-
I've noticed a significant difference between the no-lists and the catch-all systems.
In the most distilled no-list systems, items appear on the list by being done, and therefore we have a list of things we are currently working on.
In a catch-all system, the list is really two sets of items - "tasks" which we are actually working on, and "ideas" for things we will do in the future. For example, The Simplest Time Management Method makes the distinction clear. Above the line, we find tasks, below the line we find ideas. Simple Scanning and many of the other long list systems intersperse these two categories, and Mark has offered various practices to help us determine a) how to move an idea into the task category, and b) how to determine which ideas are not ready to become tasks.
I wonder what folks think about the importance of drawing this distinction. I'm currently using Simple Scanning, and feel like sometimes I would be better served by having separate lists for "I'm actively pursuing this and know it fits into my schedule" and "These would be nice to get around to once I have the resources."
16 January 2018 at 22:15 | Voluntas
-
Perhaps you could create an ongoing project called "Start new projects" with its own separate list of actions, such as "Start Project X" and "Start Project Y." On your Simple Scanning list, you could enter this project name ("Start new projects"), and whenever it stood out, you could consult its own list in the usual way that we do for multi-step projects or multi-item ongoing tasks such as "Email." If you are feeling adventurous, you might even name this new creation "The Someday/Maybe Project."
17 January 2018 at 3:33 | Bernie
-
Bernie:
<<feel like sometimes I would be better served by having separate lists>>
I think if the number of tasks you have is very large (in the 100's), then separate lists would be easier to manage. That is certainly the case with me. I find it useful to do similar tasks in bulk for a few hours at a time. Separate lists of each general category helps gather them all together.
If the number of tasks are relatively small, then I imagine a catch all list would work fine.
17 January 2018 at 13:08 | MrBacklog
-
Bernie:
I understand the approach you've suggested. However, my concern with Simple Scanning after nearly a month of consistent use is that frequently scanning items which I'm not ready to do now diverts attention away from the items which are more relevant. I know that Mark would encourage me to add a "Weed list" entry, but I would prefer that the system itself do this job. After all, we don't write "Scan list" before we start work for the day. Even looking at the single "Start new projects" item could have a negative effect if there's simply no way for me to start a new project now.
SuperFocus was pretty good at tracking WIP, but too strict about which items got worked on, and when. The June 7 system seems like a good starting place for me, but I'm still thinking through some ideas about using the "done" items from today as a starting place for tomorrow's work. I'm also leaning toward using dismissal with June 7, rather than deletion.
Aside:
I may have done a poor job titling this thread, and writing my initial post. What I'm primarily concerned with lately is the effect of a long list on my _attention_, with the long term goal of achieving more focus on the items I'm actively involved in, and a better understanding of what priorities I've set for myself, either explicitly or implicitly.
--V
17 January 2018 at 18:19 | Voluntas
-
MrB:
I think you may have misunderstood my ideas. You've written about using separate lists to keep one project or area of concern separate from others. What I'm thinking about is separating items based on my level of involvement. I'm chasing after having a small list of items that I'm actually working on at the moment, and a longer list of things that I plan to do eventually, but don't need my attention right now.
--V
17 January 2018 at 18:22 | Voluntas
-
Voluntas:
How about the recent(ish) real autofocus system, as that contains a deferral element that should keep the list more focussed?
What is the June 7 system as I can't seem to see that? Please point me in the right direction...
17 January 2018 at 19:46 | MrBacklog
-
17 January 2018 at 23:48 | nuntym
-
18 January 2018 at 0:11 | Seraphim
-
My system of a few years back had a distinctive way of handling this:
Take a notebook and build up a long list with the rule that new tasks are entered only on the left pages, and tasks you're working on are entered only on the right pages. When one of these pages is filled, close off both pages and start the next two pages.
As with my current system (see Doting on My List), I would simple-scan the entire list, but circle about the last page (right side only). The effect was what you talked about: the left pages are ideas, and the right pages are active tasks.
That said, I find the my current process more satisfying without this division. It has the switch to alternate between simple scanning and working active tasks (and new tasks).
18 January 2018 at 2:31 | Alan Baljeu
-
Thanks all for responses! I've addressed y'all individually below, but I'd also like to say that your input has helped me sort out a (non-public) first draft of my new system. I'll report back in a few days to tell you about successes and failures.
MrB:
I tried RAF when Mark first published it. At the moment, I can't recall why I grew dissatisfied, but I thank you for reminding me of it. Also, nuntym provided the correct link to June 7. My new system will incorporate a daily cut-off and something similar to DDD.
nuntym:
I hestitate to try another catch-all list, because of the potential costs to my attention. Even though the FV variants only require that one scan below the last dotted item, the older items are still there, and a wandering eye might glance at one and become distracted. (BTW: when Mark first published the original FV, I spent some time working it and found I was most successful when I limited myself to two-item chains, which is somewhat similar to FFVP, i.e. "I have to eventually address the first list item, but first I'm going to find an item I want to do NOW")
Seraphim:
Your systems are clearly well-developed, and I applaud you for your work. Personally, I've had more success with Standing Out. I do think, though, that your addition of methods for strategic and clarifying thinking will find their way into the system I eventually create, although these processes might very well happen "away from" the list.
Alan:
I had trouble understanding the benefits of Doting when I first read your post. I made another attempt today and it became more clear. It's actually much closer to what I want than I first thought. My rules will be a bit more strict than yours, but I will aspire toward the same goal of grouping together as many started-but-not-finished/recurring items as possible.
--V
18 January 2018 at 20:41 | Voluntas
-
Voluntas: Looking forward to details of your new system!
Following on from your idea of separate lists - I wondered if 3 lists would work?
One for do it now tasks, one for tasks you need to do this week and one for do it in 3 weeks. Seems a simple way of prioritising what to focus on first.
I suppose that is a similar principle as dotting or standing out. You are just putting those in the "do it now" tasks list in the first place. They then get done sooner.
If all the lists are kept clear within the designated timescales, then happy days!
I will give this a go for a while and see how it goes. I can't see any disadvantages at the moment.
19 January 2018 at 11:13 | MrBacklog
-
MrB:
Sounds similar to DWM, which I have read about, but never implemented. One of the questions I'm addressing with the new system is "If you've got something that can't go on the list because you're not working on it now, WHERE DOES IT GO?" Hint: I'm not putting it on another list. Not for now, anyway.
I remembered why RAF didn't stick with me: If I deferred an item once, too often I found it getting deferred over and over into oblivion. I didn't want to delete it, because it still needed to be done, but I couldn't manage to get it off the list by doing it. This negatively impacted my attention in much the same way as a catch-all.
Yesterday with the new system was successful enough, and I'll return to my list in a couple of hours for more testing. (Writing this between appointments at work where I don't use a list because our scheduling and record-keeping systems make it irrelevant.) There's a mechanic that only starts kicking in at the end of the second day which I'm excited to encounter face-to-face. Update soon!
--V
19 January 2018 at 18:41 | Voluntas
-
V:
<< If I deferred an item once, too often I found it getting deferred over and over into oblivion>>
Indeed! I find that the strangest thing. The more something is deferred or prioritised, then a mental block can ensue.
I'm wondering if a system can help eliminate that, or is it something that has to come from within the user? Maybe no system can cope with someone with a bad procrastination problem!
I have had a bit of a problem with that in the past and found the only thing to solve it was to more or less do everything I can on the task the first time I see it. But that does lead to issues when too many urgent things come in and I need to prioritise some tasks. Since then I have been prioritising better and forcing myself to eliminate procrastination completely. If has been really really difficult!
Anyway, looking forward to your new system!
20 January 2018 at 10:07 | MrBacklog
-
"Don’t try to get things done. Do try to increase the probability that they will get done." Khatzumoto.
20 January 2018 at 15:36 | Mark Forster
-
"Do or do not, there is no try" -Yoda
But in all seriousness, that's a meaningful contribution, Mark. The system I'm working on will hopefully increase the probability that I pay close attention to my work, to the activities of my mind, and to my environment.
--V
20 January 2018 at 21:48 | Voluntas
-
Voluntas:
<< "Do or do not, there is no try" -Yoda
I know it's important to take our life lessons from fictional characters in movies, but the "try" Yoda is talking about is quite different from the "try" that Khatzumoto is talking about.
Compare:
"I will try not to eat any more chocolate cake this week"
"I will try to fit you in for your next session this weekend"
21 January 2018 at 20:48 | Mark Forster
-
MrBacklog:
<< The more something is deferred or prioritised, then a mental block can ensue.
<< I'm wondering if a system can help eliminate that, or is it something that has to come from within the user? Maybe no system can cope with someone with a bad procrastination problem! >>
It's the idea of there being a mental block that's coming from within the user. There is no mental block - you've just persuaded yourself that there is. It's like people persuade themselves that they "can't" learn to drive a car or learn a language. Or that they have "no willpower" and therefore can't avoid eating too much chocolate cake.
The best way to get something done is to ignore the voices and just do something - anything - towards getting it done. That's why I keep harping on about "little and often".
Of course there may be real reasons why you can't get something done. The most common is that you have taken on so much work that no one person could possibly get it all done.
21 January 2018 at 21:08 | Mark Forster
-
Mark:
Yes, that certainly sums it up.
On mental blocks, interesting how the mind plays funny tricks on us! Put very simply like you say above, then we could all to a certain extent take a good looks at ourselves and think how silly. I'm guessing that most followers of this blog have some sort of time management issues around being too busy?
On too much work, there are times when that can be out of our control and I suppose just a bit of prioritising and deferring the less pressing stuff should do the trick. Also being realistic and just saying no at the right times, etc.
22 January 2018 at 11:26 | MrBacklog
-
Mark:
Is it fair to say that the first example means "attempt to" and the other means "work toward"? The distinction is not immediately clear to me given these examples.
I'm also having a little trouble with terms like "plan to" and "try to" lately. If one "plans to" do something it's a way of saying "I'm not currently doing that" with a bit of nuance. The last few days, I've been enjoying the Zen of connecting with my present activity, and being able to forget about plans, reminders, etc.
--V
22 January 2018 at 17:25 | Voluntas
-
Voluntas:
<< Is it fair to say that the first example means "attempt to" and the other means "work toward"? >>
No.
What Yoda is saying is that one should either set out to do something or decide not to do something. To say "I'll try to do it" is just a weasel way of sitting on the fence. A few examples: "I'll try to get to your party on Saturday" (meaning I probably won't but don't want to say so), "I'll try to give up smoking starting next week" (meaning I probably won't succeed in giving it up for more than a few days, or quite likely a few hours).
Your reaction to someone saying something like that is that they're not very likely to do what they say.
On the other hand ""I will try to fit you in for your next session this weekend" means exactly what it says. I'l juggle my other appointments and see if there are some gaps and if it's at all possible I'll fit you in.
Your reaction to someone saying this is that there is a high probability that they will succeed in fitting you in.
When Khatzumoto says: "Do try to increase the probability that they will get done". He means it in the second sense. He is encouraging you to think about and experiment with ways to increase the probability. You may not succeed but there is a high probability that you will.
22 January 2018 at 21:25 | Mark Forster
-
I must report that my experiment failed to produce the results I was after. At this time, I'm still pondering whether the failure was in the nature of the system I had designed, or in the fact I fell into a bit of a depressed state mid-way through the experiment, and did much drifting into tasks.
I've decided to give The Simplest Method a whirl and see if it can offer any insights into the nature of my work and my mind.
28 January 2018 at 18:57 | Voluntas
-
Voluntas:
Sorry to hear that. If it's any consolation the same happens to me about once a month!
28 January 2018 at 19:31 | Mark Forster
-
Thank you, Mark. I hope you mean the dead-end experiments; it's hard to imagine from your reports that you encounter depression on a regular basis.
My funk has mainly cleared up. I consulted Maslow's hierarchy and worked my way up a few levels.
--V
29 January 2018 at 4:37 | Voluntas
-
Voluntas:
Yes, I meant my experiments collapsing, but the reasons for them collapsing are varied and wide-ranging!
29 January 2018 at 10:28 | Mark Forster
-
Mark, I'm curious, as I'm sure are many other forum members, about these experiments that didn't deliver? What would you say is your "greatest" failure when designing a system, in the sense that the failure made it clear to you how to make your next idea really take off?
--V
30 January 2018 at 0:43 | Voluntas
-
Voluntas:
<< What would you say is your "greatest" failure when designing a system, in the sense that the failure made it clear to you how to make your next idea really take off? >>
The consistent failure of my long-list ideas to deliver on what I have been aiming for has finally made me realize that it's not the design of the system which is the problem.
30 January 2018 at 14:21 | Mark Forster
-
<< The consistent failure of my long-list ideas to deliver on what I have been aiming for has finally made me realize that it's not the design of the system which is the problem. >>
Very interesting conclusion!
Any thoughts on where the problem does lie?
31 January 2018 at 3:25 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim:
<< Any thoughts on where the problem does lie? >>
Maximizing the effective use of intuition.
1 February 2018 at 12:06 | Mark Forster
-
Mark:
Thanks to you I find I use intuition quite a lot now and I do a task when it stands out. I don't think too much about why it stands out.
However, I found a long list unworkable so decided to split the lists up into small groups based solely on when I thought they should be done by.
I then used my intuition/stand out to work through the individual tasks in that small group.
Seems to work as well and I certainly seem stress free for a while now. I can see all the tasks getting done at the right and that is very pleasing.
I can't think how intuition can be maximised any further than that?
i.e. using intuition to sort the tasks well in the first place, and the to work through them all when I feel like doing them.
1 February 2018 at 15:41 | MrBacklog
-
MrBacklog:
I'm not trying to maximize the use of intuition to get stuff done and avoid stress. I achieved that years ago.
What I'm trying to do is to use intuition to open new paths up in front of me - ones which I wouldn't achieve by conscious thinking.
1 February 2018 at 17:45 | Mark Forster
-
Interesting idea about using intuition to lead onto greater things etc.
Not sure how that links in with earlier comments on failure of long lists in time management, but any further explanation welcome.
1 February 2018 at 22:46 | MrBacklog
-
MrBacklog:
<< any further explanation welcome.>>
I'm still only trying to do it.
2 February 2018 at 14:50 | Mark Forster
-
Mark:
It sounds like you are suggesting a form of divination. I have found that Tarot readings have great power for prompting the intuition to break through creative plateaus.
--V
4 February 2018 at 16:44 | Voluntas
-
Voluntas:
I'm not trying to use intuition in general. I'm specifically trying to use the long list as vehicle for it.
4 February 2018 at 18:22 | Mark Forster
-
6 February 2018 at 19:10 | Cricket