-
I've been trying an interesting little experiment today. I've been using the random list generator at
http://www.random.org/lists/ on a list of (currently) 27 tasks to tell me what I should do next. So far it's proved to be remarkably effective.
I've not so far tried to construct a more elaborate system than just randomizing a normal list. My only rule is that I re-randomize every time I do a task (that's so that recurrent tasks stay on the list with an equal chance).There's no weighting for important or urgent items. And definitely no wild cards like "Take the rest of the day off" or "Do the silliest thing you can think of"!
So my question is who can come up with the best system for using the random list generator?
6 January 2014 at 20:09 | Mark Forster
-
Hi Mark,
I used to do this back in the day, list my tasks in Excel and use the random number generator therein to select a task. If I started by not complee a task, I would readd without crossing off, so t had a greater chance of getting selected.
7 January 2014 at 0:00 | Vegheadjones
-
Yikes, meant to say if I started but did not complete a task it would have a greater chance of being selected
7 January 2014 at 0:01 | Vegheadjones
-
Vegheadjones
Yes, I thought of doing that - or something similar. I haven't tried it yet though.
7 January 2014 at 1:30 | Mark Forster
-
Hi Mark
As per your getting every done book's tip, I use playing cards. I modified it. If I'm overwhelmed with many highly consequential deadline jobs, I simply choose 3 to start and I choose one that seems the most anxiety provoking. Aces - 4 cards. Then I choose 2 more MIT's. Queens - 2 cards and Jacks - 2 cards and 1 or 2 jokers for my choice. Sometimes the overwhelm dissipates enough where I can go back to usual MITs on my list.
If I complete a task or category, I remove the remaining cards. Until each of the 3 MITs have progressed. I take a break and do it again until I feel ok enough to just use a list. If I have many concurrent highly consequential deadlined jobs, this helps to dissipate the anxiety. Also, sometimes only crunching hard for longer hours helps also. My goal is to arrive at enough calm so that I can eat my dinner in peace. Sometimes that means not eating until about midnight. LOL! Eventually things start evening out and I can go back to a normal work pace. I especially love it when there are actual lulls. LOL!
7 January 2014 at 3:21 | learning as I go
-
p.s. typo
Getting Everything Done (and still have time to play)
7 January 2014 at 3:26 | learning as I go
-
Learning:
Interestingly the random number generator I gave the link to does playing cards as well, so you don't even need to keep a pack of cards around.
Another thing it does, though I haven't used it yet, is generate random times and (separately) random dates - always within a range you can set. So one could use it, say, with a list of major projects, use it to select one and generate a random time and date when you were going to start work on it. It'll even miss out weekends if you want it to!
I've refined the list method I described yesterday so that I start with two tasks and every time I work on a task I add another one - I only remove the old task if there is no more work I can do on it that day. That way I can make sure the most important stuff gets done early while still allowing plenty of scope for random stuff to get done - which keeps it interesting.
7 January 2014 at 10:08 | Mark Forster
-
Hi Mark
I like the cards. They are tactile and they add the spirit of gamification. Plus I don't have a smart phone. Sometimes the jobs have lots of different elements which also involve depending on others' actions to move it along. I'm visual so sometimes I'll set up 2-3 separate workstations with magnetic boards to keep track of everything especially pending and follow up. When I have to stop a job because I'm waiting on another person to do their bit, I'll move on to another job and work on it until I'm stuck waiting on another person. When I've gone as far as I need to or I'm stuck waiting on somebody else, I'll pack of that job and get another one progressed. If there wasn't others involved, it would be a hell of a lot easier.
I try to prioritize moving the jobs along as I'm able to get other's to do their part. Sometimes putting a fire under their butt doesn't work as well as I'd like so I'll just go onto another job.
I try to juggle between the impact and importance of the job, the deadline of the job, the amount of time for my work and the amount of time needed to get others to do their part. It's mostly a guessing game when you're dealing with other people. Of course they're unlikely to care as much as you do so you have to keep notes on when they promised something and when to push them some more.
The cards help when I'm looking at all of these jobs that require work and dealing with others yet I have to make sure that the deadlines are met. I already have my habits of working. Random times would frustrate me even worse. I just use my calendar, notes, the work itself and keep plugging away with breaks so that I don't totally lose it. Luckily things aren't always that frantic. I curse myself when my disabilities get in the way. LOL! If the pain dissipates enough, I'll continue working even if it's 2:00am to keep on schedule. When I can't, I'm just stuck being helpless especially when I have surguries. That totally puts a spammer in the works. The world doesn't care about any excuses. Sometimes I just have to pay the price. That's why I work so hard when ever I can so that I don't lose too many battles! LOL!
Your card trick definitely helps to reduce the anxiety. Thanks for the trick! Luckily it's not always like this. I'm happy when I can go back to business as usual. LOL! 2013 was Annus horribilis and 6 days into 2014 looks like more of the same. * sigh * Something has got to give! LOL!
7 January 2014 at 10:52 | learning as I go
-
p.s. I don't necessarily recommend working 12-13 hour stretches all the time. I'm just obsessive. I have a couple more surgeries and I'm hoping that I can get some things settled before then but life doesn't always work out that way. The surgeries always interfere with my work. I try to do as much as possible well before hand. Sometimes it helps. Usually, I prefer to do my weekly DIT in a more rational manner using my normal habits. Even then, sometimes the card trick helps when I'm stalemated. When I'm in enough pain, I don't want to do anything. I have to force myself because I can't concentrate well with the pain and taking drugs makes me even more of an idiot! Using the cards forces me to man up. When the pain abates or the drugs start wearing off, I double check my work for errors. That's usually the joker card. LOL!
7 January 2014 at 11:01 | learning as I go
-
Learning:
Wishing you all the best for the surgeries and may 2014 be a year of better health.
I agree with you that using random numbers reduces anxiety. I'm surprised by how little resistance I put up when the number comes up for a task which otherwise I would be avoiding.
There are all sorts of imaginative ways of using a random number generator - most of which I haven't yet imagined! But one that comes to mind is to use it to stop doing things. Draw up a list of projects and randomly select one (or more) to cease doing. That could be a once a month exercise or even a once a year exercise.
Among the testimonials on the random number site is one from a guy who uses it to predict the future - a future which he then makes happen. I'm not sure how seriously he meant it, but it does have possibilities.
And I've always thought it a pity that car GPS's don't have a "mystery tour" function. You could set a maximum distance or time and it would take you to a completely random destination or alternatively a random journey ending at a specified place. In the long-off days before reliable cars and GPS's I got to know many out-of-the-way villages in England by breaking down in them while completely lost!
7 January 2014 at 11:14 | Mark Forster
-
hi Mark
thanks for the good wishes.
I learned with the card trick to always add at least one joker. If all of the cards have high anxiety work, I won't play the game. LOL! The joker adds the possibility of me choosing the freedom to choose something less onerous.
Lots of my work isn't on the computer. Lots of legal stuff still uses old fashioned paper and old fashioned mail system. PITA! LOL!
I'm not sure of what you mean about randomly choosing projects not to do. I wouldn't be working on it if I didn't have to do it. Sometimes I'm forced to lose some but I'd never willingly choose to default on my obligations.
Like you, I'm stumped on what on the guy using randomness to choose his future.
When I was in the workforce and totally wiped out, I'd go buy a cup and coffee and just drive randomly. It was relaxing and sometimes I'd discover places that I'd like to further investigate. I had to remember to only drive only so far out so that I could get back home within an hour or so. Sometimes, I'd choose to take a chance on eating a meal in an interesting looking eatery. Since I live near the ocean, I'd find these great raw bars to check out. I love raw bars! LOL! I love your Beatles' reference. What a great way to think of it. I just thought of it as winding down enough to go home with less burdens of the job weighing me down. The disabilities make driving difficult. I genuinely miss car rides for the sake of it: not to get anywhere specific. I love that you named it the mystery tour. Add some Steppenwolf, and I'm with ya!
7 January 2014 at 11:52 | learning as I go
-
Learning:
The point about choosing *not* to do things is that many people tend to over-commit themselves. This is particularly bad for recently retired people, who always complain that they are much busier than they were when they were working. So a regular audit of commitments is a good idea. Doing it randomly is something I'm not sure I'd have the courage to do though!
Can't remember the last time I mailed an actual letter. Normally I only use snailmail for returning my Lovefilm disks.
This is the third time today the random selection has come up with "Comments"!
7 January 2014 at 12:04 | Mark Forster
-
Hi Mark
I only use the card game for obligations. I prefer to free wheel it otherwise. LOL! I usually have a pretty good sense of how I want to spend my free time. Of course, my silly brain is always generating lots of possibilities. I already know that I can't entertain the thought of possibly doing all of them. So far as other people trying to obligate me, I'm pretty good at saying No. LOL!
In the US, a lot of legally binding stuff is still in paper form. In fact yesterday, I was at UPS submitting a document. Today or tomorrow, there are more. PITA. I do as much as possible on internet ….when I'm allowed.
LOL about the comments coming up 3 times. I only have 1 or 2 jokers per 11-12 cards. That ensures that I get the MITs done more quickly. When I take a break, I can do a combo of recurring stuff and goofing off. Then back to another round of 4 aces, 2 queens 2 jacks and 1-2 jokers until I feel ok enough to just work off of the list. I'm dreading 8am. That's when I have to start cracking...
7 January 2014 at 12:31 | learning as I go
-
4th time today! :-)
7 January 2014 at 14:46 | Mark Forster
-
Mark, this is a very fun tool. I fed in about 8 large and small tasks, and it uncannily selected the one I most needed to finish first, put all the 'mosquito" tasks in the middle (which ultimately took little time), and finished with the next big project I need to focus on. I mean, what?? How did it know?
I'm wondering if it's playing on the suggestibility of our imaginative brain machines. Rather like Tarot cards, where the reader can make an interpretation/narrative for any picture or sequence of pictures. By offloading the cognitive chore of ordering the tasks to the random algorithm, I am free to instead use my cognitive resources to simply focus on each randomized task in sequence. It's like I didn't have to exercise any responsibility to pick what task to work on next, I just needed to work on it.
Not something I'd need to use everyday, but if faced with lots of little tasks that feel overwhelming? Throw them into the randomizer and let it sort them out for me. Some days, I'd rather be the soldier than the general.
So not cartomancy or bibliomancy but...Taskomancy? :)
7 January 2014 at 16:38 | Mike Brown
-
Hi Mark
You are far more lucky than I am! I worked almost 5 hours straight and didn't get a joker. I just took a break even though I didn't finish all of the cards. Now I get a break. I still feel overwhelmed so I'll do another round with the same card distribution. This time I'll add another joker. I hope I can get at least one joker the next 4 hours. GEEZ! LOL!
For me anyway, the magic element of randomly choosing the cards is that I'm not dreading anything specific! LOL! And I have 1 or 2 jokers in there. That gives me the hope of not doing only my dreaded work. Unfortunately I don't always draw a joker per work session. I'm ashamed to admit it but I don't put any small or recurring stuff on my MITs even when I'm doing my ordinary DIT (weekly plus daily focus). I just bundle them and treat them as a respite to give my brain a rest from the highly focused, high anxiety work. When my obligations aren't this crunched and it's only a matter of a bad attitude, I use the card trick for the same purpose. When I don't know what I'm drawing, there isn't any dread focused on particular work. I can simply curse and moan while I'm doing whatever I drew. If I'm close to finishing a unit of work, I'll just press on to get it out of the way today. I pretty much know when I've done enough for today. Unfortunately I don't always get that relief in under 8 hours. If I can't stand the worry, I'll just prime the deck and work into the evening and night. The next day, I'm grateful that I did it....unless the next day puts even more crap on my back! LOL! Since Oct 02, I've felt like Sisyphus. There has got to be a stopping point eventually or at least a lull. I hate the feelings of futility that I'm feeling. I dread checking email, answering the phone or getting my mail. At least Sunday doesn't have any incoming! LOL! I just keep telling myself that eventually all of this crap will be out of my active memory. That hopefulness gives me impetus to keep trying. LOL!
7 January 2014 at 18:20 | learning as I go
-
Hi Mark
I just thought of something. Does the randomizer keep the tasks circulating rather than eliminating them as you work on them? I like that the cards go to the discard rack so that I know that I'll likely draw at least all 3 MITs for that round. I usually draw a joker during a time block. Unfortunately, sometimes I don't get the joker. If the randomizer keeps circulating the same work such as getting 4 comment cards only half way through the day, then the actual progress might suffer. That would only add to my anxiety and I'd find myself ignoring the easy card. My way, I know that I'll make good progress on at least one or two of the MITs. During 4 hours, I'm highly likely to choose more than 4 aces. I'll get at least one queen or jack or joker.
Because I didn't get any jokers last round, I've added a joker for the simple reason that I'm envious that you got 4 jokers and I got none! "T'aint fair!" LOL! Well I only have 18" more minutes until the next block. (I give myself an hour to do the little stuff and recurring stuff plus some pure goof off time before I start the next time block.) Fingers crossed that I get a joker in the mix!
7 January 2014 at 18:44 | learning as I go
-
Mark, thanks for a fun idea or two to start 2014. An amusing variation is to put your favourite music playlist on "shuffle" and be alert to synchronicities.
"Random" may of course just be a label for unknown causes, like luck maybe.
7 January 2014 at 20:50 | michael
-
Hi Mark
WooHoo! I got a joker! Load of laundry going in while I do bills. That is so relieving to to this instead of the other stuff for awhile. I love the jokers. There's one more in there. Fingers crossed.
7 January 2014 at 21:24 | learning as I go
-
Learning:
<< Does the randomizer keep the tasks circulating rather than eliminating them as you work on them? >>
It's easy to arrange it either way.
8 January 2014 at 17:56 | Mark Forster
-
michael:
<<"Random" may of course just be a label for unknown causes, like luck maybe. >>
Many so-called randomizers use formulas which simulate randomness, but actually aren't. However random.org uses atmospheric noise - don't ask me how - which gives much truer randomization apparently.
My favourite demonstration of a randomizer is to show how traffic authorities can sincerely report huge improvements in accident rates from the use of speed cameras without actually making any difference at all to the accident rates.
8 January 2014 at 18:01 | Mark Forster
-
Mark wrote:
<< My favourite demonstration of a randomizer is to show how traffic authorities can sincerely report huge improvements in accident rates from the use of speed cameras without actually making any difference at all to the accident rates. >>
Are you referring to the "regression to the mean" phenomenon described here?
http://understandinguncertainty.org/speed-cameras-regression-mean-and-daily-mail-againOr something else?
A good friend of mine has been battling speed cameras, red-light cameras, and yellow-light timing shenanigans all over the western United States - they generally DECREASE safety but are still popular with lawmakers because they generate lots of revenue for states and municipalities.
8 January 2014 at 22:59 | Seraphim
-
Mark wrote:
<< Among the testimonials on the random number site is one from a guy who uses it to predict the future - a future which he then makes happen. I'm not sure how seriously he meant it, but it does have possibilities. >>
This reminds me of one of Peter F. Drucker's quotes: "The best way to predict the future is to create it." Lots of variants here:
http://quoteinvestigator.com/2012/09/27/invent-the-future/ 8 January 2014 at 23:06 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim:
<< Are you referring to the "regression to the mean" phenomenon described here?
http://understandinguncertainty.org/speed-cameras-regression-mean-and-daily-mail-again >>
Yes! It can be demonstrated very clearly with a randomizer. I might demonstrate it in a later post.
<< A good friend of mine has been battling speed cameras, red-light cameras, and yellow-light timing shenanigans all over the western United States - they generally DECREASE safety but are still popular with lawmakers because they generate lots of revenue for states and municipalities. >>
This country is infested with them - that and stupid "traffic-calming measures" *. But they are not quite so popular with the authorities now because the government has cut the link by which the money raised went to the same authority which set up the cameras.
* The safest roads are also the fastest, i.e. motorways. Furthermore the majority of accidents on motorways occur where there are roadworks and the flow of traffic is deviated or interrupted. So the solution for reducing accidents in urban areas? Obviously to break up the flow of traffic by putting in artifical deviations and interruptions.
9 January 2014 at 12:44 | Mark Forster
-
I am now going to demonstrate how speed cameras are incredibly efficient at reducing accidents.
Let's take six potential camera sites and examine their accident records. To establish the accident records for the sites, I will use the random "dice roller" function on random.org. I will give each site six throws of the dice and every time a six comes up I will record an accident. Here goes:
Site A: 2 accidents
Site B: 0
Site C: 1
Site D: 1
Site E: 2
Site F: 3
Obviously site F is highly dangerous, so we will install a speed camera.
Let's roll the dice again:
Site A: 2
Site B: 0
Site C: 1
Site D: 0
Site E: 2
Site F: 0
Wow! Putting the speed camera on Site F has reduced the accident rate to 0!!! That's one in the eye for all the doubters.
So obviously the next step is to tackle Sites A and E which have an accident rate of 2 accidents a year each.
Roll the dice again:
Site A: 2
Site B: 1
Site C: 1
Site D: 2
Site E: 1
Site F: 1
Hmm... The new speed camera hasn't changed the accident rate on Site A, but the one on site E has reduced it by 50%, and the camera on Site F is still having a huge effect. So you can see clearly from these statistics that speed cameras overall are having great success. Obviously the next step is to reduce the speed limit on Site A and put another camera on Site D, which has become more dangerous - probably because drivers are now taking the opportunity of a camera-free zone to speed up.
COMMENT:
All this discussion is just fantasy in the minds of the highway authority. What is really happening is that the accidents are completely random, and there has been no difference whatever to the likelihood of accidents at any of the sites. If you take the total number of accidents Year 1 was 9, Year 2 was 5 and Year 3 was 8. Note that the big dip in Year 2 was also a random event.
NOTE: I didn't cheat at all. Try this for yourself if you don't believe me.
9 January 2014 at 13:13 | Mark Forster
-
And note that this works in reverse too. If you take cameras away from sites which have a low accident record, some of them are bound to have an increased accident rate the next year. Naturally the people responsible for removing those cameras are murderers in all but name.
9 January 2014 at 13:38 | Mark Forster
-
I renamed "Site A" to "Flibblesville" and accidents dropped to zero. Clearly the new name encourages better driving!
9 January 2014 at 13:42 | Chris
-
Sounds like Demings work on Quality. I believe it works like this (I'm not an expert, just fascinated by it) What you look for in a set of data is variability. If the variability is within a certain range, it's random, I believe Deming called this common cause variability. So if you look at 5 intersections and they all have between, say 15 and 20 accidents per year, that's common cause variability. Of course, the strategy is to reduce the number of accidents at all 5 intersections, but putting a camera on the intersection with 20 accidents won't address the "core" problem. However, if a 6th intersection has 60 accidents, then this is called a special cause varation because the data is so far outside the regular stream. You would need to look at this intersection more carefully to find out why there are so many accidents at this particular intersection.
There are two circumstances where traffic cameras might work. First, to reduce the average number of accidents per intercection from, say, 15 to 5, you could try installing traffic cameras at each intersection and track the data. This may be a way of addressing the common cause variability. Or, if one intersection did have 60 accidents, you might install a traffic camera at that intersection to see if you could get the data under control, or perhaps there is another reason for the anomaly.
This is important for management because so often we confuse special cause variability with common cause variability. We make changes to an individual intersection when what needs to be addressed is the whole system, or, we initiate a systematic change across the whole system when the problem is just one intersection. That's why I believe data is so important.
9 January 2014 at 14:22 | Paul MacNeil
-
Chris:
Next year you'll probably find they've got used to the new name and the accident rate has risen again.
9 January 2014 at 14:24 | Mark Forster
-
Paul MacNeil:
<< This is important for management because so often we confuse special cause variability with common cause variability. >>
Yes, variability is a characteristic of random numbers. They "clump" as opposed to being evenly spread, which is what people intuitively assume.
This has implications in many fields, including for example epidemiology. Incidents of fairly rare diseases can clump, giving the impression that there is some local environmental factor that is producing the result when it's just natural randomness. Of course, to complicate things there may actually be a local environmental factor that is producing the result. This gives rise to two questions: 1) How do you tell the difference? 2) How do you explain the result in language which will satisfy the local population, press, politians and class-action lawyers?
9 January 2014 at 14:33 | Mark Forster
-
Hi all
I can't be the only one who drives more carefully where I know there are cameras. *guilty!* A few acquaintances have complained to me about tickets they've received for speeding, running red light and one made an illegal U turn. They got no sympathy from me. All of these cameras are in or very close to our neighborhood. LOL! What did they think would happen? In my state, you have to pay a surcharge for three years on top of a one time penalty when you accrue enough traffic violation points. I'm never in that much of a hurry! If others are like me, the cameras play well to our frugality. Some people here are on 6 months suspended license for....accumulated traffic violations points! I thought only drunk drivers got their license suspended.
It used to be seeing a cop car on the highway or following somebody who had the guts to own a speed trap dectector even though it's illegal in some states. The highway traffic would reduce from 75 - 80 miles per hour down to posted limit of 55 mph! LOL! I think those cameras have the same effect. Who wants to pay a surcharge for three years because they kept ignoring the cameras?
9 January 2014 at 17:44 | learning as I go
-
Hi Mark: How do you tell the difference between special cause and common cause variability? Believe it or not, there's a mathematical formula for that, it has to do with the distribution of data over time. If you can imagine a graph of data points along an axis over time, say 12 months. Within that date you can draw a straight line which represents the mean value, kind of a mid-point through all the data. That mean value is the result of a formula based on the data. Two other calculations are possible: an upper control limit and a matching lower control limit. This calculation will give you two lines above and below the mean value. (FYI, the formula is simple: usually standard deviation +/- 3) Any data point above or below those two lines represents a possible special cause and should be examined individually for the causes. There may not be any special cause, but nevertheless it would be wise to examine it and figure out the cause. In the cases of the other data points, time would be better spent looking at the system as a whole and make improvements on the system. Improvements on the system are designed to minimize the distance between the upper and lower control limits ("getting the system under control") and then lowering the mean value ("improving quality"). I believe this is the essence of 6 sigma.
The graph I asked you to imagine is called a control chart, and an example of one is here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Xbar_chart_for_a_paired_xbar_and_R_chart.svg Here is an article about how to create a control chart. Try it!
http://www.wikihow.com/Create-a-Control-ChartOthers can explain this better, this is totally not my field. Please forgive me if I've gotten it wrong.
9 January 2014 at 20:10 | Paul MacNeil
-
I've tried this a few times with the original AutoFocus (AF1). It's a great way to break down resistance and get moving on different projects, especially when you are in a rut and no activities look appealing. I haven't been able to sustain it for more than about a week though. First, once you get moving on a few random tasks, after several days you "know what you want to do" (ie keep working on some of the random items). Also, I find that in a lot of cases, for every AutoFocus task I complete, another two are created. As you keep working on things the list just fans out and gets larger and larger. If you have 100 items on your list and are processing 10 randomly every day, a feeling of frustration can set in when you realize a preferred activity will only come up once every 10 days on average, and you have no way of "getting to" that item because the random number generator is "in charge" (ha ha).
Actually, the realization that the AutoFocus list was always going to fan out and get larger and larger made me take an approach of every week condensing the list down to about a page, resulting in an iterative process of working and consolidating, working and consolidating etc. Condense the list on Saturday to a page of around 30 items. Work the list as normal from Sunday to Friday. The following Saturday the list will be about 4-5 pages, so condense it back to 1 page, then repeat the process. Use random numbers if necessary to start on something.
9 January 2014 at 22:21 | Simon
-
Simon:
I've found the random selection is amazingly effective in overcoming resistance and getting jobs done which I know I wouldn't have done otherwise.
My best solution so far to the problem of the ever-growing list is to start the day with a list of two tasks and every time I finish working on one task I add another. I remove tasks which are completely finished from the list, but keep unfinished and recurrent tasks on it. The random number generator is set to the number of tasks currently on the list.
A variation on this which I haven't tried yet is to write out a list for the day in order of importance, set the generator to choose a number between 1 and 2, and then increase the second number by one each time..
10 January 2014 at 1:56 | Mark Forster
-
Maybe to simplify a little, you could roll a single six-sided die and move that many tasks forward in your list. It would be simpler than resetting the generator all the time, and you wouldn't need a website at all, just a die.
Do you think that would work?
To move faster thru the list, you could use an icosahedron (d20), or percentile dice if you have a really long list.
10 January 2014 at 2:14 | Seraphim
-
Hi Seraphim
What's wrong with rolling the die or dice is that each roll is a virgin roll. Was was a craps croupier in my past. Example: You could roll 10 12's in a row. Contrasting a deck of cards, in which you can track them and adjust the odds. That's why they have 6 decks in a shoe and shuffle them after dealing only a few decks. When I'm forcing myself to get stuff done, I want to make sure that I can stack the deck to my favor yet still have some randomness. People don't realize that the dice odds are based on each roll or an infinite amount of rolls. IOW, each roll of the dice is a virgin roll. Mark got 4 jokers in only 1/2 a day. With my dimishing pile of cards, there was no way I'd get so many jokers because I only had 1 or 2 jokers. Or you could break down the work into smaller units but that would require more times of having to draw cards/numbers. My way, I choose a job and work on subtasks until I choose another card (which could be a repeat. LOL!) My aim is to use the game to get me more willing to start and to spend as little time as possible getting the work done. That's why I prime the deck.
10 January 2014 at 2:57 | learning as I go
-
Seraphim
<< you could roll a single six-sided die and move that many tasks forward in your list. It would be simpler than resetting the generator all the time, and you wouldn't need a website at all, just a die. >>
I've tried that, but the problem is that moving fast through the list isn't really an advantage in itself. As learning says, the dice take no notice of what you want or what has gone before or what is coming after. So all you get is a random selection from a list of 60 tasks (or whatever number you have), which is exactly what you get if you set the randomizer to select from 60 numbers. What is needed is a way of increasing the odds of selecting certain tasks. I'm doing it by putting the important tasks at the beginning, so the odds start at 50%.
And btw you won't move very fast through the list if you do what you're suggesting. With one die you would move at an average of three tasks per throw.
10 January 2014 at 10:35 | Mark Forster
-
I've spoken before about the similarities between using systems for productivity and using diets for weight loss. In both cases there is a feeling of overwhelm and increasing loss of control of tasks / weight. We know we need to work more efficiently / eat better. Despite knowing this we still continue procrastinating / eating poorly because there is an immediate neurological payoff.
Diets can be effective because you outsource your food habits to the rules of the chosen diet programme. Similarly productivity systems can be effective because you outsource your task processessing to a chosen rules based system. By outsourcing the decision process you are freed from the guilt of continuing with poor choices and the productivity / diet system takes over a large part of the decision process.
In both cases the systems can work for a while then start to fail. This is because we learn to game them and push against the system's inherent weaknesses. For diets, surely one cake is okay, and for productivity I'll do that awkward task after I've just spent another hour watching television. These individual pushes are okay by themselves but they represent a change in attitude to the system which can ring alarm bells as it suggests the poor decision making processes are slowly being taken back from the system in order to once again experience the immediate gratification feeling.
The most common result is "falling off the wagon" (Dave Allen cheerfully uses this exact phrase, somewhat cunningly encouraging people back to GTD) followed by a new diet / productivity system - this is a new approach, it is definitely The One! I've lost count of how many times I've done this.
It's interestng to read Seraphim's experience under stress - he started looking for a fresh system which would address the creep. But he caught himself doing it and said "NO!" and drew closer to his system, which takes some willpower, like sticking to a diet that already works rather than looking for a new one. The stress was the trigger which caused a flight response, looking for safety in a new hiding place.
The use of random selections is interesting because it's the ultimate sacrifice of decision making, and it works if you have the willpower to stick to what the selector says. If you find yourself picking another card or rolling the dice again to try and get another task then your gratification habits are making themselves known again - time to really knuckle down and focus on the good results from the system as the payoff instead. That takes real willpower and a longer term vision as to what you want.
I've been through my story before. I've tried lots of productivity systems (and lots of diets!) over the last 25 years until, like Serpahim, I said to myself "This is just going over old ground, I'm not doing this any more". At that point I abandoned all diet and productivity rules based systems and changed to a combination of getting my head down and getting on with doing things and eating correctly, and using a simple text list to keep track of a few things. The relief at the time, from dropping what felt like baggage, was amazing and since then this way of living has just become normal.
I think it's fascinating just how powerful the immediate gratification can be and how we can construct supporting environments to help control them. When done right they are incredibly helpful and lots of experimentation and experience helps to tailor the most useful concepts which stay with you forever.
10 January 2014 at 14:42 | Chris
-
Hi Chris
Congrats on your mastery! However, it's not so easy for many people. You said
"The relief at the time, from dropping what felt like baggage, was amazing and since then this way of living has just become normal."
Even before the brain damage, my brain was never like that. Unless you have the same type of hard-wiring, you can't begin to realize what it actually feels like. I have managed to enjoy some accomplishments despite having this life long battle. Trust me. Continuously forcing myself to do what I want to get done yet hating the process has always been the most challenging part of the battle. I'm not the only one. People only see what you've accomplished. They aren't aware of the daily grind of forcing yourself to do what your brain is begging you to avoid.
After the cognitive reconstruction therapy, my brain's capacities improved somewhat but the damage made the challenge of fighting my brain's tendencies much harder to do. I came to Mark's site in desperation because I couldn't think or do as I used to. I learned principles and work arounds that have helped tremendously. I only wish I had learned them 50-60 years ago, especially little and often and not needing to work my list in order.
It's not so much "instant gratification" as it is profound relief. It's incredibly difficult to fight against seeking relief when your brain's response is making you feel agonizingly restless. These work arounds may seem silly to you but them are a lifesaver to me. They help me to follow my conscientious with far less of a cognitive battle to keep approaching what my brain is registering as "avoid! avoid! pain and anxiety ahead!" LOL! I'd still do my work even if I didn't learn these tricks. However, these workarounds greatly reduce the stress and mental fatigue. It may seem silly to you but it's a lifesaver to me. And I'm not alone. Trust me. It's a life long battle. I actually have to stoke up my brain like I'm going into battle. My weapon is the ways I've learned to circumvent the problem. My only shield is my determination. The cognitive dissonance is hard wiring, not just a wimpy attitude. It never gets easier. We just carry on.
That's just the flip side of my wiring. It's the price I pay for also having the benefits of this quirky hunk of gray matter. When I'm challenged or interested, I can work non-stop for obscene lengths of time (if the disabilities don't interfere.) Hey, I can't take any credit at all. It's just how my brain sputters along. LOL!
If you could appreciate the incredible amounts of willpower needed to do dreaded work, then you could see how heroic Seraphim actually is. We sometimes feel desperate to find a way to make approaching dreaded work easier. Seraphim saw his as merely mental habits. I sincerely pray that's all it is for him. When it's genetic, there is no cure or adjustments. There's only determination and that doesn't quell the torture. We just get used to living the grind knowing that there's no alternatives other than delegation. LOL!
When my resistance stalemates me, I just grab the cards. It's silly to you. It's a Godsend to me.
10 January 2014 at 16:44 | learning as I go
-
Mark, I like the idea of starting with a very small list of only a few items. I think my problem might've been applying the random number generator to a full AutoFocus notebook of 10+ pages and 100+ items. It actually had a lot of benefits for the first few days -- items on the earlier pages were as likely to come up as current items, and it felt as though nothing would ever get lost in the system because eventually everything would be addressed.
(FYI the strategy to pick random items from a paper AF list was to generate two random numbers -- one for the page # and the other for the line # on the page. If it came back to page 4 and line 17, but that item was already crossed off, I would just do the first open item below it.)
Anyway, I think deep down we know what we need to do. After 3 or 4 days of running random AF, I felt a really strong tension building up because I wasn't getting to the things I knew I really had to do. After about 5 or 6 days the tension was quite strong, so I abandoned "randomAF" and just started doing what needed to be done. But ... I was happy that randomAF not only helped me clarify what needed to be done, but it also built up tension that worked as a great motivator, and I got started on quite a few interesting projects that I wouldn't have done otherwise.
So there might be a back and forth here -- work the lists and do what needs to be done. When you hit the point where you are cycling through the lists and nothing is standing out, rather than dismissing, just switch over to randomAF for a little while.
10 January 2014 at 17:22 | Simon
-
LifeBalance has an interesting use of the randomizer. Here's the program in a nutshell:
1. Enter all your tasks, and organize them however you like in a tree.
2. Define for each task it's life area (family, recreation, work, service, whatever), and optionally importance, and timeframe, duration, sequence, etc..
3. The program randomly chooses a short list of things you might work on, while respecting what you have defined about each task.
4. If you neglect an area of your life, those tasks are more likely to come up. If you neglect certain tasks for a while, those become more likely to appear on the list.
5. Do things on the list, check them off, and new things get randomly thrown in the pot.
It is a bit unnerving for a while, as you think whether something should be done that's not on the list, but eventually you learn to trust it and adapt. If something should have be done sooner you can adjust the properties when you define and organize the tasks in the tree.
10 January 2014 at 17:40 | Alan Baljeu
-
Chris wrote:
<< But he caught himself doing it and said "NO!" and drew closer to his system, which takes some willpower, like sticking to a diet that already works rather than looking for a new one. >>
Yes, it took a little willpower, but mostly it took a recognition of what was happening, and the realization I had missed a trigger. This is very helpful as I try to figure out what triggers and rewards are at the root of these undesirable behaviors.
I have been drafting another post on this topic, to show how important Charles Duhigg's book, The Power of Habit, has been to me lately: his discussion on the way habits form, how they function, and how they can be reprogrammed. A short version is posted here:
http://markforster.squarespace.com/forum/post/2252333#post2258150Learning, if you have not yet seen this book, or tried the techniques in it, I think it might be helpful for you. The center of habit formation is the basal ganglia, which is pretty deep inside the brain and is usually not impacted by physical brain damage, so perhaps the techniques in this book can help you.
These ideas mesh very well with Mark's emphasis on structure and systems, such as what he described in the Do It Tomorrow book and in many places on this site.
10 January 2014 at 19:17 | Seraphim
-
Alan, LifeBalance sounds interesting. It reminds me a little of an app I've been using called Lift, which simply tracks repeated habitual behavior. I wonder if I can work some of these concepts into my personal kanban.
10 January 2014 at 19:19 | Seraphim
-
Mark wrote:
<< What is needed is a way of increasing the odds of selecting certain tasks. >>
If you are using an AF1-like list, where items are added at the end, and re-entered at the end if not completed, then I'd guess the "freshest" and "most important" items are near the end (de facto, based on the fact that actioned tasks will tend to conglomerate there).
Coming from a person who, at age 9, memorized the Monopoly game board and the relative probabilities of landing on the various squares, and used this information to great advantage against his friends and siblings, there are lots of ways to set up dice rules to help emphasize different parts of the board. :-)
For example, you might want to spend less time on early pages and more time on later pages. Let's say you have four pages in your AF1 book. OK, get our four six-sided dice. Depending on what page you are on, roll this many dice to see how many tasks to move forward:
Page - Dice
1 ----- 4
2 ----- 3
3 ----- 2
4 ----- 1
If the chosen task is still valid, take action for as long as you want, and re-enter at the end of the list if you don't finish it in one go.
If the chosen task is no longer of interest, simply delete it and roll the dice again.
This way, you don't need to arbitrarily assess which tasks are "important" - you can let the system decide that, based on which tasks actually see action.
10 January 2014 at 19:33 | Seraphim
-
Simon:
<< FYI the strategy to pick random items from a paper AF list was to generate two random numbers -- one for the page # and the other for the line # on the page. If it came back to page 4 and line 17, but that item was already crossed off, I would just do the first open item below it. >>
I'm not sure if you are aware of it, but this method is not fully random. It gives preference to tasks which are on the pages on which the most tasks have already been done. The chances of landing on any particular page are equal, but once you are on the page the odds will vary according to the number and position of the remaining tasks.
For example if you have a page of 20 lines and it is full with 20 tasks, then once you have landed on the page there is only one number which will select any particular task. The task on line 8 can only be selected if you throw an 8. So its chances of being selected are 1 in 20 or 5%.
However if the tasks on Lines 1-7 have all already been crossed out, then any number between 1 and 8 inclusive will select the task on Line 8. Its chances of being selected are therefore 8 in 20 or 40%.
I'm not sure what you intend to happen when you throw a number which refers to a line below the last open task on the page. Do you carry on to the following page and do the first open task there? If that is the case then the odds in my example would be even higher.
So you can see that there is a huge difference in the odds of individual tasks being selected and this tends to favour the older tasks on the list.
This may well be a good thing.
10 January 2014 at 20:33 | Mark Forster
-
Alan:
<< The program randomly chooses a short list of things you might work on, while respecting what you have defined about each task. >>
I'm not sure I understand how it does that. Does it select a few tasks from each life area?
10 January 2014 at 20:36 | Mark Forster
-
Seraphim:
Simon's method puts the emphasis on the earliest pages and now your method puts the emphasis on the latest pages. I assume that if a throw on the last page takes you beyond the end of the page you go back to Page 1 and finish the count. Otherwise I don't see how Task 1 would ever get done.
<< This way, you don't need to arbitrarily assess which tasks are "important" - you can let the system decide that, based on which tasks actually see action. >>
I don't understand how that works. The system would certainly favour completing tasks once they've been started, but I don't see why those would necessarily be more important than the ones which haven't been started.
10 January 2014 at 20:45 | Mark Forster
-
Another method is to have several lists with different numbers of tasks on them. For example you could use the "A - Must Do", "B - Should Do" and "C - Could Do" grading system to produce three lists. Work on List A using the randomizer until it is complete, then List B and then List C.
Or perhaps you could take one task from each list in turn. This would work because there should be less tasks in List A than in List B, and less tasks in List B than in List C. Therefore the odds on List A tasks are higher than those on List B tasks and those in List B higher than those in List C.
10 January 2014 at 20:54 | Mark Forster
-
Mark, actually for a while I actually numbered all of the unactioned items in the AF notebook, and then randomized those numbers in Excel. If there were 80 unactioned items in the notebook, cells A1:A80 in Excel would be populated with integers 1 through 80. Cells B1:B80 would be random numbers. I would select columns A and B and sort by column B, which would randomize the numbers in column A. Each time a task was completed I would delete the number in Excel and cross it off the list in the notebook. It sounds tedious, but actually it wasn't, and I only used this method here and there to get out of ruts.
You can also try this if you want a higher probability of picking some tasks. Let's say you have four tasks -- A, B, C and D, and you assign them a score between 1 and 5 based on importance, with 5 being the highest. For example:
A - 3
B - 2
C - 5
D - 4
Those numbers add to 14. Use the numbers to create ranges:
A - 1 to 3 (3 numbers)
B - 4 to 5 (2 numbers)
C - 6 to 10 (5 numbers)
D - 11 to 14 (4 numbers)
Then pick a random integer between 1 and 14, and then choose the corresponding activity.
The other simpler approach to randomizing tasks would be to just write the activities on blank business cards and then shuffle them. The cards can also be physically sorted, project steps can be listed on the back etc. But not terribly portable.
10 January 2014 at 22:03 | Simon
-
<< The program randomly chooses a short list of things you might work on, while respecting what you have defined about each task. >>
<I'm not sure I understand how it does that. Does it select a few tasks from each life area?>
I'm not entirely sure Mark. It does pick tasks from each area for sure, but it will emphasize areas you neglected and tasks you neglected. There's also a button to pick a different set if you don't like the current list.
10 January 2014 at 22:21 | Alan Baljeu
-
Alan:
<< There's also a button to pick a different set if you don't like the current list. >>
It's not really random if you keep pressing the button until you get the answer you want!
11 January 2014 at 0:33 | Mark Forster
-
Simon:
<< for a while I actually numbered all of the unactioned items in the AF notebook, and then randomized those numbers in Excel. >>
That sounds as if it's exactly the same as the method I started with, which was to keep a numbered list in Evernote and then use the randomizer to pick a number. That does give a truly random choice in that every task has exactly the same chance of being picked.
I'm actually trying out the method you originally described because I'm interested in the effect of the rules, which gradually increase the probability of a task's being picked as it gets older.
<< You can also try this if you want a higher probability of picking some tasks. Let's say you have four tasks -- A, B, C and D, and you assign them a score between 1 and 5 based on importance, with 5 being the highest. >>
Another way of achieving the same effect would be to enter a top priority task five times on the list, a slightly less priority task four times and so on.
But one does have to remember that when one increases the chances of one task on a list you are also reducing the chances of all the others.
11 January 2014 at 0:43 | Mark Forster
-
Yes, please ignore that button.
11 January 2014 at 6:22 | Alan Baljeu
-
I am pleased that, finally, I find others appreciating the use of randomness to choose tasks.
I have felt very alone.
My way of getting around total randomness...i.e. swaying the choices to those that have higher "importance"....is to create a new list each morning, writing down everything that is pressing on my mind. I know you can create a never-ending list, but I list the important things and then stop when I find myself getting too creative (usually after about twenty or so items). Some items can be large, some small. No matter...whatever is foremost in my mind.
11 January 2014 at 9:01 | Fiona
-
Thanks, Fiona. That sounds a sensible way of doing it. How has it worked for you?
11 January 2014 at 12:00 | Mark Forster
-
In the Life Balance software you have a slider-wheel to determine importance of life-areas. Like a cake diagram you give out percentages to each life-area. The program factors that in, when it calculates the list.
11 January 2014 at 15:56 | Christopher
-
Actually, Mark, using a new list every day has worked very well - particularly at my workplace. On days that I have very pressing tasks, the list ends up quite small..sometimes only six items. The urgency I feel stops me from adding extraneous tasks. When I have no must-do tasks, the list becomes longer. That is the time when the nice-to-do tasks get a look in.
11 January 2014 at 17:56 | Fiona
-
Mark wrote:
<< I don't understand how that works. The system would certainly favour completing tasks once they've been started, but I don't see why those would necessarily be more important than the ones which haven't been started. >>
Thanks Mark. I agree with you that the main feature of my proposal is to help drive tasks to completion once they've been started. The selection for importance is weaker, but I do think it's present. Here is how I was thinking that would work:
When the dice select the item, you have a choice: take action, or delete. If you take action, work for a while, then re-enter without completion, this fact (that you thought it worthwhile enough to take action rather than deleting it) gives the task some importance.
This is based on your principle that action itself is the best way to identify importance. Or maybe you would phrase it differently, or maybe you don't think the "act or delete" mechanism is selective enough to filter for importance.
In any case, I like Fiona's method better. :-)
12 January 2014 at 0:01 | Seraphim
-
The original AutoFocus (AF1) could be modified as follows -- if you cycle through a page and nothing stands out, rather than just dismissing the entire page, use a random number to choose one task on the page. Complete that task and move on to the next page.
This would ensure that even the hardest tasks on the earlier pages would eventually be addressed. It would also let you deal with your list as you see fit, with the randomizer only taking over when you are stuck.
If there were 8 open items on a page where nothing stands out, generate a random number between 1 and 8. If it returns 3, do the third item.
12 January 2014 at 22:29 | Simon
-
Since I last wrote I've been trying out several different ways of using the randomizer - including one which was similar to Seraphim's suggestion.
So far I have found the best method to be the one I suggested earlier:
- start with two tasks
- add another task each time you finish working on a task
- leave tasks on the list unless you have completely finished with them for the day
- start again from scratch each day
- always set the randomizer to the number of tasks actually on the list
- best to use an automatically numbered list (e.g. Word, Evernote) then you don't have to keep counting tasks.
The advantages of doing it this way are:
1. You can ensure that the high-priority tasks get preference by entering them first.
2. The number of tasks on the list will bear a reasonable relationship to the amount of time you have available to do them.
Disadvantages:
I haven't found any real disadvantages yet, though if you want to make sure you don't miss anything you will need to have a "master list" as well.
General Comment:
It's best to work off quite large tasks and use project lists where necessary.
14 January 2014 at 10:52 | Mark Forster
-
Simon:
<< if you cycle through a page and nothing stands out, rather than just dismissing the entire page, use a random number to choose one task on the page. >>
One problem with this is that there is often only one task on the page anyway.
14 January 2014 at 10:54 | Mark Forster
-
Mark wrote:
<< 1. You can ensure that the high-priority tasks get preference by entering them first. >>
If the randomizer selects each task with equal probability, I don't understand how it gives preference to the ones entered first. Can you explain that again?
14 January 2014 at 15:46 | Seraphim
-
This was a fun thread to read. Mark got comments how many times in a row? Looks like the programmer put a lot of work into the options. (Will not wander over and procrastinate even more. There's free wifi in the
I'll often use a random number on my existing list, to break out of a stall. I use the second-hand on my watch. Depending on the list length, I might subtract 20 or 30. Don't count lines with completed tasks. If I reach the end of the list, I go back to the top of the list; older tasks get a bit more attention, which is useful if I leave uncompleted tasks on the list (marked "worked on today") rather than moving them to the bottom.
Less set-up time than typing in a list. Easier to shift back to your regular system when the stall is broken. Can do without entering computer room.
My list includes a wide variety of energy and interest levels.
An easier variation on Simon's method of giving some lines more priority is to decide which ones get more attention (number of stars?), then tap (count) twice or more as you reach those lines. So 1-read book, 2-cook supper, 3-cook supper, 4-read forums. Easier than copying the list each time priorities change.
Sometimes, being forced to do something (by the random number) actually forces you to make a decision. If the choices really are equal (food court line), I'd waffle and be unable to choose. Then I'd flip a coin, and realize I really didn't like what it chose. In that case, it was a system to force me to make a decision, not a system to ensure things got equal attention.
Seraphim, if I read it correctly, if you start a task but don't finish it, you don't erase it, but you do write it again at the end. That way it's both number 3 and number 27 -- twice the chance of being selected. If you do another chunk, it's numbers 3, 27 and 31. When it's finally done, you get to stroke out several lines at once. I did something like that for several months. The same task might get entered (and not done) on several week plans. Stroking it off multiple pages was a big reward!
Done one pass of the forum. On to the MIT.
14 January 2014 at 19:27 | Cricket
-
Seraphim:
<< If the randomizer selects each task with equal probability, I don't understand how it gives preference to the ones entered first. Can you explain that again? >>
Easy.
Say the first two tasks you enter are Email and Paper In-tray. You set the randomizer to 2. So each task has a 50% chance of being selected.
Since you need to work some more on whichever task was selected you leave it on the list. Now you add a third task, say Tax Return, and set the randomizer to 3. Each task now has a 33.33% chance of being selected. Then you add a fourth task, say Invoicing.
Your list now is:
1. Email
2. Paper
3. Tax Return
4. Invoicing
Set the randomizer to 4 and each task has a 25% chance of being selected.
Note that the first two tasks Email and Paper have had four opportunities to be selected (at 50%, 33.33%, and 25% odds), then Tax Return has had two opportunities at 33% and 25% respectively, while Invoicing has only had one opportunity at 25% odds.
And so on.
14 January 2014 at 20:33 | Mark Forster
-
Cricket:
<< Mark got comments how many times in a row? >>
I think it was four, but they weren't in a row - there were intervening tasks.
<< Seraphim, if I read it correctly, if you start a task but don't finish it, you don't erase it, but you do write it again at the end. >>
No, you just leave it on the list where it was. You don't re-enter it.
<< That way it's both number 3 and number 27 -- twice the chance of being selected. If you do another chunk, it's numbers 3, 27 and 31. >>
That's not it. You don't need any of that. Each throw gives all the tasks equal preference. The prioritizing of the first tasks on the list comes from the number of throws they are present for and the higher chances of being selected when there are only a few tasks on the list. See my previous post to Seraphim.
14 January 2014 at 20:49 | Mark Forster
-
I'm still fascinated by the random-number generator and am currently experimenting with a variation of Simon's method.
I'm using a notebook in which I cross out out tasks which I've finished working on for the time being. Unfinished and recurrent tasks are then re-entered at the end of the list. The list is treated as one long list. Pages with no tasks remaining are removed.
I set my randomizer to a maximum equal to the number of lines on a page. My notebook has 32 lines on a page, so the randomizer is set to produce an integer between 1 and 32 inclusive.
This is just a convenient number which produces reasonable results, but you can use a lower or higher number if you wish.
I use the randomizer to produce a number and move forward that number of spaces (onto the next page if necessary). I INCLUDE lines which have been crossed out in the count - this is important.
If the task I land on is crossed out I move to the next uncrossed-out task (on the next page if necessary).
When I reach the end of the list, I circle back to the beginning of the list, ignoring empty lines on the last page.
This method has the effect of increasing the likelihood of the older tasks on the list getting done. Note that if you don't include lines with crossed-out tasks in the count, then every task would have an exactly equal chance and there would be no preference for older tasks.
15 January 2014 at 18:39 | Mark Forster
-
I'd imagine the bias toward selecting older tasks is equivalent to a bias toward *starting* tasks rather than *completing* tasks. How does it work out in actual practice?
16 January 2014 at 6:22 | Seraphim
-
"Note that the first two tasks Email and Paper have had four opportunities to be selected (at 50%, 33.33%, and 25% odds), then Tax Return has had two opportunities at 33% and 25% respectively, while Invoicing has only had one opportunity at 25% odds."
While that's true, it's a common fallacy to believe that this means there is bias to selecting them. The fact that they are still present means they weren't selected in previous random selections, therefore they cannot be counted towards any advantage. All that matters is their chance of being selected on the next selection, which is equal to the chance of anything else present being selected.
The only way to create an advantage for selected tasks is to bias the selector towards them. One method might be each time the selector is used the remaining tasks are represented by an additional copy in the list (which could be a virtual copy by simply writing the next available line number next to them so if the selector picks 3 or 33 that is the same task. On the next selection 3, 33 or 37 would select it and so on).
By the same reasoning I should do the same lottery numbers every week so they increasingly have more opportunities to be selected and win me some money. The fact that so many people do exactly this shows how common the fallacy is.
16 January 2014 at 13:55 | Chris
-
Chris, I also pondered whether this is a fallacy, and I don't think it is. It isn't the same situation as the lottery. In any one trial, every task has an equal chance of being selected - older tasks do not have a higher probability - you are right about that. But if you look at the results over 10 trials (for example), and make a list of the 10 tasks that got selected, you would find that tasks that were on the list for more of those trials appeared in the selected results more often.
16 January 2014 at 15:09 | Seraphim
-
See sample spreadsheet here:
http://www.dropbox.com/s/77rvirdv7ltk2yu/task%20prob.xlsxRow 18 uses the formula =RANDBETWEEN(1,COUNTA(K2:K16)) to select a task from the list in rows 2:16. When it selects the task, I then replace the formula with the chosen random number, and then decide whether to take the task off the list (completed) or let it ride (recurring or unfinished). I think it illustrates Mark's point that a task that remains on the list has a nonzero chance of being selected again. It actually worked out this way in this example, where "check email" was selected 3 times in 9 trials, at which point I deleted it because I figured I'd be done clearing out my email by then. :-)
16 January 2014 at 15:25 | Seraphim
-
Chris said: "While that's true, it's a common fallacy to believe that this means there is bias to selecting them."
It's only a fallacy if the initial selections are considered to have already been made. Before any selections are made, it's perfectly valid, and that was Mark's point. You put what you want to do soon on the list first, when there are only two items, because at that point there is a strong likelihood that they will be done soon, as opposed to the likelihood that you will do something soon that you haven't added yet.
To illustrate this, the chance of getting two heads in a row when tossing a penny is 1/4 if I haven't tossed either penny yet, but it's 1/2 if I've already tossed one head, and 0 if I've already tossed one tail.
16 January 2014 at 20:22 | Austin
-
One only needs to look at Mark's percentages to see that he didn't make the fallacy referenced here. If he were making the fallacy, then he would have used a larger number than 25% to describe the chance of getting an item on the list when there are four items, since that item was on there longer. But he used 25% -- an equal probability for older tasks as for any other task.
16 January 2014 at 20:27 | Austin
-
The system Mark described, where if you land on a crossed-off line you do the next one gives more emphasis to the ones after crossed-off lines.
<<I use the randomizer to produce a number and move forward that number of spaces (onto the next page if necessary). I INCLUDE lines which have been crossed out in the count - this is important.>>
The task immediately after a crossed-off task has twice the chance of being done.
1
2
3
4
5x
6
7
8
9
10
Role between 1 and 10. If you get a 5 or a 6, you do #6.
1
2
3x
4
5x
6x
7
8
9x
10
Now 4 and 9 have two chances each, and 7 has three. #1 has nothing in front of it to be scratched off, so it will never get that boost.
Some easy ways to solve this:
As Mark suggested, roll a larger die, so crossing-off #10 gives #1 a boost.
Skip the crossed-off lines.
If you land on a crossed-off line, go to the one before it. That way 2 and 8 have twice the probability, and 4 has three times. Pretty soon, 2 and 4 will be crossed-off, and #1 will get five times the probability.
++++
Going back to rolling for page, then line number, on a list that's normally done with AF1. Lines on pages with fewer active lines will get chosen more often. That might be a good thing. Those lines have been already been put off many times.
16 January 2014 at 20:40 | Cricket
-
Seraphim:
<< I'd imagine the bias toward selecting older tasks is equivalent to a bias toward *starting* tasks rather than *completing* tasks. How does it work out in actual practice? >>
No not really. By the end of the day the two starting task on my sample list, Email and Paper, will have been present in every throw throughout the day. That means they stand a good chance of being selected several times, even though the odds lengthen as the day goes on against their being selected on any particular throw.
16 January 2014 at 23:16 | Mark Forster
-
Chris:
<< While that's true, it's a common fallacy to believe that this means there is bias to selecting them. The fact that they are still present means they weren't selected in previous random selections, therefore they cannot be counted towards any advantage. All that matters is their chance of being selected on the next selection, which is equal to the chance of anything else present being selected.>>
I said that the tasks would remain on the list for as long as work was needed on them, which in the case of Email and probably Paper would be all day. If there were 50 throws during the day the advantage they would get from being present for 50 throws as compared to another task which was only present for 10 throws would be considerable, even if the odds were the same for every throw - which they are not.
16 January 2014 at 23:22 | Mark Forster
-
The system which I described yesterday (January 15, 2014 at 18:39) is working extremely well.
I've made one amendment. It relates to when the randomizer takes one to a crossed out task, and you move to the next active task. I call that a "slide". My amendment is that if a slide takes one to the end of the page, then you continue the slide from the top of the SAME page.
The reason I made this amendment was that I realized that the first task on the first page was at a disadvantage under my original rules because it could not be "slid" to from another page.
One amendment I'm thinking of making is to mark tasks which need to be done quickly or several times a day - I'd use a dot but anything will do. Then use the randomizer to select a task in the usual way but if there are any marked-up tasks in the gap between the selected task and the previously actioned task, then these tasks should be done before the selected one. Marking up tasks in this way should be done extremely sparingly.
I'm amazed at how well this system is working (even without the possible amendment). The randomness takes away all the procrastination element - which is much bigger than I'd realized. And the random numbers never cease to surprise me - they don't behave in the way I would instinctively expect at all.
16 January 2014 at 23:39 | Mark Forster
-
Cricket:
<< Going back to rolling for page, then line number, on a list that's normally done with AF1. Lines on pages with fewer active lines will get chosen more often. That might be a good thing. Those lines have been already been put off many times. >>
Lines haven't been "put off" in the sense we'd put something off. They just haven't been selected. The randomizer is completely indifferent to what tasks it selects.
Just to illustrate how it works, my first page (started yesterday) now has four tasks left on it. These tasks are on lines 1, 2, 5 and 9 of a 32-line page.
There are 24 lines on the page (1, 10-32) which if they were landed on would result in line 1 being selected. There is only one line on the page which would result in line 2 being selected, but if line 1 were to be selected then on the next throw there would be 25 lines on the page (1, 2 10-32) which would result in line 2 being selected.
It's quite feasible that all four tasks would be selected before the randomizer moves off the page.
Afternote:
I just missed clearing all four tasks off page 1. I threw a 27 from the last page which took me to line 22 on the first page, from where I slid to line 1. Then 5 came up and I slid to line 9. I then threw a 2 and slid all around the page to line 2. Only two numbers (31 and 32) would have prevented me from hitting line 5, the only unactioned line left. Of course I threw 31 which took me off the page.
Next time I hit that page there is a 100% change of dealing with that one remaining task.
Tally after 2 days on the system:
Page 1 - 1 task remaining
Page 2 - 0
Page 3 - 8
Page 4 - 19
Page 5 - 22
Page 6 - 26
Page 7 - 14 (of 16)
16 January 2014 at 23:57 | Mark Forster
-
Hi Mark
Totaling your tasks for 2 days is a staggering 130 tasks! Even if I low balled the computation at 10 minutes per task, that's over 10 hours per day! Each task is randomly chosen. What if you have a few projects that require more than 10 minutes of concentration at a time. If you chose a few tasks that you spent an hour or two working on, that would bring your day totals to well over 10 hours a day. This can't be your everyday working hours! I can rack up 12-13 hours but it's usually only a few projects taking the bulk of my time and effort. I don't think I've EVER completed 130 tasks in two days. I don't complete that many in an entire week! LOL! In fact, I only work 10-12 hours when I'm overloaded by outside circumstances. I never voluntarily pile that much time and effort on my back unless it's ONE passion project that's swept me into a trance. What's your secret? Or are you front-loading your week to free up the weekend?
130 tasks in 2 days? Doesn't all that switching scramble up your focus and determination to complete particular jobs? Even before my brain damage I didn't have that amount of control over my brain to switch gears 60 times during a work session. My hat's off to you! What's your secret?
17 January 2014 at 15:15 | learning as I go
-
learning:
I should think that's about right. 10 mins is an average. Some of the tasks take much longer than that, some no time at all (e.g. they just get crossed out because there's nothing to do). I use the system for everything - not just work.
18 January 2014 at 2:07 | Mark Forster
-
This system continues to amaze me. I've got some really sticky tasks done today, including my tax return - for once it hasn't been left to the last minute!
Tally after 3 days on the system:
Page 1 - 0 tasks remaining
Page 2 - 0
Page 3 - 0
Page 4 - 6
Page 5 - 6
Page 6 - 17
Page 7 - 18
Page 9 - 27
Page 10 - 12 (of 12)
You can clearly see the effect of the emphasis on the older pages. After three days there are only 6 left of the 128 tasks I entered on day 1. The lack of resistance caused by the random selection has also made my work much faster. And the list has shrunk rather than expanded - there are only 87 tasks in it at the moment, compared with 90 at the end of Day 2.
The really amazing thing is that there is nothing that I feel behind on. There's not really even anything I feel I would like to have processed a bit faster. It's just got everything done, without fuss and without stress and, as Learning has pointed out above, the "everything" I've got done has been huge.
18 January 2014 at 2:19 | Mark Forster
-
This thread is getting too long to be manageable. I'm going to close it now. I'm opening a new thread on the same subject as I think there's more to say on the subject - which I at least am finding very interesting.
New thread at:
http://markforster.squarespace.com/forum/post/2275650 18 January 2014 at 10:37 | Mark Forster