a big believer in competition being good for the competitors... so no problem with your link!
18 October 2008 at 18:53 | Mark Forster
-
I changed the way it works, there is a link you can click on which downloads a folder. When you click on the folder it is in there in pdf form. Please leave a comment if you can't access it.
Thanks
19 October 2008 at 2:06 | Gerry
-
Gerry, I downloaded your ebook and found it very interesting.
In some way, it reminds me of 'tabbed Moleskine' GTD 'hacks' or the 'superbook' discussion we had in this forum:
http://www.markforster.net/forum/post/480192 One trick to improve it (which, IIRC, was also mentioned in the 'superbook' thread) might be to write the 'Results', 'Owed Me' and 'Action Items' sections (in that order) from front to back while writing the notes pages starting from the last page inwards. You'll still waste space when the first of the sections runs out of pages and you have to switch to a new notebook, but not as much as if you had four fixed sections.
Your method also suffers from a problem we discussed here: How to schedule tasks or reminders in the future.
Another question: Where can one find the other ebook, 'Desired Outcomes Implementation Technology'? It's mentioned in the SGTM ebook, but I can't find it on your site.
Sorry for hijacking the thread.
19 October 2008 at 13:22 | Alex W.
-
If I right click on the link and download it from the pop-up menu I get a .php file which nothing on my computer will open.
If I left click on the link a .zip file opens which I can then download and it unzips to reveal a .pdf file.
So I've finally got the document, but it's not easy to do!
19 October 2008 at 15:38 | Mark Forster
-
I found that it worked very easily when I left clicked on the link then instead of clicking on save I clicked on open. Up came a window called sgtm.zip with a single file in it called sgtm.pdf when I clicked on the pdf it opened then I saved it to an apprporiate folder on my pc. I went back and tried clicking save instead of open and it looked like that would have been more involved but clicking open first then saving once I'd opened the pdf itself was very simple and straightforward.
Hope this helps...
19 October 2008 at 18:13 | Hannah
-
I don't want to hijack Mark's forum. So Mark if you want to delete this no problem.
I agree Alex the ability to schedule task in the future is a weak point and one I struggled with. Your suggestion is a fine one. The task diary obviously is a superior way to schedule forward.
As far as the computer problems, I am not a technical guy, so I am glad people are getting the file.
The next book Desired Outcomes Implementation Technology is in draft stages. I have been writing it on plane trips and in my spare time. I am thinking I may have a small charge for it.
Thanks
19 October 2008 at 22:09 | Gerry
-
(Let's forget the thread hijacking for the moment.)
Wrt the original post: My impression ist that it's yet another "Schedule your life to death" scheme. I have to say that I'm not really impressed by the author's thinking, esp. after I had a look at the linked “live in your calendar” post.
Gerry's idea to structure your day's tasks into personal/work tasks on one side and before/after lunch on the other looks interesting to me.
It's like subdividing the daily perspective of the DIT principles (or the Task Diary) into a 2x2 matrix (more precisely, it's a linear time scale with 5 distinct periods, but for modeling, that won't matter).
Mark,
what do you think of that system?
I write this from the perspective of someone who is neither self-employed nor a CEO type of person, and - unfortunately - most time management system seem to be geared towards those two groups.
I must say that I keep having a hard time to adapt the DIT principles to my real world, where I have little control over my schedule, interruptions, or the expectations of immediate reactions. (Yes, I wanted to make this the subject of a new forum post, but ironically I don't get around to it.)
20 October 2008 at 1:17 | Alex W.
-
Alex:
What do I think of that system?
I have to confess that I have never seen any need for any of these complications.
With DIT there is no need to plan your day, no need to prioritise, no need to time anything. You just have a list of stuff to do and get on with doing it. If you have meetings and interruptions, then you just carry on with the list once the meeting or interruption is over.
DIT also allows you to make sure that your work is in balance, but insisting that one day's incoming work must equal one day's outgoing work on average.
So why all the complication?
I just write down everything that comes in during the day for tomorrow and then do it tomorrow.
If it really has to be done today, then I do it today.
If I don't get through the list tomorrow then I carry it forward, but with the proviso that I must catch up within 4 days or so.
If I can't catch up then I must look at why I can't and do something about it.
What's so difficult about that?
20 October 2008 at 11:02 | Mark Forster
-
I tend to agree with what you are saying here Mark. In fact I sometimes wonder if constantly fiddling with time management systems is another sophisticated way of procrastination (speaking from personal experience). Of course it is good to experiment and try to improve things if they are not working for you, but in my view a time management system that is more complicated to run just tends to slow productivity down. Not that I mean to critiicize any body else's ideas, particularly as I have not reviewed them for myself on this occasion.
20 October 2008 at 13:52 | Leon
-
I've always worked on the principle that if something doesn't work then I should find ways of simplifying it.
Making anything more complicated is usually a "work around".
20 October 2008 at 13:57 | Mark Forster
-
I tend to agree with Mark. Keep it simple!
When I was working in an office environment when answering the phone and doing others' bidding was the norm, I had a simple system based around a single reporter's notebook. I would write a 'to do' list and would just keep it running - crossing out tasks as they were completed. Sometimes, to stop having to look back too many pages, I would rewrite a task later on to keep tasks bunched together over fewer pages. This meant I could work off my to do list, be interrupted and then just come back to where I'd left off. Some days I got interrupted a lot, others hardly at all. I would review things now and again (depending on how much had built up) and if some tasks were continually being left undone I would either do them, try to persuade someone else to do them (delegate/bribe), or delete them if by neglect they had become obsolete. It's amazing how even in a customer support situation like I was in, you can avoid the need to do some tasks altogether. Obviously I was careful only to do this with tasks that seemed unnecessary in the first place - if I was chased on a particular task then it would get done sooner.
With DIT then, a similar system would work but using the task diary as the default list. I would work from the list of tasks in the task diary, get interrupted, then continue on my list of tasks for that day. All the other guidelines of DIT (checking incoming work for its level of urgency, etc. and entering reminders for the future for delegated tasks, etc.) would still apply. I think this is where figuring out the basic premises of a time management system then adapting it for your own environment is so useful. No time management system is bespoke and, like a software package I used to do the support for, each person has to tweak the system to make it work for them. But, providing you still follow the basic principles then the philosophy behind the system should remain pretty much intact - which is presumably what appealed in the first place.
20 October 2008 at 14:05 | Hannah
-
Oh, one more thing.
In say a customer support role, or any other role that involves constant interruption from the phone or other people, then many of the tasks that are 'incoming' work are treated as same day immediate. That's just the nature of the beast. It is only other tasks that are not ones that you would instantly react to that would end up in the task diary (in my opinion - I know Mark says to write every task down but I would think that answering the phone is an exception since in a support role you wouldn't want to be deciding 'yes, this is same day immediate' and entering it into the task diary prior to every call). However, any tasks resulting from that call would need to be assessed as per standard DIT to avoid doing things immediately just out of habit.
20 October 2008 at 14:15 | Hannah
-
One more thing! Last for now honest...
I think the main criteria for any time management system is does it help you get done what you want to get done or does it hinder you. If the former, great - go ahead and use it; if the latter - chuck it out and get a new system!
20 October 2008 at 14:19 | Hannah
-
Hannah:
In DIT "same day" and "immediate" are not the same thing. "Immediate" is defined as being so urgent that you drop everything else in order to deal with it.
The example you give of answering the telephone is an example of an "immediate" action. You wouldn't normally write an immediate action down in your Task Diary because you would be too busy doing it.
However any action coming out of the phone call would not be "immediate" (unless it was an emergency). It would either be "same day or "everything else". In that case you would write it down and be forced to chose between writing it on today's page or tomorrow's).
20 October 2008 at 15:52 | Mark Forster
-
It almost looks like I hit a nerve here (maybe I shouldn't have used words like 'matrix' and 'modeling').
What I meant was that I liked:
(a) The thought of separating work and personal actions. DIT is basically about work (only), but with the examples coming from the world of a self-employed person, the lines tend to be blurry, which confuses me a little - GTD has a similar tendency to mix work and private life. To be fair, the basic metaphor of the repair shop is a good, work-centric one and I might be messing things up with some stuff from GED, not DIT.
(b) The before/after lunch time separator for work. This enables you to use a buffer of 1/2 a day instead of a day. This could be much more in line with the nature of *my* work, where I can rarely let open tasks linger for a whole day, due to a very tight schedule (I probably should have written my planned post, that would have made it much clearer). I'm not into advocating scheduling your tasks (though it is imposed on me quite a lot, unfortunately). I wouldn't really call this 'complicating' things.
20 October 2008 at 21:26 | Alex W.
-
My intent in separating the day into the sections was to solve the problem some of us find ourselves in whom are not self employed. It allows you a place to put the things you need and want to do into time you control. It is almost akin to the “unschedule” idea. By seeing that you have time for yourself and what you want to accomplish in life, you do not feel so overwhelmed by your responsibilities at work. If was self employed and “owned” my whole day, I would not need it.
My attempt at designing the system was to be as simple as possible while adding a few ideas that I thought were worthwhile enhancements. Part of the design is due to my personal situation, i.e. employed, supervising others, with lots of projects and an ok memory. So these features are the minimum I need. Other may need less.
21 October 2008 at 4:54 | Gerry
-
Alex:
Well, you did ask me what I thought of the systems so I told you!
On the employment/personal divide, my advice has always been to have a separate Will Do list for each location. It really doesn't matter whether a task is personal or employment related - it's WHERE you do it that counts (I think GED says the same).
However one should I think distinguish between personal chores (paying the bills, mowing the lawn, getting the car repaired) and leisure activities (writing to friends, watching a DVD). I think leisure activities should only be minimally scheduled - they are supposed to be relaxing after all!
21 October 2008 at 14:05 | Mark Forster
-
Gerry:
My intent wasn't to criticise you methods so much as to extol the benefits of DIT's ultra-simple approach. I think the remarks I made about location in my previous answer to Alex apply to what you say as well.
It's interesting what you say about self-employed people "owning" the whole day. Actually that's what people tend to think *before* they become self-employed. When they do become self employed, it comes as a rude shock to find that they spend the whole day at the beck and call of clients and have no boundaries to mark the beginning and end of the working day in the way which people who travel to work have.
Of course there are many advantages in being self-employed or working from home, but they tend not to be the ones that first spring to mind.
And finally, I've been intending to write my blog posting about "Keep It Complicated, Stupid" for ages. It's not directly related to this discussion.
21 October 2008 at 14:15 | Mark Forster
-
Mark,
sorry, I really don't want to introduce any unpleasentness here.
The employment/personal divide isn't a huge problem (even though from my experience, the same planning horizon - i.e. daily vs. weekly - often doesnt seem to fit both well at the same time). IMO it doesn't really matter whether you use 'contexts' (the GTD criteria) or a simple 'work'/'personal' divide (I usually find this more practical than over-atomized 'contexts') or a time-based divide (as in Gerry's example) to separate work from your personal tasks (I didn't mean leisure activities). But the time-based separation seems to play nicely with the core DIT concept of 'limits'.
What about using a half-day buffer instead of a whole-day one?
22 October 2008 at 2:19 | Alex W.
-
Mark,
I do not view anything you said as critical. I have successfully used DIT after GTD and had success with it. To me employed means a more limited ability to control your agenda.
I wrote my little ebook to try to put my thoughts out there for a system that would incorporate some of DIT GTD and my own thoughts on time management. I have a full time job in another field and so I thought I would just give it away to see if some people connected with it. Thanks for the forum to discuss it.
Gerry
22 October 2008 at 3:04 | Gerry
-
Alex:
I don't see any problem with the use of a half-day buffer if circumstances warrant it. Another alternative I once advised to someone in unusual circumstances was to keep a one-day buffer but to start the day at 12 noon instead of 12 midnight.
22 October 2008 at 12:05 | Mark Forster
-
Mark,
I'm the author of the original post "Why a to-do list doesn't work" (from the Evolving Excellence blog), and have very much enjoyed following this discussion. Your concept of the closed list is intriguing: I like the simplicity of the system and the way it doesn't require the user to constantly shift around the inevitable broken appointments for his own work. There's real elegance in that simplicity.
As you suggest in your comments, I do advocate leaving plenty of time for interruptions: scheduling one's day completely full is a recipe for certain failure and frustration.
That said, I think there are three real benefits from scheduling time in the calendar. First, blocking out the time in the calendar prevents other people from scheduling you for other activities. (Nature abhors a vacuum -- and an empty calendar.) Second, using the calendar forces you to really consider how long an activity will take. Finally, just as making a commitment to doing something on a specific *day* helps ensure that it will get done, choosing a specific *time* is similarly powerful in promoting action.
Thank you for the thought-provoking ideas. I look forward to following your blog in the future.
24 October 2008 at 16:07 | Dan Markovitz
-
Thanks, Dan, and welcome to the discussion.
I agree with everything that you say. There's nothing wrong with scheduling if one takes the necessary precautions and is disciplined about it.
My own methods in Do It Tomorrow produce the same benefits but in different ways. That doesn't mean that one system is better than the other - just different!
28 October 2008 at 10:01 | Mark Forster
-
Hello,
The forum is very informative. Feel great to be a part of the community.
Wanted to share a website which might be very use full for some of the people here.
I was doing some research on my mortgage refinance issue when I came across this website.
It lists some 21 mortgage calculators that I did not see anywhere on the internet so I was compelled to
share it. The coolest thing was that it also gives you the findings in plain English as well so you can
understand the results of your findings easily. The website can be accessed here. <a href=
http://1mortgagecalculator.info>Mortgage Calculators</a>
Thanks
2 March 2009 at 7:07 | Extegetor