-
My trouble with all the "common sense" rules is when they get triggered too often.
If I have one or two items that are governed by "common sense", then I can keep track of how to handle them. They are just one or two exceptions -- no big deal.
Maybe even 3 or 4 would be OK.
But when the number starts to climb, I suddenly no longer have a system. And personally I find that I work best with a real, consistent *system*. Even if it's just Gerry's simple "write it all in one place" system.
Actually, whenever AF1 broke down for me, I used Gerry's approach as a fallback. I just processed the same list but didn't really use any rules. And then, after the crisis of the day subsided, I could try to get back to actually following the AF rules. The problem was, I got sloppier and sloppier over time, till the days I was actually using the rules were the exception and the random cherry-picking was the rule. And I lost all feeling for the intuitive aspect of AF.
That's what I am afraid of with SF, if I need to play the "common sense" card too often. I want the rules to WORK, 99% of the time. SF gets pretty close. I am trying to think of how to work it properly, so it really does achieve that. Mark's absence is forcing me to think through it all myself, which is fun and challenging.
2 March 2011 at 2:27 | Seraphim
-
This is indeed a challenge, for me too. My suggestion: when chaos arrives, do what you have to when you have to. As soon as there's no "have to", immediately go back to the system.
2 March 2011 at 3:20 | Alan Baljeu
-
<<As soon as there's no "have to", immediately go back to the system. >>
If I understand SF correctly, column 2 was designed to do just that i.e. "have to". My problem is simple: If I get stuff done sans system, I think to myself: "Feh, I got stuff done without gtd/af/gsd/SF/7 Habits.... and I'm back to square 1 (that being, oscillating between Quad 1 and Quad 2 activity).
2 March 2011 at 3:25 | avrum
-
"Feh, I got stuff done without "
maybe I'm too simplistic, but I suggest your problem is precisely thinking that. It seems you know it yourself too. The solution then is, don't think that :-)
Sure you got away with it an hour or a day, but you need turn back to the "path" before you get lost.
2 March 2011 at 4:31 | Alan Baljeu
-
Alan wrote:
<< As soon as there's no "have to", immediately go back to the system. >>
That's the problem. It starts to build resistance. It's not so easy to "immediately go back".
When I'm working off-system, I am chasing the most urgent thing. After awhile, I chase whatever happens to be moving the fastest or has the brightest colors, masquerading as urgent. I get tired and fuzzy-minded and don't WANT to go back to a system. Just can't handle it. The chaos has worn me out, the cherry-picking has broken all my intuition and I am just NOT anywhere near "the zone" or the "mind like water". Trying to figure out what task is "standing out" just seems too hard -- my mind puts up resistance to it.
And that resistance grows. Making it harder to get back into the system. Especially when I know the system isn't as reliable as I'd like it to be. I want to TRUST it. But when I have to invoke the "common sense" rule too many times, what does that mean, but that I can't really trust the system? It needs so many "common sense" overrides to make it work when the road becomes difficult.
This is why I keep asking about the rules and how they apply in a particular situation. They might seem like edge-cases to some, but for me they are real situations. I need to know I can trust the system, that I can follow its rules and it will work just fine in these situations, 99% of the time.
2 March 2011 at 6:01 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim, I'd really be interested with a concrete example of how you work the system... Some scans of your pages or a Skype conversation. I found the rules really clear and self reliant. I encountered the least resistance to tasks with SF3. I honestly have a hard time seeing how it can be so difficult in any environment. Could you share some insight from your perspective with actual concrete examples?
2 March 2011 at 7:04 | Erik
-
Hi Erik,
The rules are clear. My problem is always the volume of tasks I am dealing with. In Autofocus I typically had over 1200 tasks across 30+ pages. In DWM I also leveled off at about 1200 tasks. (DWM worked pretty well with this actually...) With SF it's stayed smaller, longer, but it still hasn't leveled off. Part of this is being overcommitted both at home and at work. Part of it is I like to explore and still imagine that the Internet is finite. :-) (Mark's systems have cured me of quite a lot of these problems already, but the tendency is still there!)
The main issue is when I find I am processing pages more slowly than I am adding new ones. The last page gets further and further away.
Here's how a typical page works for me. Let's say I have 2 or 3 unfinished tasks I am trying to move forward. One major one, one or two medium ones. Then I get hit with 5 or 6 urgent tasks that must be done within the next few hours (phone call from boss, coworkers, urgent meeting that generated urgent action items, wife needs help with picking up the kids or something, Outlook reminder reminds me to do this or that daily recurring task, etc.). The last page is about 4 or 5 pages away -- well outside the range I could expect to reach in a few hours. Thus almost all those tasks all go in Column 2, current page.
So I keep cycling through my current page, following the "standing out" rules. I take action on the urgent tasks, finishing most in one go, but one or two need to be moved along to the next page. Meanwhile I have a phone meeting or two (there goes an hour or more!); then I often need to take the minutes for these and send them out, which also become urgent tasks.
Many C1 tasks get actioned along the way, since I am cycling through and working on whatever stands out. When I first came to this page, almost none of those items stood out. But I find that the more urgent tasks I add, the more time I spend on the page, cycling through. And that repeated cycling breaks down resistance to the C1 tasks -- "get it done already!" So, many of these get actioned, many completed, maybe 1 or 2 passed along to the next page.
LOTS of work is getting done. But I spend lots of time on each page. Combined with the meetings, going through this one page can easily take 2-4 hours.
So, I finally come to the next page. There's already half a dozen items in C2 -- many still urgent and relatively small, plus some larger items, and usually only 1 really large item. I follow the rules: quickly read through the whole list, then start back at the beginning and take action on whatever stands out. Usually there are at least 1 or 2 C1 items that are already completed -- I just cross them out (which happens to save the whole page from dismissal). The other C1 items usually don't draw any of my attention -- it's the C2 items that do. So, I work on them, one after another, usually finishing many of them, but maybe some of them getting moved along to the next page. (I just follow the rule, "work as long as you want to".)
Then, there's another meeting. And another urgent reminder. (Some of the urgent things are Outlook reminders of tasks that need to be done daily -- and I really LOVE how SF handles them!) And then an urgent request from someone at work, or maybe from my wife.
On a typical visit to a page, C2 usually already has 4-6 urgent tasks that resulted from Outlook reminders, and another 1-3 urgent tasks that come up while processing the page, and then 1-3 unfinished carry over items.
Overall I love how it flows, I love how much I get done, and I am happy to keep working my list from when I get up till way past the time I should be in bed. It really does keep you "in the zone" -- by definition, actually.
Again, the main issue is when I find I am processing pages more slowly than I am adding new ones. The last page gets further and further away. I start to lose track of what's in my list -- especially older pages that I visited several days ago. I don't know when this process will end -- will my list of tasks grow indefinitely? Or will it reach an equilibrium?
DWM *forces* an equilibrium -- and that worked great for me. I really got a sense of the size of my total workload, and whether it was getting to be too much, or whether it was OK for me to take on something new.
AF never did that. And so far, I don't see SF doing that. It just keeps growing.
Ideally, I'd want to see pages being completed faster than they are added -- this means I am clearing backlogs -- and then eventually I'd want to see an equilibrium established, where the total number of open pages stays about the same from day to day. I think I could do that, if I could move more quickly through the pages.
That's why I am trying (starting tomorrow) to enter urgent items on NEXT page, C2 -- Mark said this made it go too fast for him. But that's exactly what I need right now.
2 March 2011 at 7:55 | Seraphim
-
I've been lurking a long time but ony just joined the forum. Ive read a lot of what you've been saying Seraphim and one thing struck me. I hope you wont mind me saying so.
Youve identified the problem yourself. Its nothing to do with SF3 or any other system. You can fiddle all you like with the system, but the systems not the problme.
Youre overcommitted. That's your problem. Not the system. Do you really expect a system to sort that out for you?
Go through your 1200 tasks and cut it down by 9/10. Remember what Mark says in DIT Don't cut tasks on their own. Cut commitments. And when you've done it don't let any new ones in without getting rid of an old one.
2 March 2011 at 8:59 | Meryl
-
@Seraphim: I agree with Meryl 100% (again, see another topic, great minds think alike, fools seldom . . . oops, Roger, stop the sarcasm NOW!)
Perhaps because I have found myself overwhelmed by the sheer volume of outstanding tasks sometimes, I empathise with you.
Perhaps you do need to set aside a quiet time and place on your own and go through the active tasks, maybe in blocks of 50.
For really dramatic effect, ask yourself what would happen to other people in your life if you were physically unable to do each task, due to context/illness/other reasons or death (!). If a task has a perceived nil or minimal effect, then dismiss or delete it.
For other that may have an impact or if you're unsure, transfer these to a separate list (I call mine 'LTBW' = 'Let The B*****d Wait'), then just put in eg LTBW in your active and now shorter task list and revisit this separate list from time to time, maybe as a 'break'.
It's similar to reviewing dismissed tasks, or a project with lots of individual tasks.
2 March 2011 at 11:35 | Roger J
-
You know, if you just get through the list a couple times, the pages are shorter and you'll pick up fewer things. But I see that 6 urgent items really messes up the whole flow. The system would be better if you ignored it to process those urgent items because there's so many.
As for resistance to returning, I feel that too, and my remedy is Mark's "I'll just take out the book". Then I "just" scan the active page. Scan again. And again. Now I'm in the mood for one thing, do it, carry on. And take it as a "must do" to take out the book.
2 March 2011 at 13:31 | Alan Baljeu
-
Hmmm, Meryl beat me to it.
You are DEFINITELY overcommitting but...
There is a solution that I have found in your use of the system.
I might take this out of context so excuse me for pointing it if it is but there are 3 things I think would help a lot and all of them are linked to dismissing. Taking tasks is ok, the system should filter out overcommitment easily by dismissing. That's why it's there for.
First: Learn or re-learn to dismiss. Dismissing doesn't mean you won't get to it at some point, it only means you have to re-assess your priorities and commitments (one thing done for overcommitting ;)
Second: You are probably using more common sense then rules then most people. Let me explain: If you get to a page and cross off C1 stuff because it was done earlier and simply work on C2 stuff then you HAVE to dismiss that entire page, period. You haven't worked on a C1 task on your pass of the page... Since you dismiss, you are relieving overcommitting again ;)
You are basically using your intuition to do that stuff that was crossed at a more opportune moment which is good but not using the "rules" of the system (hence my saying that you use more common sense then probably most people do). The system is there to balance the relative difficulties/commitments of the tasks by page increments allowing the alleviation of procrastination by comparing one task with another on that list/page. And to finally leave you with all the stuff you are not really committed to or haven't well defined and having to dismiss it... for now. You seem to often do stuff that is not even on the current page, using your better judgment on what the situation is at the moment. All good, but diluting the cycling through the pages.
Third: Often, some things on a page will stand out but you know theres more important stuff on a later page so my advice is that you do one task and move on. Later you'll come back and that stuff will be past due so not necessary to do anymore, guess what you just alleviated overcommitting again ;) If you don't have variation in task difficulties, everything will seem urgent. Give it 1 hour by putting it at the end of your list and you'll see the world won't stop turning.
It's simple, your pages should get dismissed as fast as you put stuff in.
Tell us what you think?
2 March 2011 at 13:43 | Erik
-
Seraphim - you said - DWM *forces* an equilibrium -- and that worked great for me. I really got a sense of the size of my total workload, and whether it was getting to be too much, or whether it was OK for me to take on something new.
It sounds to me like DWM worked better for you than SF is. Why not go back to DWM?
2 March 2011 at 14:23 | Lillian
-
But this is ridiculous. If the solution to Seraphims problem is to dismiss half of what he puts in his list, then u have to ask why he's putting so much on his list that he doesnt need to do. And the same with DWM. Whats all this stuff that hes puting on his list that gets dismissed? Why's it a good thing it gets dismissed? Because he didnt need to do it in the first place thats why.
What he wants is a system that will allow him to put even more on the list so even more can get dismissed. Well to my mind thats just crazy. No offense intended.
2 March 2011 at 15:10 | Meryl
-
@Lillian: Good question. DWM is a good answer to the ever expanding list. Mine is a steady 50 to 90 tasks long. I follow the SF threads and have tried it a couple of times but keep going back to DWM.
2 March 2011 at 15:20 | Laurence
-
@Meryl
Me thinks it's a personality thing. Some people just NEED to have the freedom to think they can try to do any and everything they think about, or else they just feel too limited and get frustrated with their life, which can lead to impaired creativity, and maybe even loss of joie de vivre, and depression ?
Yes, everybody SHOULD be a realist, but not everybody is able to (without eventually feeling alienated).
So maybe, for creative / idealist types, DWM would be the better system by letting them "dream on" while still keeping them honest, vs SF which would inflict the dreaded "column 2 pain" as "punishment" for being such an "irresponsible" person (which would end up making them feel miserable) ?
These are just thoughts that popped out without much consideration, I haven't even tryed either system yet...
2 March 2011 at 15:26 | Daouda
-
Well if youll excuse me saying so Daouda if hes got to put down every thing he thinks about and its so important for his creative whatnots, then what does it really matter what he does? I mean he could just do anything or nothing couldnt he?
I think hed be better off keeping SF3 for the real world. The things which he really has to do. Then he can go off and do his fantasy stuff as much as he likes - but he doesnt need a system for that does he>
2 March 2011 at 16:10 | Meryl
-
Seraphim,
I don't think any system will fix the issue of over commitment. Time management systems will not limit your commitments, pick your priorities nor will they make you work faster - only you can do these things. If the rule says you need to dismiss something because you have not worked on it, but you know it needs to get done you are at a logjam.
I think the overhang of systems and rules may be a drag on your productivity and major distraction for you.
I would suggest you stick to "write it all in one place" for a week or two, let your mind be your guide and forget everything else. Then see what you really need in the way of a system. Good luck
Gerry
2 March 2011 at 16:25 | Gerry
-
Meryl
I was rather talking about myself there, because although I havent used SF3 yet Im pretty sure I would run into the same problems (overcommitment related) that Seraphim is currently confronted to. But it might not be for the same reasons : from what Ive read, Seraphim is probably more of a responsible person that I am and his problem could rather be related to (as Alan stated it) "Lots of interruptions, little free time".
The result is still the same however : "overcommitment", and the REAL solution also is the same : be more realistic about what you assign yourself to do.
That being said, after reading your last post, Im not sure you would be able to understand the time (or rather life) management issues of the "creative/idealist" people I was talking about :
The "creative whatnots" and "fantasy stuff", as you put it, that these people come up with, NEED to be adressed by the system so they can get a chance to become a part of the "real world". This is the very reason these people are living for... a life filled with nothing but doing the most mundane stuff, or just the stuff they "really have to do", is not worth living for them. As I said, it's a personality thing.
Anyway looking back at my post i realize I expressed myself clumsily :
The good thing about DWM seems to be that it forces people to be more honest with their commitments : simply following the rules takes care of PREVENTING overcommitment.
On the other hand, follwing the rules of SF3 does not prevent overcommitment, but the system will eventually "crash" if one doesnt prevent overcommiting BY HIMSELF.
It seems like the "chronic overcommitter" (which are often creative/idealist types) can find a cure to his bad habits in DWM, while SF would only make him feel miserable not be be able to make such a sensible system work.
2 March 2011 at 16:51 | Daouda
-
Im sure I'm not capable of understanding anything Daouda. But it seems common sense to me that the worst place to write down all your creative/idealistic stuff is on the list of things youre going to do. If you want to build castles in the air then the air is the place to build them.
Some other guy was talking about Tolstoy on another thread. I guess he was about as creative/idealistic as you can get but I bet he spent his time writing his novels, not inventing another million things he could do but would never get round to.
2 March 2011 at 17:06 | Meryl
-
Im sorry Meryl, but I just can't get past the condescending tone in your posts.
"It seems common sense to me", "Isnt it obvious", "creative whatnots" "fantasy stuff", and now "castles in the air"; your advices might be wise, but let me tell you that the way you write them wont make the people who need it most receptive to them. Bottom line, not helpful at all.
2 March 2011 at 17:14 | Daouda
-
"Youre overcommitted. That's your problem. Not the system. Do you really expect a system to sort that out for you? "
The answer is to this is yes. In fact SF3 is not intended for the things you will do, but only the things you might do. They aren't commitments at all! SF does balance your work, eventually reaching the following equilibrium:
new stuff - stuff finished = stuff dismissed.
In Seraphim's case, new stuff grows too fast, and we need to reduce that or accelerate dismissal. If there's a lot of duplication, maybe altering the system to get around to stuff faster will suffice. Certainly getting around faster will turn on the column 2 dismissal rule quicker.
Also having more urgent stuff will turn on that rule quicker. And maybe that fact should be considered a good thing, same as the DWM waterfall is a good thing, and not be fought against.
2 March 2011 at 17:37 | Alan Baljeu
-
Thanks for everyone's replies! It's fun getting so much attention. :-)
Meryl wrote:
<< Youre overcommitted. That's your problem. Not the system. >>
You are absolutely correct!!
<< Do you really expect a system to sort that out for you? >>
Actually, yes I do. Mark always said his AF series of systems can help do that, and I found myself that DWM was especially effective at it. I specifically asked him if SF could do this, and he said he thought it could -- at least that was his experience at the time. Mark is (woefully) familiar with the magnitude of my overcommitment problem, but I think it still surprises him sometimes how I am able to overwhelm his systems. :-)
2 March 2011 at 17:47 | Seraphim
-
Roger J wrote:
<< Perhaps because I have found myself overwhelmed by the sheer volume of outstanding tasks sometimes, I empathise with you. >>
Thanks Roger for all the suggestions. Actually I do this kind of reflection regularly, alone, and/or with my wife. And I do have some health issues that stop my in my tracks sometimes.
I have gotten a lot better at preventing hare-brained ideas from getting on the list in the first place. Most of what's on the list does need to get done sometime, or is at least related to projects that need to get done. Sometimes they are just ideas, brainstorms, related to my commitments, and these often get dismissed or deleted.
Anyway, thanks again!!
2 March 2011 at 17:51 | Seraphim
-
Alan Baljeu wrote:
<< The system would be better if you ignored it to process those urgent items because there's so many. >>
But then I've got to write them down somewhere else. A sticky note will do. But then I lose the sticky note, or I start to accumulate them on the sides of my computer monitor, or stuck in the back of my SF book. And then I start to get anxious. Normally when I'm anxious I just turn to my SF book, and start working, and the anxiety goes away. But in this case, the tasks that are making me anxious aren't even written down there.
Anyway, in short: Been there, done that. :-) It doesn't work for me. I need to have everything in one place.
<< As for resistance to returning, I feel that too, and my remedy is Mark's "I'll just take out the book". >>
Yeah, that works pretty well for me too. :-)
2 March 2011 at 17:55 | Seraphim
-
Erik wrote:
<< First: Learn or re-learn to dismiss. >>
Actually this is working pretty well. It's been working GREAT since I observed Mark dismissing a bunch of stuff just because he had the flu. I had always operated my list without rules, if I was sick. Mark using dismissal when he didn't feel well enough to do the tasks was a revelation to me. Dismissal is a GREAT tool and I love how it works.
<< Second: You are probably using more common sense then rules then most people. Let me explain: If you get to a page and cross off C1 stuff because it was done earlier and simply work on C2 stuff then you HAVE to dismiss that entire page, period. >>
Actually this has been discussed in the past, and if I remember correctly, Mark said it didn't really matter if you count those as completions or not, for sake of dismissal. For me it functions as a simple straightforward rule.
Just because the items were completed early doesn't mean they were done outside the system. Sometimes the items in question were completed earlier because they were entered more than once in the list (Mark says not to worry about this, don't waste time trying to track down the duplicate entries). Or maybe because they became urgent and got done in C2 somewhere. (Mark says not to worry about tracking down the duplicate entries in that case, too.)
<< Third: Often, some things on a page will stand out but you know theres more important stuff on a later page so my advice is that you do one task and move on. >>
A rule like that would force me to look over all the things on the page, and prioritize among them. I like Mark's "standing out" process better. It produces less anxiety. And if I am familiar with the contents of my list, the "standing out" process takes into account the contents of other pages. If I am NOT familiar with my list, I can enter an urgent item to review it.
<< Give it 1 hour by putting it at the end of your list and you'll see the world won't stop turning. >>
It generally takes me a lot longer than an hour to get to the end of my list.
<< It's simple, your pages should get dismissed as fast as you put stuff in. >>
Yes, exactly, that's the end goal. The problem I am trying to avoid is an ever-growing list. The problem is making that happen simply by following the rules.
2 March 2011 at 18:11 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim,
You are certainly a valued member of this forum and no one can critique someone else's list without seeing it.
But 1200 tasks is going to strike a lot of people as too many. If you action one task every 2 minutes, it would take 40 hours to finish all the tasks. If you replace them as often as you work through the list, you would have to action and add about 240 every day (eight hours a day).
Even if many of these are sometime/maybe, it is still an awful lot of items to sift through every day. You indicate that you would have trouble keeping up with everything if they are not on the list, but it has got to be hard to keep from losing items that are on the list itself simply due to its shere size.
We don't participate in these forums only to find help, but to guide others. If the system is succeeding or failing for someone, it helps to know the circumstances. SF v.3 works well for me, but then again I have six open pages with only 44 open tasks and currently two in column two. I am using this at home and do not face many really urgent tasks, so it is easy for me. I see SF as little more than AF 1 with an added pop. SF will be a completely different situation for someone with hundreds of tasks, a disorganized boss, and less discrecionary time. My suggestions may not apply. If the system is not working as well for you, it is important that we sift through your circumstances to some extent, even if it seems cruel, because it is important to note what is and is not causing the problem as a means of maybe guiding someone who is absolutely new to this whole web site.
2 March 2011 at 18:15 | Chris
-
"If you get to a page and cross off C1 stuff because it was done earlier and simply work on C2 stuff then you HAVE to dismiss that entire page, period."
I didn't follow whether in practice you agree or disagree with this. My notion is that moving forward is important, and dismissing is valuable, So I think I would suggest to not count previously done stuff, but I'm not sure.
2 March 2011 at 18:19 | Alan Baljeu
-
Well, Seraphim, I did read some of what Mark and you talked about the system, and my memory is that he didn't say that the system could deal with tons and tons of irrelevant stuff being thrown at it. My memory is that he said that the system would seize up if people abused it and that would help to cure people of abusing it. Which sort of comes back to what I was saying.
2 March 2011 at 18:19 | Meryl
-
<<
<< Third: Often, some things on a page will stand out but you know theres more important stuff on a later page so my advice is that you do one task and move on. >>
A rule like that would force me to look over all the things on the page, and prioritize among them. I like Mark's "standing out" process better. It produces less anxiety. And if I am familiar with the contents of my list, the "standing out" process takes into account the contents of other pages. If I am NOT familiar with my list, I can enter an urgent item to review it.>>
Has anybody tryed 2mc (Matt) AF1 "flagged tasks" tweak on SF3 yet ? It precisely adressed that issue and brought up other benefits as well.. I think it looked brilliant and I plan to try it
2 March 2011 at 18:19 | Daouda
-
Seraphim wrote:
<<But then I've got to write them down somewhere else. A sticky note will do. But then I lose the sticky note, or I start to accumulate them on the sides of my computer monitor, or stuck in the back of my SF book. And then I start to get anxious. Normally when I'm anxious I just turn to my SF book, and start working, and the anxiety goes away. But in this case, the tasks that are making me anxious aren't even written down there.>>
IMHO, it's great to write everything down as long as I don't try to do everything I've written down.
Everything is input, but not every input is a commitment.
Perhaps you should write stuff down and then dismiss it after you have written it down, regard it as a simple note and not as a commitment.
2 March 2011 at 18:31 | Rainer
-
Lillian wrote:
<< It sounds to me like DWM worked better for you than SF is. Why not go back to DWM? >>
Actually SF is working even better, and I REALLY like the AF-like flow (which DWM didn't really have).
I'm just trying to see if there can be any very simple adjustment(s) to the rules that would help the C2 congestion and ever-growing list problems to self-correct.
2 March 2011 at 18:31 | Seraphim
-
edit: what I was saying was already covered. Ignore.
2 March 2011 at 18:33 | Don R
-
Meryl wrote:
<< But this is ridiculous. If the solution to Seraphims problem is to dismiss half of what he puts in his list, then u have to ask why he's putting so much on his list that he doesnt need to do. >>
I don't dismiss/delete THAT much stuff. Most of those 1200 tasks DO get worked on, many of them get regularly completed.
That's not the problem.
The problem is there doesn't seem to be a mechanism in SF to prevent unending growth of the list. The mechanics of SF do seem to keep the overall list much shorter, more compact, more nimble, and that's great!! But the list does still seem to be growing too fast. I'm still exploring the dynamics of the system to figure out if there's a simple way to get it to self-correct and stop that kind of growth, to balance out somehow, achieving the same sense of equilibrium that DWM provided.
2 March 2011 at 18:46 | Seraphim
-
Gerry,
<< If the rule says you need to dismiss something because you have not worked on it, but you know it needs to get done you are at a logjam. >>
Actually dismissal doesn't work like that, in my experience at least. Dismissed tasks get reviewed, and if I find an important commitment among my dismissed tasks then I know I need to think about why that happened. That helps me re-negotiate my commitments, evaluate my project systems, cancel appointments, whatever is needed.
I was always afraid of dismissing tasks like that -- what if I missed an important deadline??? But if the review happens regularly (which it does for me) then I can make sure I don't miss deadlines.
<< I think the overhang of systems and rules may be a drag on your productivity and major distraction for you. >>
Well, yes, if the rules involve frequent "common sense" overrides. But if the rules remain simple, like with SF, then they are a major support and help.
Thanks for your suggestions! Your ideas are always very sensible.
2 March 2011 at 18:51 | Seraphim
-
Daouda -
<< The good thing about DWM seems to be that it forces people to be more honest with their commitments : simply following the rules takes care of PREVENTING overcommitment.
On the other hand, follwing the rules of SF3 does not prevent overcommitment, but the system will eventually "crash" if one doesnt prevent overcommiting BY HIMSELF.>>
Yes, exactly! You've captured the difference very succinctly.
2 March 2011 at 18:53 | Seraphim
-
Chris wrote:
<< 1200 tasks is going to strike a lot of people as too many. >>
Yeah, I get that a lot. LOL!
2 March 2011 at 19:04 | Seraphim
-
Rainer wrote:
<< Perhaps you should write stuff down and then dismiss it after you have written it down, regard it as a simple note and not as a commitment. >>
Yes, as someone else (Alan?) wrote earlier in the thread, entries in the list are not "will do" items but "maybe do" items.
Some of the urgent stuff I write down does occasionally get crossed off without me doing anything. For example, my wife and I discuss 5 things that need to be done right now. I write them all down. While working on them, my wife comes back and says she did XXX herself, so I can cross it off. Or she tells me that something has changed, so we can delete it. Or I realize it isn't really urgent after all, so it's "DONE FOR NOW" and gets moved to end of list, C1.
2 March 2011 at 19:08 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim you said "Or I realize it isn't really urgent after all, so it's "DONE FOR NOW" and gets moved to end of list, C1"
Just curious, are you using the list as a tickler? I mean, is this 'done for now' something that will likely be ready to be done by the time you get to it again, or is it 'a done for now, and can wait until April but I don't want to forget about it" item? If it's the latter, have you tried having a future-tickler page at the end of the book (to keep things together) and check that list once a week -ish?
2 March 2011 at 19:17 | Lillian
-
Seraphim
Slighltly off the most current topic :
1200 tasks indeed sounds like a LOT... You said that DWM worked great for you by limiting your commitments through dismissals... Sounds like you were expecting -consciously or not, out of a DWM-built habit - SF to do the same ?
Maybe you should approach SF radically differently that you did DWM, and make use of a "someday/maybe" list, reviewed regularly, on the side?
Maybe DWM is simply the best solution for a "chronic overcommiter" such as you ?
Maybe you should face the facts that you are just a regular human being, that life is boring and dull, time is finite, and then cure yourself from your irrealistic overcommitment tendencies (you probably should, as much as myself, but I sure as hell know this approach would NEVER work for me - This just makes me want to sit down in a corner and do nothing. And also, with this kind of thinking, I dont think anybody would ever have contributed with anything extraordinary to this world)
Finally, and this seems to be your rightful quest right now, the SF rules could be appended to make them work as well as DWM in the face of overcommitment !
Im with you on the latter option...
2 March 2011 at 19:29 | Daouda
-
Lillian -
<< have you tried having a future-tickler page at the end of the book >>
Yes, I've been putting more and more things into Outlook reminders to be considered in the future. Sometimes they are very precise things that need to be triggered at a very precise time (calling back a colleague; preparing for a presentation; etc.).
Other times they are things that I just don't want to deal with any time soon but do want to remember for later. These might go into a "read later" list (which almost never gets checked, LOL) or into an Outlook reminder for a month or two from now.
Actually, I really like using "read later" lists that never get checked, and other lists or folders of that sort. They provide the illusion that I am saving something for later, which reduces the anxiety of simply deleting them. But they also reduce my task load since they almost never actually make it back onto my task list. LOL
2 March 2011 at 19:31 | Seraphim
-
Daouda -
<< 1200 tasks indeed sounds like a LOT... You said that DWM worked great for you by limiting your commitments through dismissals... Sounds like you are expecting -consciously or not, out of a DWM-built habit - SF to do the same ? >>
Yes, Mark said he expected SF could help with this -- SF tends to be much more compact than the other list systems and seemed to help limit the total number of tasks. I'm still thinking through the dynamics of why that happens -- because it DOESN'T have an explicit mechanism for this like DWM does.
<< Maybe you should approach SF radically differently that you did DWM, and make use of a "someday/maybe" list, reviewed regularly, on the side? >>
Yes, I am doing more of this with my "read later" lists -- see my last post above, to Lillian.
<< Maybe DWM is simply the best solution for a "chronic overcommiter" such as you ? >>
Maybe, but SF is so much more FUN! :-)
<< Maybe you should face the facts that you are just a regular human being, that life is boring and dull, time is finite, and then cure yourself from your irrealistic overcommitment tendencies. >>
Yeah, I need a Puddleglum to keep me honest. (cf. CS Lewis "The Silver Chair")
I do have that tendency to want to create and explore. But actually those tendencies are not the main problem. There are just lots of things I really must do.
I am always trying to figure out the best ways to get the things done in different ways -- focusing on "high-leverage activities" as they say. For example, delegating! Delegating is pretty fun when there's someone you can delegate to!
<< Finally, and this seems to be your rightful quest right now, the SF rules could be appended to make them work as well as DWM in the face of overcommitment ! >>
That's my hope!
2 March 2011 at 19:38 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim
you wrote
Well, yes, if the rules involve frequent "common sense" overrides. But if the rules remain simple, like with SF, then they are a major support and help.
I have a total opposite view, I personally would never look to a rule to solve a problem for me. I always filter what I do through common sense.
You did not answer my suggestion to try a simpler system. But, another thought would be to make a list of your commitments and review this list trimming it down outside of being in a task management system where you clearly are struggling to keep up. This may shed some clarity on what you really need or want to do.
Additionally, many people have commented that 1200 tasks is quite a bit, can you post some of what is on the list it may be helpful in helping develop solutions.
Gerry
2 March 2011 at 21:48 | Gerry
-
Don't post all 1200 tasks please. ;-) Thought: maybe you need bigger tasks? Then you won't have so many.
2 March 2011 at 22:28 | Alan Baljeu
-
1200 tasks?? You must be joking. Seriously, guy...I run an NIH-funded lab with Post-Docs, graduate students, etc. and serve on NIH Study Sections, author books, manuscripts, teach graduate courses, serve in university administrative roles, and....well....I have NEVER had 1200 tasks in ANY kind of system. My God, man....what are you writing in there?
Seriously, Sepahim....I am only concerned about your sanity. Wow....I thought I was always overwhelmed.
2 March 2011 at 22:46 | David Drake
-
Don't worry, I won't post my task list. I am fine having a long list of tasks. I don't recall asking for help in reducing its size. The only reason I mentioned it is because Erik asked me to describe my list and what's on it and how I typically process it. :-)
My point in opening this thread was not to find help in reducing my number of tasks. Rather, it was to observe that frequent invocation of the "common sense" rule leads to my mind getting muddled and my attention getting unfocused. It also builds resistance to using the system at all. I was wondering if anyone else has had that experience.
When I post questions about how the system is supposed to work, about 80% of the answers are "Good grief, just use common sense!" Do you mean, "Good grief, please go muddle your mind, get unfocused, and build resistance to the system!" Of course not. :-)
Whenever it's Mark who is responding like that to my questions, I know I have just surprised him again with my large load of tasks and how his latest invention is responding to the stress test. But since I am really just asking for his guidance about how he intended the system to work, eventually he responds with great insights and helpful tips.
2 March 2011 at 22:48 | Seraphim
-
Gerry wrote:
<< You did not answer my suggestion to try a simpler system. But, another thought would be to make a list of your commitments and review this list trimming it down outside of being in a task management system where you clearly are struggling to keep up. This may shed some clarity on what you really need or want to do. >>
For me, just capturing everything in one place doesn't provide enough structure. I've tried it many times. It diminishes my sense of focus and creates anxiety. I need more of a system than that. I'd mentioned that elsewhere, which is why I didn't specifically respond to you on that. Sorry!
Yes, reviewing a list of commitments can be helpful. Sometimes I've put a list of them in my list and done some thinking about them whenever they stood out: why is this important / not important, why is this working / not working, etc.
But really, in these various threads I've started, I'm not looking for help in reducing my task load or my commitments. I've been making various observations about aspects of the SF system and asking people if their experience is similar to mine or not.
Right now my main "trouble" is that the list keeps growing. Yes, it comes from my commitments -- I know that. Yes, I have a lot of tasks and a lot of commitments. That's not my problem. DWM handled this workload pretty well, and SF is generally working even better.
My problem is that SF has not yet reached an equilibrium, and I don't see how the dynamics of the system will produce one. I'm trying to see if there are any simple adjustments that can be made to achieve it, without compromising the fundamental rules and "feel" of the system.
2 March 2011 at 22:56 | Seraphim
-
Sorry, Seraphim. I was not trying to be sarcastic. I am just amazed at how many entries you have in your system. You do need a way to trim that down in some manner. I don't think ANY time management system can help you maintain such a list. SF3 may be great, but wow....that is incredible.
Hang in there, guy...
-David
2 March 2011 at 23:13 | David Drake
-
Seraphim,
Not to be argumentative, but if you do not reduce your commitments the only way you get more work done is to work faster. Again I am not sure a system can make you work faster especially if you are using a portion of your time to experiment. Maybe I am missing something here, but it seems as though the expectation of the system may be unrealistic. Good luck
Gerry
2 March 2011 at 23:16 | Gerry
-
Personally, I find it unvaluable to have such an "extreme case" in Seraphim to REALLY stress-test the system. Most of the people here seem to find him almost "crazy", even myself am in awe in front of the 1200 number, but you can be sure someone in the world reading this on the internet can exactly relate to his situation. Seraphim, Im 100% sure you are not alone, and your experiments with the system are eventually gonna be useful to many. I think (hope) that Mark, who probably would never have thought by himself that someone could push his system to such limits, will eventually modify the final instructions in some way to adress the issues that you are exposing. After all, he admitted himself recently that SF is still in the "experimental" phase.
2 March 2011 at 23:30 | Daouda
-
Seraphim, you wrote:
<<And if I am familiar with the contents of my list, the "standing out" process takes into account the contents of other pages. If I am NOT familiar with my list, I can enter an urgent item to review it.
<< Give it 1 hour by putting it at the end of your list and you'll see the world won't stop turning. >>
It generally takes me a lot longer than an hour to get to the end of my list.>>
Do you see the conundrum?
If you are familiar with what's in your list, your intuition is affected and the standing out process helps you move faster through your list. If you are not familiar with what's in your list because it takes too much time to go through, then you put stuff that you remember being important in C2 acerbating your problem of being stuck on a page... The answer is obviously to cycle faster and there are not many solutions.
Also, I'm sorry to say that I still believe you should dismiss the entire page if you didn't work on a C1 item even if you have stricken multiple from having done them earlier. And especially if they where done as being pulled in C2 and done as part of a previous page. You are crippling yourself by pulling them i and not facing up with the consequences. Those 2 things paired are a big wall if used the way you do and a highway if used the way I suggest.
No matter what happens, you'll have to drop stuff so let me ask you this:
Which is the best of these 2 evils?
1 - Going through the list quickly, acting on the most important stuff on each page, being familiar with your stuff, few double entries and dropping the least important?
2 - Pulling stuff forward, not cycling through the list fast enough, doing what is the most important that you can remember off the top of your head and feeling anxious you have left important stuff somewhere else and dropping or simply not finishing in time what was on the pages you didn't get to in time?
I hope this post will be taken in the spirit it is written, I honestly want to give helpful insight. If you feel badgered in any way, please let me know.
3 March 2011 at 0:08 | Erik
-
Ok, I hate to write about Seraphim again (sounds like I'm appointing myself as his attorney) but here I go :
@Gerry :
You wrote
<< if you do not reduce your commitments the only way you get more work done is to work faster. Again I am not sure a system can make you work faster especially if you are using a portion of your time to experiment. >>
Seraphim may correct me later, but dont recall he ever asked SF to help him get MORE work done. He just wants it to KEEP WORKING WELL following the rules ,while still throwing at it the same amount of stuff he used to throw at DWM without any problems. And he most definitely doesnt refuse to "reduce his commitments" since he observed that this is precisely what made DWM work so well for him through its timed dismissal process.
@Erik
<<If you are familiar with what's in your list, your intuition is affected and the standing out process helps you move faster through your list. If you are not familiar with what's in your list because it takes too much time to go through, then you put stuff that you remember being important in C2 acerbating your problem of being stuck on a page... The answer is obviously to cycle faster and there are not many solutions.>>
I wrote a post earlyer in this thread that nobody seem to have noticed :
Maybe the "flagged tasks" tweak that 2mc apllied to AF1 can be used with SF3 with the same benefits (and this could be most helpful to those whom have a very long list like Seraphim)
Here it is
http://www.markforster.net/forum/post/1357320Relevant part :
<<Each morning, I review each page (in reverse order - from newest to oldest) and flag any task that stands out by my intuition. I flag the task by placing a see-through Post-It "Arrow" Flag on the task. These tags are great, because they can be easily repositioned and reused. I usually flag 25 items.
I circle through the Flagged tasks – beginning with the first page having a Flag – until I come to one my intuition tells me to do. I do it, remove the flag, place the tag on the inside cover of the notebook, date, strikethrough, and re-enter, if necessary. I then circle through the remaining Flagged tasks in like manner.
If I finish all 25 items, I circle through the entire notebook AF1 style.
>>
3 March 2011 at 0:11 | Daouda
-
Okay I just realized that this implies that the dismissal rules have to be tweaked as well... so it's not "just a flag tweak"... But it might be interesting to experiment with it
3 March 2011 at 0:49 | Daouda
-
Daouda,
Maybe I am wrong, but the early posts along with the statement that there were 1200 things on a list seemed to imply overwhelm and a breakdown, which I just assumed were due to too much to get done. So I assumed something was not working well. Apologies if I had the problem wrong.
Gerry
3 March 2011 at 0:57 | Gerry
-
David Drake -
<<< Sorry, Seraphim. I was not trying to be sarcastic. >>>
I didn't take your comments that way!!! I always appreciate your thoughtful comments. Sorry if there was any misunderstanding.
3 March 2011 at 1:00 | Seraphim
-
Gerry wrote:
<<< Not to be argumentative, but if you do not reduce your commitments the only way you get more work done is to work faster. >>>
Agreed!!
<<< Again I am not sure a system can make you work faster >>>
Sure it can. There are lots of ways that AF and DWM and now SF have helped me work MUCH faster:
+ Stay focused and "in the zone" -- my work is far more effective and productive when I'm working this way, rather than scattered and muddled and super-multi-tasking
+ What can I eliminate? The dismissal process allows me to focus on things that really matter NOW
+ Think more deeply and clearly about my work -- For example, what can I delegate? Delegation can really multiply one's productivity - getting double or triple the results I can get by myself, or even more. The AF systems have really helped me with this.
I'd bet you get some of these benefits from your own systems as well.
3 March 2011 at 1:07 | Seraphim
-
Hi Erik,
<<<I hope this post will be taken in the spirit it is written, I honestly want to give helpful insight. If you feel badgered in any way, please let me know. >>>
I am truly thankful for everyone's posts here, even if I disagree with some of them! I don't feel badgered at all. I'm sorry if I've given any other impression!
I do think it's funny that everyone seems to think having a large number of tasks is such a horrible problem. But like Mark once said, if I didn't have a lots of things to do, I'd be terribly bored. I LIKE doing meaningful work. And thank God, so much of my work really feels meaningful to me. I also feel very thankful to have such a variety of things to do.
<<< The answer is obviously to cycle faster and there are not many solutions. >>>
Yes, I agree the answer is to cycle faster. So far (today), putting urgent things on Next Page C2 has helped a bit. Time will tell if it makes any significant difference.
<<< Also, I'm sorry to say that I still believe you should dismiss the entire page if you didn't work on a C1 item even if you have stricken multiple from having done them earlier. >>>
Maybe you're right. I have entered this as a task on my list, and if it stands out, I'll give your dismissal rule a try.
<<< No matter what happens, you'll have to drop stuff >>>
Why? I don't necessarily come to that conclusion. My goal is equilibrium, not necessarily a smaller list.
<<< Which is the best of these 2 evils?
1 - Going through the list quickly <snip>
2 - Pulling stuff forward, not cycling through the list fast enough <snip> >>>
Clearly the first is best (though I don't see any "evils" there).
3 March 2011 at 1:34 | Seraphim
-
Dear Attorney Daouda,
Thanks for all the moral support! (I hope your fees aren't too high!)
Sorry I didn't respond to your "flagged tasks" post. I remember when Matt posted that. It just seemed like another layer of complexity to me.
Some questions -
1. Why 25 flags? Why not 10? Why not 100?
2. What to do with urgent tasks that arise, if I still have some flagged items left?
3. What to do if I can't get through all the flagged tasks? What if that becomes a chronic problem?
Anyway, questions like that prevented me from trying it.
3 March 2011 at 1:44 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim, great to see how you are taking the advice people give. Not everybody can be as open minded as you :)
As for the "no-evil" thing, it was a figure of speech as well as a wink in the sense that there is no evil there. But after thinking about it, there is the fact that one needs to control some urges,... maybe.
3 March 2011 at 2:06 | Erik
-
Crazy thought here: if the blunt time-based dismissal of DWM was working so well for you (to prevent your ever expanding list problem), couldn't you apply a similar rule to dismiss the oldest pages of SF3?
I'm in the habit (for many, many years now) to always date an empty page when I start writing on it, be it for taking notes or even scribbles. I still do that in SF3 when I start a new page, although purely for information purposes.
It'd be trivial to simply dismiss pages older than a month when picking up the list first thing in the morning.
Just an idea… ;-)
3 March 2011 at 2:35 | Hugo Ferreira
-
Seraphim, congratulations on launching what must be the most popular debate ever on this site! 50+ posts in hours! I'm equally amazed to see such spirited discussion without the negativity. Why isn't the rest of the net like that :-(. On with the discussion!
You just agreed with Erik that it's best to move faster through the list. Then you wrote:
[<<< No matter what happens, you'll have to drop stuff >>>
Why? I don't necessarily come to that conclusion. My goal is equilibrium, not necessarily a smaller list.]
In short, it's because a smaller list is got through faster. A longer list is slower, and not just doubly slow. You have more pages to pass through, AND the length pushes more things into the urgent category, slowing you down and reinforcing the problem.
In other words, a long list strains the system. I think Mark indicated early on that the amount of stuff in C2 (crossed out) tends to correlate with the number of pages in your list.
Or maybe I got that wrong.
Besides the above, I'm coming to the opinion that next-page urgent is the right rule, and that now-urgent doesn't merit a spot in the list unless it's big enough to merit setting aside unfinished after your initial attention.
3 March 2011 at 3:06 | Alan Baljeu
-
I feel as Alan on the debate/positiveness thing :)
As for the urgent going on next page, from the first time I heard of it, I made it mine. It tests the small possibility that I thought it was urgent and in reality, it wasn't. If it was, I'll move to the next page pretty quick. If it wasn't, then I won't have lost time over it at that moment. The next time similar task pops up, I'm sure to put it in C1 from the start.
3 March 2011 at 4:39 | Erik
-
Hugo Ferreira wrote:
<<< Crazy thought here: if the blunt time-based dismissal of DWM was working so well for you (to prevent your ever expanding list problem), couldn't you apply a similar rule to dismiss the oldest pages of SF3? >>>
Yes, I always date my pages too. My oldest SFv3 page is dated 2/7/11. I suppose I could try dismissing anything older than 1 month. I'll add it to Outlook as a reminder in case adding urgent items to C2 on next page doesn't speed things up enough. (I don't want to try too many modifications at the same time!!)
Thanks for the idea!
3 March 2011 at 4:45 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim,
You wrote:
> Sorry I didn't respond to your "flagged tasks" post. I remember
> when Matt posted that. It just seemed like another layer
> of complexity to me.
>
> Some questions -
>
> 1. Why 25 flags? Why not 10? Why not 100?
>
> 2. What to do with urgent tasks that arise, if I still have
> some flagged items left?
>
> 3. What to do if I can't get through all the flagged tasks?
> What if that becomes a chronic problem?
>
> Anyway, questions like that prevented me from trying it.
I just posted a revised method in a thread entitled, "SF3 Alternative." Perhaps it answers some of your questions. Have a look.
Matt
3 March 2011 at 4:49 | 2mc
-
Alan Baljeu wrote:
<<< a smaller list is got through faster. A longer list is slower, and not just doubly slow. You have more pages to pass through, AND the length pushes more things into the urgent category, slowing you down and reinforcing the problem. >>>
Good point. Let's see how small it gets with putting urgent on next page C2.
After 1 month of usage, my original AF1 list had about 500 open tasks, if I remember correctly, which eventually grew to over 1200 (and was still growing). DWM was actually higher than that, leveling off at around 1600 active tasks after a few months of consistent use.
Currently I have 23 active pages and 244 open tasks in my SFv3 list. I'll try to track this and see what happens. Until today, the page count kept growing and growing. Today I moved through 4 pages and added only 1 - generally it's closer to the opposite - so this is good progress. But moving through pages isn't enough -- real progress would be when the active page count starts to level off, or actually decrease.
3 March 2011 at 5:02 | Seraphim
-
Alan Baljeu wrote:
<<< .... now-urgent doesn't merit a spot in the list unless it's big enough to merit setting aside unfinished after your initial attention. >>>
Could you restate that in English please? LOL It sounds like there's a great idea hiding in there but I have no idea what it is. :-)
3 March 2011 at 5:05 | Seraphim
-
2mc wrote:
<<< I just posted a revised method in a thread entitled, "SF3 Alternative." >>>
Good to see you back Matt! I will take a look.
3 March 2011 at 5:06 | Seraphim
-
Alan Baljeu wrote:
<<< congratulations on launching what must be the most popular debate ever on this site! 50+ posts in hours! >>>
Ah, you must not have been here yet when the original AF was launched! "There were giants in the earth in those days..."
<<< I'm equally amazed to see such spirited discussion without the negativity. Why isn't the rest of the net like that :-(. >>>
I think it says a lot about its owner and moderator (Mark Forster of course!). The tone of discussion boards is set by the owner/moderator. The longer I've been on this forum the more I believe that to be true. Many people have come and gone, but the positive tone has remained very consistent and drawn additional people who appreciate it. There are little flare-ups now and then but overall it's a very positive, very helpful, very interesting board.
3 March 2011 at 5:13 | Seraphim
-
<<< .... now-urgent doesn't merit a spot in the list unless it's big enough to merit setting aside unfinished after your initial attention. >>>
Example:
"honey, take the garbage out!" "I will dear!". Depending on family dynamic, you now write as urgent on the next page. It gets done within the hour.
The next week, "honey, the garbage truck is coming down the road!" you immediately run to the door, grab garbage, and bring to curb. Returning to AF, you write nothing.
Week 3. "honey, the garbage is on fire!". You grab the fire extinguisher and kill the fire. Emergency passed, you could immediately finish the job by cleaning up on the spot. Instead, returning to the list, you write next page, "clean up garbage". This was the now-urgent big enough to set aside unfinished.
3 March 2011 at 5:54 | Alan Baljeu
-
Seraphim,
If DWM was working fine with 1600 tasks, how is it a problem that SF is still expanding with less than 250?
What DOES seem to be a problem is that you aren't getting through the list every day. So things which Mark would put in C1 as "later today" need to go in C2, slowing down the system. If this then means that you are invoking common sense rules all the time, I can understand your concern. As you have found, dismissal helps.
If you have an 8 hour working day (HA!!) of which half is taken up by meetings, that gives you about 25 ten minute bursts of action. Or 15 ten minute bursts and 50 two minute bursts. Or... (the parameters will be different for everyone, of course). So it's just a matter of arithmetic as to how many pages you can handle and, therefore, where you need to set your dismissal level. Just keeping your parameters in mind may help.
I am really writing this for myself, as I can feel myself following you to the same situation. I didn't get through my list yesterday.
3 March 2011 at 7:59 | Will
-
Seraphim.
I was speaking literally about how fast one does a task. So if I need to write a report and it takes one hour, if I can do it in 30 minutes, I can then do something else. So in my mind a system can not make us work faster. For me I want my system to make sure I do not forget things (my notebook) which is generally bad for business and make things easy to find so I don't waste time hunting for them (A-Z filing system). I do not expect it to review my commitments, prioritize or dismiss thing.
Gerry
3 March 2011 at 16:01 | Gerry
-
Urrk: seem to have lost the paragraph that I thought was interesting...
Seraphim,
You mention you often find yourself doing a few C1s in between C2s. Is this after some have stood out on their own merits on the first pass, before you looked at the C2s? On coming to a new page, I know that the first task should be either a C1 task or dismissal of all C1 tasks, before I even look at C2. But often I look at the C2s as well. I'm thinking of making a point of covering the C2s on the first pass.
This should help move the "someday maybes" through dismissal more quickly.
Gerry,
I guess we Superfocus users have rather different expectations!.
3 March 2011 at 17:50 | Will
-
Will,
I guess if something has Super in the name it better deliver LOL.
3 March 2011 at 18:21 | Gerry
-
Gerry,
:0D
3 March 2011 at 20:36 | Will
-
Hi Seraphim,
although I sympathize (I'm having trouble getting through the list myself), I can't help thinking this problem should resolve itself when using the system a bit longer. You wrote that you often have to enter C2-tasks a few pages ahead, because at the next page(s) C2 is full. That means, once you manage to reach the end of the list and go back to the first page, you either have to do everything remaining in C1 (not a lot, you said, because you already did most on your first pass), or dismiss the lot. Either way, that's one page less, and this will happen for a lot of pages once you start again on the first page. And because your urgent C2-items will be entered further and further down the list (because your C2's are full :-), you're probably going to dismiss.
At least, that's how I hope it will work out in my case. I'm not processing more than 2 or 3 pages a day, which is too slow, but I hope that once I manage to speed things up (I'll try the suggestion to enter urgent C2-tasks on the next page instead of the current one!) dismissal will kick in.
I had a similar experience when I started to use AF1: initially I crawled through the list, but once I reached the point to dismiss pages, I happily dismissed page after page. I'm hoping it will work out similarly with SF3.
3 March 2011 at 22:31 | Nicole
-
@Will
<<You mention you often find yourself doing a few C1s in between C2s. Is this after some have stood out on their own merits on the first pass, before you looked at the C2s? On coming to a new page, I know that the first task should be either a C1 task or dismissal of all C1 tasks, before I even look at C2. But often I look at the C2s as well. I'm thinking of making a point of covering the C2s on the first pass.>>
I'm confused. When you say the first task "should" are you referring to Mark's rules or your own? If the former then:
I don't see anything in Mark's rules that impose an order-for-action between col 1 and col 2, merely restrictions on when one can move off the current/active page. (i.e. you must have actioned all the col 2 entries, and also you must either have actioned at least one col 1 entry or dismissed all unactioned col 1 entries - exemption from dismissal for the last page - provided it's col 1 is not full).
If my take on the SF3 rules is out of whack please will somebody correct me ;-)
Beauty sleep time.
John Angus
3 March 2011 at 22:34 | John Angus (Anguish)
-
Alan wrote:
<<< "honey, take the garbage out!" >>>
OK, that makes sense now!
4 March 2011 at 1:30 | Seraphim
-
Will wrote:
<<< If DWM was working fine with 1600 tasks, how is it a problem that SF is still expanding with less than 250? >>>
Because I've seen this before with AF. I know that if I can't get that expansion under control, the system will eventually become totally unworkable. I want to get it under control NOW, while it still has a reasonable number of tasks.
<<< If you have an 8 hour working day (HA!!) of which half is taken up by meetings, that gives you about 25 ten minute bursts of action. Or 15 ten minute bursts and 50 two minute bursts. Or... (the parameters will be different for everyone, of course). So it's just a matter of arithmetic as to how many pages you can handle and, therefore, where you need to set your dismissal level. Just keeping your parameters in mind may help. >>>
Yes, this is why I find it helpful to keep some daily metrics - they help with diagnosis.
4 March 2011 at 1:34 | Seraphim
-
Gerry wrote:
<<< I do not expect it to review my commitments, prioritize or dismiss things. >>>
Then I suppose we have different expectations for our TM systems.
Thanks again - sincerely - for your sensible ideas!
4 March 2011 at 1:37 | Seraphim
-
Will wrote:
<<< On coming to a new page, I know that the first task should be either a C1 task or dismissal of all C1 tasks, before I even look at C2. >>>
Where do you see that rule? I just double-checked and don't see that in the SF rules.
<<< You mention you often find yourself doing a few C1s in between C2s. Is this after some have stood out on their own merits on the first pass, before you looked at the C2s? >>>
Just for the sake of clarity, here is what I do when processing a new page (I think it's mostly just standard SF):
+ Write the date in the top margin (so I know when I visited a page)
+ Draw a line at the end of the list of C2 items (to emphasize that this is a "closed list" since I am testing the urgent-tasks-go-in-C2-next-page variant)
+ Read through the entire page (both columns) (crossing off all items that are already done and not counting these for the purpose of determining whether C1 tasks get dismissed - thanks Erik!)
+ Start back at the top of the C1 page, and start reading through the whole page (both C1 and C2), reading each item carefully, and taking action on whatever stands out. Sometimes none of the C1 items stand out at first -- meaning, the first thing that stands out happens to be in C2.
+ If I ever take action on anything in C1, then I put a checkmark next to today's date at the top of the page -- meaning this page is saved from dismissal.
+ When I come to the bottom of C2, I have to decide if I am DONE with the page or not:
+ If I took any action on any tasks in either column, then I am NOT DONE, and start cycling through the page again from top of C1.
+ If there are ANY items in C2, then I am NOT DONE, and must start cycling through the page again, from the top of C1.
+ If all the C2 tasks are crossed out, and I did not take any action on any items on the page on that pass, I am DONE. I then check whether I took action on anything in C1 during this visit to the page. If NO, then all C1 items are dismissed and the page is closed.
+ Then, I move on to the next page.
Does that answer your question? :-)
4 March 2011 at 1:58 | Seraphim
-
Nicole -
<<< I had a similar experience when I started to use AF1: initially I crawled through the list, but once I reached the point to dismiss pages, I happily dismissed page after page. I'm hoping it will work out similarly with SF3. >>>
Thanks for the thoughtful suggestions. Maybe you are right.
When I was using AF1, after awhile it got to the point where I was chasing the end of the list, day after day, week after week, never arriving there, never cycling back to the beginning of the list at all. New pages were always being added faster than I could process them. As a result, nothing ever got a chance to be dismissed.
Now, it is moving a little faster, and I think you are right, many of those full pages that are still sitting there in the earlier part of my list will get dismissed right away. I do think that will help. But my main fear is, if I can't get the list expansion under control, I'll end up chasing the end of the list like I did in AF1.
4 March 2011 at 2:03 | Seraphim
-
I think it Might help if you tweak your inner Definition of standout to be slightly more stingy. You'll do a little less per page, and move forward a little faster. Eventually you'll reach that end :-)
4 March 2011 at 2:42 | Alan Baljeu
-
Seraphim,
Oops: I can't find it either. must be an earlier version of superfocus (or possibly the late version of me, approaching senility.)
I still think it would be an interesting tweak, but it's too early for tweaks.
THANK YOU for the daily check-off: I'm sure I've let a few pages live because, working on C2 I've lost track of whether I've done any C1s. (Spot the inconsistency here!)
Alan's point is spot on, of course.
4 March 2011 at 6:39 | Will
-
Checkoff: I suppose this is why my habit is to usually start C1, so I don't forget to do 1.
4 March 2011 at 12:23 | Alan Baljeu
-
Very good habit Alan!
4 March 2011 at 14:16 | Erik
-
Seraphim, if you are endlessly chasing after the end of your list without ever reaching the end, you might go through it the other way round: starting at the end and progressing towards the beginning, from where you start again at the last open page. Then you get a chance for dismissing. In that case, the next C2 for unfinishe will be on the previous page.
Wolfgang
4 March 2011 at 15:10 | wowi
-
wowi - Hmm! Interesting idea. I tend to get dizzy working lists backwards (I HATED AF2) but maybe I'll try this if the other simpler adjustments don't work out.
Alan - I suppose I could ask, "Does this REALLY stand out?" Or, "I mean REALLY REALLY stand out???" "Does this task jump off the page, waving its arms and DEMANDING to be done?" "Do I actually HEAR this task speaking to me???" LOL Maybe I'll try it. I could use a vacation. :-)
(You do have a good point, I am just having fun with it.) :-)
4 March 2011 at 16:38 | Seraphim
-
Alan - <<< Checkoff: I suppose this is why my habit is to usually start C1, so I don't forget to do 1. >>>
I start with Column 1, too. That's not the problem, for me. The problem is that, since there are almost always 1-3 tasks that are already done when I come to a new page, and I simply cross them out, I have a hard time remembering exactly when the task got crossed off. Was it THIS visit, or a PREVIOUS visit? That's why I started using the checkoff.
4 March 2011 at 16:40 | Seraphim
-
I hear you. For me, of course it was this visit because if I got to the end of C1 and didn't pick anything, I'd doublecheck and if I STILL don't pick anything, I immediately mark the page dismissed. Then I go to C2.
So if C1 isn't dismissed, I must have found something.
4 March 2011 at 17:49 | Alan Baljeu
-
Alan wrote:
<<< For me, of course it was this visit because if I got to the end of C1 and didn't pick anything, I'd doublecheck and if I STILL don't pick anything, I immediately mark the page dismissed. Then I go to C2. >>>
Of course you can do it that way if you like, but that's not how the rules are written. Dismissal doesn't occur till it's actually time to turn the page.
4 March 2011 at 19:30 | Seraphim
-
I like. It's not technically correct but it's practically the same, and easier for me.
4 March 2011 at 21:24 | Alan Baljeu
-
Seraphim,
Can I take it that talking to us is a C2 task for you? I am flattered. (And working off-list. Mea culpa, mea maxima culpa, etc.)
5 March 2011 at 15:41 | Will
-
Will - <<< Can I take it that talking to us is a C2 task for you? I am flattered. >>>
It always starts out as a C1 task. But then after a while I need a break from everything else, a mental break more than anything, and so I move it into C2 as an "urgent" task. That's usually what happens, anyway. :-)
<<< (And working off-list. Mea culpa, mea maxima culpa, etc.) >>>
For shame!!! LOL
5 March 2011 at 15:54 | Seraphim
-
<<It always starts out as a C1 task. But then after a while I need a break from everything else, a mental break more than anything, and so I move it into C2 as an "urgent" task. That's usually what happens, anyway. :-) >>
Moving stuff to urgent this way IS the reason you go slow through the system, don't do it. It goes to urgent not if you want to but if it HAS to be done. A better way would be to always put at least one of those breaks on each page in C1. You'll always have an escape from the drudgery.
6 March 2011 at 3:24 | Erik
-
Erik:
<<A better way would be to always put at least one of those breaks on each page in C1. You'll always have an escape from the drudgery.>>
I've started to sort of do this. Not in any organized fashion, but I notice that I like C1 to have a variety of things...outdoor things...indoor things...cleaning things...project-y things...organizational thing...research-y things, etc.
This, however, leads to something I've typed and deleted a few times.
If I do task X and after doing it, I also do tasks Y and Z, but they are a page or two ahead in my system...and they're the type of thing that when it's done it gets re-entered, according to 'the letter of the law' am I supposed to cross these out and re-enter or not.
This is one way that I'm sort of doing what Erik suggests. I look at the page that Y and Z are on and I look at the last active page. I decide where I feel my system is better served with Y and Z living for the moment, and leave them or cross off or move them accordingly.
What do others think of this?
6 March 2011 at 4:01 | malisa
-
I think Seraphim's approach is actually closer to the rules.
These are important questions.
6 March 2011 at 10:42 | Will
-
Melisa, I propose writing Xyz as one item instead of 3 separate. Then it becomes correct to continue one to the next.
6 March 2011 at 17:32 | Alan Baljeu
-
Erik wrote:
<<< Moving stuff to urgent this way IS the reason you go slow through the system, don't do it. It goes to urgent not if you want to but if it HAS to be done. >>>
I think we disagree on this one. "Urgent" is defined by the person who owns the list. :-) I like Mark's definition the best: "you want to get to it before you would in the normal processing of the list".
Yes, it probably makes the system go slower. But it's completely within the bounds of the rules, and a completely natural application of the rules. Rather than change the rules and their "feel", I'd prefer to find other ways to make the the system go faster. The whole reason I prefer SF over DWM is that sense of freedom and "working in the zone", which DWM doesn't preserve nearly as well.
6 March 2011 at 19:57 | Seraphim
-
Malisa wrote:
<<< If I do task X and after doing it, I also do tasks Y and Z, but they are a page or two ahead in my system...and they're the type of thing that when it's done it gets re-entered, according to 'the letter of the law' am I supposed to cross these out and re-enter or not. >>>
Malisa, can you give an example? It's hard for me envision what you're doing here.
6 March 2011 at 19:58 | Seraphim
-
This is my home list. One example:
-Pick up yard (dogs)
-Remove honey locust trees (we have one big one but 'suckers' pop up all over and they have nasty thorns)
-Gather items in yard (we have a big yard that has been neglected and I want to pick up tools, sprinkler parts, broken bird feeders, etc.)
By entering these as single lines rather than something more big and overwhelming, I'm actually doing them. I could enter something more generic 'do some work in yard', but that hasn't worked in the past, so I don't want to do that. The dog-related task has to be done more regularly, but the others if I do them once a week or so, I'm okay. I don't want them on some other checklist because they'll get glossed over. This is working for me.
I did all three of these during the day yesterday when I hit 'pick up yard' on the list (got on a roll out there). The other two items were a page or two back. I got to those pages last night. I couldn't do the yard type stuff at night. I could have left them for the next cycle through. But that leaves old pages open longer with just an item or two on them (that was the case with one of them...crossing it out and moving it ahead allowed me to close a page).
I'll probably still do whatever common-sense tells me is right for me and my list at the particular time that something like this occurs, but I'm trying to make sure that I consider the consequences that I may not have thought of.
6 March 2011 at 20:28 | malisa
-
Malisa -
That's what I would do also. If I come to a page and it has a recurring item that I've already finished for one reason or another, I cross it out and re-enter at the end of the list (or wait till it gets triggered again by an Outlook reminder).
6 March 2011 at 22:04 | Seraphim
-
I agree. Do as much as you like. Cross off the list later when you find the item.
7 March 2011 at 1:10 | Alan Baljeu
-
Might I point out that Rules exist to make sure the mechanics of a system are respected from one individual to the next. They are a way to describe an abstract concept in manageable thoughts. Thus the spirit of a rule is actually the system and how it is meant to move to achieve optimum performance. No matter how precise a rule is, you will never understand it if you do not understand the reason that drove the creation of the rule in the first place.
All Autofocus systems are like a gear. With the gear itself being the entire list and all the (I don't know the term in english) teeth being the equivalent of the pages. There are actually 2 different kinds of revolutions inside the system. The first one is obviously the cycling through a page. This makes you work on that stuff a lot but keeps you from going forward. You are stuck in 1st gear in a car or on a bike if you will. It is powerful and you can climb mountains but you won't go fast anywhere.
The second is the cycling through all the system. It takes more time to go through one iteration of the loop but the mileage on it is quite considerable. For long span projects, this use of the system is quite effective. It is equivalent to being in 5th gear on your car or 3rd speed on your bicycle.
Notice the gap?
If you want to go for the mileage, you have to get out of first gear.
Now Superfocus answered a crucial problem,... It's hard to go from 1st gear to 5th gear.
If you have say the 3rd gear of a car or the second speed of a bike, then the transition is easier and more automatic. Superfocus does this with the second column. It let's you bring an item forward with you to the next page (third type of loop). That loop has the power of the first kind of loop and the mileage of the second type of loop.
Seraphim, you are stuck in 1st gear, there is no other way to go faster then to shift gear! And I'm sorry to say that longer pages will only give you longer second columns, it will most probably cripple you more then help. Try 10 lines per page, you'll go through fast enough and won't put stuff C2 that much, and if you do, you'll only dismiss stuff (that's cool). That's at least what a friend of mine has tried recently and it works great...
Last thing...
Things you put in your list are your commitments. They change depending on situation and environment. If you have a big list and taking a cup of coffee is something important to you, the longer the list, the less often you will get to it. You can absolutely and reasonably have the commitment of taking 3 cups of coffee while you cycle your system once!
7 March 2011 at 2:02 | Erik
-
<<I think we disagree on this one. "Urgent" is defined by the person who owns the list. :-) I like Mark's definition the best: "you want to get to it before you would in the normal processing of the list". >>
Agreed, but you are already going too slow through your list and that skews the definition of when you get to the item. It only acerbate the problem. I don't say not to pull stuff if you feel like it but just think twice on what it will do to the system. It's like pulling cars on the highway from the in-way on rush hour. A jam is the only result that can happen!!!
7 March 2011 at 2:09 | Erik
-
Erik wrote:
<<< And I'm sorry to say that longer pages will only give you longer second columns, it will most probably cripple you more then help. >>>
Here is the reasoning why longer pages should help the system move faster.
(1) It makes the page count shorter. This makes it easier to cycle through the pages. The last page with the newest tasks is only 1-2 pages away, rather than 4-5 pages away. This reduces the urge to put things in C2, since I'm more likely to get to them pretty soon anyway "in the normal process of working the system."
(2) C2 does not fill as quickly. This reduces pressure to finish C1 tasks in one go -- which reduces the tendency of C1 tasks to "stand out". With smaller pages, that pressure from C2 filling up is very strong, making it much more likely for C1 tasks to stand out, which slows down the overall progress.
(3) The stress on C2 from (1) and (2), above, is reduced, which means subsequent pages also have fewer C2 items to deal with.
(4) Fewer C2 items means that you don't cycle each page as many times, which further reduces the number of C1 items that stand out, which further speeds up the cycling through the overall list.
I've only just begun using a notebook with longer pages, so I don't know how it will work out in practice, but the reasoning (inspired by Bob Pankratz's post at
http://www.markforster.net/forum/post/1424127 ) makes sense to me.
<<< Try 10 lines per page, you'll go through fast enough and won't put stuff C2 that much, and if you do, you'll only dismiss stuff (that's cool). That's at least what a friend of mine has tried recently and it works great... >>>
Yes, I can see how it can force you to dismiss things faster, especially through C2 filling up quickly. But that's not the ideal way for dismissal to happen. Dismissal is more useful when it happens after repeated exposure to the task -- and failure to act despite the repeated exposure. If your list is dominated by stuff that is "maybe I'd like to do this someday" kinds of tasks, then perhaps fast dismissal is OK. But my list doesn't have a lot of that kind of task in it.
<<< Things you put in your list are your commitments. >>>
No, not really.
It's a list of everything I feel I must do, should do, would like to do, or someday/maybe would like to do, or things I am not sure how important or urgent they are yet.
It includes not only tasks but ideas to explore; notes from meetings that need more thought before action can be defined; etc.
Back in the AF1 days we often joked on the forum that you could put anything from "walk the dog" or "clip your nails" to "start a company" or "conquer the world", and the list would process it effectively.
Not everything in life is necessarily attached to a commitment. Putting it on my list actually helps me decide whether or not it is something to which I should make a commitment.
<<< If you have a big list and taking a cup of coffee is something important to you, the longer the list, the less often you will get to it. You can absolutely and reasonably have the commitment of taking 3 cups of coffee while you cycle your system once! >>>
I'm not sure what your point is here, but here are my thoughts - I hope they are relevant.
If I were thinking of grabbing a cup of coffee, but it was more than a 30-second exercise to do so, I'd write it in Column 2 and act when it stood out. Or perhaps I'd go when my coworkers stop by and ask if I'd like to walk down to the cafeteria for a coffee break.
If I were addicted to coffee, and trying to limit my intake, I'd be more likely to add it to Column 1 and try not to act on it unless it stood out -- but if it were just driving me crazy I'd add it in Column 2 and act on it when it stood out.
7 March 2011 at 5:27 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim
Sorry for the brusk replies, I try to do this fast today.
<<I'm not sure what your point is here, but here are my thoughts - I hope they are relevant.>>
The relevance is between the first thing I said and the second. Please don't separate them or take to the word what I said as commitment. Say it's something you may want to do if you want. What I wanted to say is that you can have 2 times a recurring task in your system without it being a problem.
<<Dismissal is more useful when it happens after repeated exposure to the task>>
I agree but not while cycling inside the same page a number of times. If you cycle a page 15 times before going to the next, the exposure is just once.With 10 lines per pages, if you act on 1 item on each page on each pass, you will get much better exposure in my mind. And dismiss will happen not as often as you might imagine. We actually tried it at 5 lines per page for a week for him to get the feel of the mechanics and the flow of the system and then ramped it up a notch. The real benefit is that C2 is almost not used or just when REALLY needed.
7 March 2011 at 9:25 | Erik
-
Hi Erik,
<<< What I wanted to say is that you can have 2 times a recurring task in your system without it being a problem. >>>
No argument there.
<<< If you cycle a page 15 times before going to the next, the exposure is just once. >>>
That's not how it works in my experience. Often, nothing in C1 stands out when I first read through the page. But something in C2 stands out. Then I cycle through C1 and C2 again, and now, reading C1 for a second time this visit, some of the resistance has broken down, and one or two things in C1 stand out. I keep cycling, and with each cycle, the repeated exposure does tend to decrease the resistance and increase the likelihood of something standing out.
<<< With 10 lines per pages, if you act on 1 item on each page on each pass, you will get much better exposure in my mind. >>>
I suppose this could work if you add a new rule, "Act on no more than 1 item in C1 during each visit to the page." I don't think it works so well if you follow the original rules, "Keep cycling through the page till nothing else stands out."
I'll add this to my "things to try" but it seems like a pretty big change to the original rules.
8 March 2011 at 0:41 | Seraphim
-
You might be pleasantly pleased :)
(I don't advocate a rule to do just one thing per page,. In my experience, the normal rules are perfect for a 10 lines book)
8 March 2011 at 7:11 | Erik
-
Seraphim, Erik,
"1 item on each page"
You don't have to change the rules, if you can just set this expectation in your mind. Then you should find that things don't stick out so much. But if a couple of things do stick out, you still work on them.
8 March 2011 at 8:44 | Will
-
Yeah, but Seraphim prefers hard rules.
8 March 2011 at 12:03 | Erik
-
Seraphim if you want longer pages and this is just a suggestion mind you then its easy enough to do. All you have to do is to ignore the pages in your book and make a virtual page every time you finish the list and move back to the beginning by drawing a line across the page. So what happens basically is that you get a new page every time you pass through the list. From what I've heard from reaeding your posts that should give you a LOT longer pages. And its self adjusting because if you are moving very slowly that gives you a few long pages and if you are moving fast that gives you a lot of short pages so the end of the list is about the same distance away if you see what I mean. And you could use this with AF1 or with SF.
8 March 2011 at 15:10 | Meryl
-
Quite a sensible idea Meryl!
9 March 2011 at 0:03 | Erik
-
Meryl -- Interesting idea, it reminds me of AF4, a little bit. I'll have to think about this one some more.
9 March 2011 at 5:56 | Seraphim
-
Yeah, it's basically that concept.
Do you remember how things went with AF4 Seraphim?
9 March 2011 at 13:06 | Erik
-
Erik:
<<< Do you remember how things went with AF4 Seraphim? >>>
Yes, for me it was basically the same as AF1 - ever-growing list, always chasing the end of the list, once I broke out out the "Backlog"/"Closed List" it would be days or weeks before I entered it again. I think I had left it behind for over a month when DWM came along and I started using that instead.
9 March 2011 at 17:36 | Seraphim
-
Congrats on the essay!
I'd like an update about this thread's situation...
From the essay, I gather that you dismiss more then before and have eliminated a lot of "less then necessary" stuff or am I totally off track?
17 March 2011 at 23:02 | Erik
-
Short answer: I haven't had to invoke any "common sense" rules in a long time -- at least a couple of weeks.
Long answer: See below. :-)
So far, I decided to go back to ALL the original SF rules and follow them strictly. (I was trying for a couple weeks to enter urgent items in C2 on the next page, to try to get the system to go faster; but I have stopped doing that, mostly.)
The only real change I implemented was to use a larger notebook. This does seem to make progress through the book proceed more quickly, and helps prevent C2 overload. (I miss being able to carry the notebook in my pocket, however.)
I did start dismissing more, but this hasn't really been a conscious effort. It started happening because I realized that I could try to follow the SF rules strictly at all times -- even when I'm sick and would normally just cherry-pick a few things to do. This realization somehow freed me to strictly follow the "standing out" rules at all times, and dismiss whenever the rules say to dismiss.
I'm still having trouble "chasing the end of the list" and moving slowly -- but it's not too bad, not anywhere near as bad as it was with AF1 or AF4. I've only got 11 active pages which is probably about 250 active tasks. When I was this far into it with AF1/AF4, I already had at least 800 tasks.
Part of this is because SF is just better. Part of it is that I've learned better habits as a result of using all of Mark's systems (thus increasing my brain power, as per Mark's recent blog post!).
To answer your question, "have you eliminated a lot of 'less then necessary' stuff" -- I think I put in just as much ideas and random thoughts and odds and ends as I always have. Some of them get processed more quickly -- especially if they are rather large in scope and/or require creative energy -- I move those into Outlook reminders set for 3 months from now, since I am just too busy at work to deal with them right now and I don't even want to see them in SF.
Anyway this is kind of long but I hope it answers your questions. And I hope you are doing OK in Japan!! :-)
18 March 2011 at 2:25 | Seraphim
-
Hey, I'm glad this thread just bubbled to the top of the forum, where I am seeing it for the first time. I actually read the *entire* thing.
Seraphim, thank you for sharing so much of your experience in so much detail and being such a willing troubleshooting subject right out in public. I too am impressed at how well the dialog went and how constructive it has remained.
Though I have never had even close to 1200 tasks, my progression learning SF has been similar to yours, and it looks like you and I have similar personality types. Tweaks that I think of trying, you often have already tried and reported on. It is very encouraging to see that you are now following the rules strictly and finding the system more effective.
Today I realized that my "today list" has begun to harbor things that really ought to be in C1. This began as my pace through the list lagged, and I began to feel anxious about the pages I haven't seen in a while. So, I started to resist writing things in C1 if they are "kind of urgent," for fear they would disappear for too long. I am now realizing that this is a message from SF: "you are moving to slowly through the list (and going off-book too much!); put everything in the system, be more selective on each page, and work littler and more often."
I just finished moving these things back into C1, and I am going to let that anxiety affect my feeling of "ready to be done," hoping it will pull me through the list. If I'm so anxious about being stuck on this page that I'm not writing new items in C1, then I guess nothing on this page is really "ready to be done," eh?
That's a little tricky for me, because I tend to have a pretty warped sense of time, thinking that a thing will take ten minutes but then spending over an hour on it (ahem, it is nearly 1:30 am here as I write this). I can't expect any time management system to fix that for me automatically, but SF is the first to push me to take it seriously (that is, not blame it on "too much to do" or say, "well that's just how I am"); instead, I am really wanting to work on it now and feeling like the payoff will be worth it. I once had some success to this end with time boxing, so I will get my timer out again tomorrow.
Despite my struggles with C1/C2/etc., this is an example of why I am so happy with SF. SF's feedback is incredibly concrete and useful and constructive, much more so than other systems I have used. When things go wrong, I feel like I am actually learning something rather than simply failing, and the fix (i.e., being more selective on each page) is something I can visualize doing without undue pain or resistance.
Thank you to everyone who invested time in this thread.
18 March 2011 at 7:41 | Bernie
-
<< Seraphim, thank you for sharing so much of your experience in so much detail >>
It's a good learning experience, and everyone has so many good ideas!
<< I too am impressed at how well the dialog went and how constructive it has remained. >>
Yes, this forum has always been like that -- it's great!
<< it looks like you and I have similar personality types. >>
I also got that impression from many of your posts -- they really resonate with me. :-)
<< It is very encouraging to see that you are now following the rules strictly and finding the system more effective. >>
Yes I am encouraged by that too. :-)
<< Today I realized that my "today list" has begun to harbor things that really ought to be in C1. >>
The whole "today list" idea still hasn't "stood out" so I am continuing to happily abuse C2 with my daily recurring tasks. :-)
<< I am now realizing that this is a message from SF: "you are moving to slowly through the list (and going off-book too much!); put everything in the system, be more selective on each page, and work littler and more often." >>
I'm still not so sure I know what to do when SF sends me a message like that. I guess I'll have to wait and see if SF can continue to teach me better habits. I can still very easily spend all day working a single page. Trying to work littler and more often doesn't always make sense.
<< If I'm so anxious about being stuck on this page that I'm not writing new items in C1, then I guess nothing on this page is really "ready to be done," eh? >>
For me, it's the opposite. TOO MANY of the items in C1 are standing out -- that's why I get stuck on a single page. And the longer I remain there, the more things stand out. The building pressure of the growing number of new pages helps prevent things from standing out, but not enough to counter-balance the tasks that are right in front of me.
<< That's a little tricky for me, because I tend to have a pretty warped sense of time, thinking that a thing will take ten minutes but then spending over an hour on it >>
Yeah, I have that problem too. :-)
Anyone know how to build a negative gravitational field of relativistic proportions? I'd like the rest of the universe to slow down while I get caught up. :-)
<< I can't expect any time management system to fix that for me automatically >>
Hm, the contrarian in me immediately says, "Oh yeah? Prove it!!" :-)
It makes me wonder if there's anything a minor rule adjustment might be able to do that would make us more aware of the passing time...
For a few weeks, I'd start a countdown timer every time I started a new task in DWM (or was it SF already? can't remember). I'd set it for 20 minutes. I just could NOT believe how fast that 20 minutes would fly by. After a few weeks it did help to give me a better sense of time, and a greater sense of urgency in getting right into the new tasks and not dilly-dallying around it.
It's not really a rule adjustment but it's a useful technique nonetheless. Maybe I could just write the starting time next to each task in the SF notebook when I start it and get a feel for the time expenditure that way.
<< SF's feedback is incredibly concrete and useful and constructive, much more so than other systems I have used. When things go wrong, I feel like I am actually learning something rather than simply failing >>
Yes, this is a big reason why I like SF (and Mark's other AF systems) so much.
19 March 2011 at 0:52 | Seraphim
-
Because you asked! :-) I've never tried anything like this with Autofocuses before, but it could work:
"It makes me wonder if there's anything a minor rule adjustment might be able to do that would make us more aware of the passing time... "
The Pomodoro rule tweak for SF:
The infamous tomoato timer system has you work 25 minutes, break 5, repeat 3 more times for two hours of productive work. After 4 tomatoes of work you celebrate or something.
So in SF with a Pomodoro tweak, you must turn the page after 4 tomatoes or less. If after 3 you've got lots of c2s around, the last Pomo will focus on moving each of them forward so you can escape. You may turn the page long before 4 periods are up. Restart the count on the next page.
Have fun (or go nuts)!
19 March 2011 at 2:17 | Alan Baljeu
-
Hi Seraphim
I just red your post and wish to answer about a major point.
I won't give any lesson. I am just a learner. But some events in my life gave my some good lessons I would share with you. May be it will help you and some others and I received so much from many of you that it's the less I could do.
You seems "over committed'
There could be 2 reason one because your boss want to slave you more and more, second because you'r a serious man and so you want to do your best.
Let me tell you a story. 5 years ago I was working in a big French assurance company and did my best for my job. I worked harder and harder. Did my best, took all commitments possible and finally i was fired not because I was inefficient but because I needed too much for others. It was hard for me but I decided to create my own company and since I did, it is a success. But this time the rules were said by myself then they were more difficult to realize. The situation began little by little very hard to control. Then I discovered GTD and later MF site. I thought this was the end of my problem. But no.
Anyway with the help of all what I read here and everywhere I now understand 2 or 3 things it's not much and it's the common sense but I am going to share it with you.
1. You are not Superman. Do your best but not more
2. Think to you first and after to others. What could you do without health ? You won't be able to serve others. Then be good and love you first. Then you will be able to give to other and love them.
3. SF, GTD are systems. There are interesting but no enough. You must think first to the nature of your work and find solution to make others working for you. I red somewhere that someone dismissed the same tasks all the time in SF. He suddenly realized that he Hated this activity. So he delegated it to a friend who loved it and it was a success. We are not good in everything, accept it and try to give and receive from others.
4. Remember Pareto 80 % of the success is done with 20% of action. So you spend 80% of your time doing nothing useful but you must do it if you want to reach the 20%. But may be you can do better. I recently realized that there are 2 kinds of task actionable and not actionable. I wrote some threads about this. (ie MF site - context GTD). I put all my actionable tasks on SF and the Non actionable task in Omnifocus it's much better. One time I will spend 80% of my time on the 20% and will increase my success.
5. Remember the golden rule choosing is trashing. Use Dismiss if you can't do something there is a raison. Dismiss too everywhere. Trash a lot it's your best friend after your wife and your dog. LOL. If you suddenly die what will be left ? Nothing. When I realized that I changed my life and my behavior with others. I now live a rich life even I have like others many difficulties but I have the real feeling of living. Doing many tasks sometime is only a way to forget our own weakness among the universe.
So carefully choose your tasks, don't let people decide for you, think regularly about what you are and where you want to go, and try to make the best choice for controlling your life and not being controlled by it and see it in perspective.
The rule of life is quiet unfair. You know you'r here but no for how long.
Nobody knows what time is left.
So live your life, do the wright things and even if you die at 150 years old spent each day as it would be the last and make the right choice in every domains.
19 March 2011 at 10:45 | FocusGuy.
-
Great post, Jupiter, and lots of good advice. Thanks very much -- I really appreciate it!
20 March 2011 at 3:43 | Seraphim
-
<<The Pomodoro rule tweak for SF ...
Have fun (or go nuts)!>>
Alan, I think it will be "go nuts" for me!
I do like timers, though for me their main value comes by insulating me from the clock. If I have four hours before I need to pick up my son, for example, I may set the timer for two and dive into something. I can *completely* forget about time, because the timer is watching my back, and I know I'll have plenty of time left to deal with whatever else is on my list.
My brief Pomodoro experiment was excruciating, mostly due to the tiny 25 minute window. The timer too often rang when I was really getting something done and had no need to stop, so it seemed counterproductive. But I could imagine a more relaxed version of Pomodoro working for me. It would definitely have longer blocks (45 minutes at least!) and would be less rigid about counting them up.
21 March 2011 at 17:12 | Bernie
-
I'm trying a new experiment - starting a timer for the PAGE, not for the task.
If I have 13 pages and about 10 hours per day of time working the list, that gives about 45 minutes per page (MAX) to get through the whole list once/day.
I just started doing this today and it's been pretty weird -- I am getting through the pages MUCH faster than usual, and generally in 20 minutes or less. I also find that I naturally gravitate toward the C2 tasks and knock most of them out quickly, then act on a few C1 tasks, then linger on any remaining C2 tasks as long as I want.
I like this MUCH better than using Pomodoro on a per-task basis. That never worked for me at all.
It's just the first day that I'm doing this, but since it's working so well and seemed to be relevant, I thought I'd mention it...
21 March 2011 at 23:38 | Seraphim
-
Seraphim:
<< I'm trying a new experiment - starting a timer for the PAGE, not for the task. >>
I just came across this old post of yours while looking for something else. How did it pan out?
16 February 2022 at 10:51 | Mark Forster
-
Hi Mark -
Wow, so many interesting old discussions. Fascinating how the themes recur in different forms.
I don't remember how that experiment played out in the end. But I am finding myself doing something similar with my AF4R experiment. I have my three page types -- New, Unfinished, and Recurring. There are days when I find myself getting pulled into one category of tasks, and the other categories are neglected. For example, I may have a lot of Unfinished tasks, and I might inadvertently focus on them exclusively, with the result that I fall behind on my inboxes, or neglect urgent tasks on my New list.
So I have been trying the following --
-- I set a time limit (maybe 30-60 minutes) to get through whatever category of pages I am working on.
-- I do an FV-style task selection within those pages, and try to pace my work so that I get all the selected tasks completed within the time limit.
-- After the time expires, I stop and move on to the next page type.
For example, I might start the day with 30 minutes dedicated to the Unfinished tasks, and select three of those tasks to work on. When the timer is done, I move on to the New tasks, and set the timer again. Then move on to the Recurring tasks, and set the timer again.
This helps to get things moving and give an appropriate balance to the different kinds of tasks. It gives me a good sense of the work of the day.
I don't always use the timer. After I have a good pace and a good sense of what I want to get done that day, I stop using the timer.
21 February 2022 at 6:07 | Seraphim